I checked them out because I'd never heard of them. I got excited about the prices...and then i found out that those were for digital cards, and the real ones weren't any cheaper than where I'd been searching. I was disappointed.
Always my go to when searching for cards, always quality service. Today I sold my collection, took less than a day for the deal to be done. If I plan on returning to MTGO, they would be my first choice to shop from.
Sold a $500 USD collection over the weekend. Fast and courteous. I even messed up my password that I had given and they reached out on a Sunday evening to confirm. Would definitely use again!
Just sold what I had bought into on MTGO to them ($80-100) 4.5 hour turnaround on a small order the day of the B&R update?! Even for my notoriously impatient self that's great. Quite a fair offer, which with their Cape Fear Games store credit option was just enough for an SOI box. Now if only I had a time machine or lived closer to them...
Only suggestion is that there needs to be a better way to transfer the digital cards - as a new guy it felt kind of sketchy, but apparently that's just how it's done.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Standard: I'm a control player at heart, but going with Boros Allied Equipment this Standard
Modern: Love my Goblins, but want to build Merfolk
Utterly terrible at all things limited
I've been a customer of MTGOTraders.com for a long time. Today, I sold my collection to them. Farewell, Magic Online, you were good. You were the best. You used to be the best.
Never had any problems with them at all since the beginning.
Edit: By "them," I mean MTGO Traders, not Magic Online.
Very quick and professional sale. I chose to sell to MTGOTraders because I've made some orders from them in the past when I was still grinding mtgo a bit. Would definitely sell again.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Standard
:symg::symw::symu:Birthing Pod:symu::symw::symg:
MTGOTraders provided the best offer for my MTGO collection between half a dozen places. On top of that, the cards were transferred and I had received my money via wire transfer within an hour of accepting their offer. I already felt confident selling to them due to the large amount of positive reviews they've received here, but I was still surprised by how quickly and professionally everything was done. Would absolutely sell to them again.
MTGOTraders are one of the few legit organizations on MTGO. They offer fair prices for both buying and selling, never stooping low enough to gouge people.
I sold my online collection to them and it was the easiest thing ever. If I ever get back into MTGO, I'll only go through them.
Sold my online collection and got the best offer of 5 different buyers, they quoted within 24h and after i replied with the agreement email in less than 20min I got payed Thanks guys.
I was soliciting quotes from 7 top bot chains on MTGO for my collection once I knew I wasn't ever going to really play on it again. Only 3 stores ever got back to me with a quote, and my quote here was by far the most generous and gave me a 3-day window to collect quotes from other stores.
My contact with MTGO Traders was Gustavo, and he proved why his company was the best. I have bought my cards online from many vendors, but this was definitely one of my top choices when I played regularly. I'm very happy to say that my 'final' transaction only cemented this reputation for excellence. I never felt too scared selling my 13-year-old account thanks to the and crystal-clear instructions and communication. The options for payment were numerous, convenient, and generous. My major concerns were answered immediately, as an experienced company understands this process better than anyone else. Gustavo even let me know that he'd set me up for the Momir Vig format if I ever had the MODO itch. I can't recommend these guys highly enough.
Got quotes from a couple different places for my small MTGO collection (Mostly just Khan's block stuff) and MTGOTrader had the best offer. Gustavo was my contact and was super quick to get a quote back (less than a day) and less than 30 minutes to respond to my questions. I don't plan on playing much Magic Online anymore but would recommend MTGO Trader for any transaction.
EDH/Commander is a social format, right? So why don't people use their social skills to discuss what they like and don't like, instead of adopting a list with 60+ banned cards?
Recently sold my collection to them (again) for a large sum. Received my check in the mail as promised! The cards were removed out of my account within an hour of my email.
Would do it again (once I get sucked back in after v5 maybe, v4 is still garbage)
I've bought from MTGO Traders bot network many times during my course of playing Magic Online with no problems whatsoever.
I decided recently to trade MTGO for Hearthstone and sold my collection back to them. Was a little apprehensive to begin with, but their price was right and their reputation as one of the large/not shady Magic Online vendors was enough to push the button on selling. Pretty painless. I got a quote from them 2 days after I first contacted them. When I accepted, the cards were gone and the money wired within the hour.
I recently did a collection sale to MTGO Traders and had a great experience. I did a combo of taking store credit and a check. I'd also like to state that my experience with their B&M operation who I have credit with now has been excellent.
Created an account to post my positive feedback for Gustavo and the team at MTGO Traders. I've used their bots plenty of times with no issues and felt reasonably confident offloading my full collection with them. The entire process took about 7 days, from submitting my collection .csv file via their website to the check arriving in the mail. While I do not intend to return to MTGO, I have only good things to say about MTGO Traders and wish them further success.
Cape Fear Games and MTGO Traders are incredibly trustworthy. I have bought and sold cards with them over the course of two years and have not had a single issue with them.
Just sold my Mtgo collection to mtgotraders. Highly recommend for their service. Not only did Gussie answer all my questions but he offered HIGHER than their other major competitor.
Thanks Mr Montangie.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Only suggestion is that there needs to be a better way to transfer the digital cards - as a new guy it felt kind of sketchy, but apparently that's just how it's done.
Modern: Love my Goblins, but want to build Merfolk
Utterly terrible at all things limited
Never had any problems with them at all since the beginning.
Edit: By "them," I mean MTGO Traders, not Magic Online.
:symg::symw::symu:Birthing Pod:symu::symw::symg:
I sold my online collection to them and it was the easiest thing ever. If I ever get back into MTGO, I'll only go through them.
My contact with MTGO Traders was Gustavo, and he proved why his company was the best. I have bought my cards online from many vendors, but this was definitely one of my top choices when I played regularly. I'm very happy to say that my 'final' transaction only cemented this reputation for excellence. I never felt too scared selling my 13-year-old account thanks to the and crystal-clear instructions and communication. The options for payment were numerous, convenient, and generous. My major concerns were answered immediately, as an experienced company understands this process better than anyone else. Gustavo even let me know that he'd set me up for the Momir Vig format if I ever had the MODO itch. I can't recommend these guys highly enough.
Most of my card purchases in the last 4 years were done with them and I never had any issues.
Fully recommended.
Would do it again (once I get sucked back in after v5 maybe, v4 is still garbage)
I decided recently to trade MTGO for Hearthstone and sold my collection back to them. Was a little apprehensive to begin with, but their price was right and their reputation as one of the large/not shady Magic Online vendors was enough to push the button on selling. Pretty painless. I got a quote from them 2 days after I first contacted them. When I accepted, the cards were gone and the money wired within the hour.
David G. / EtDecius
B Gonti, lord of luxury B
Thanks Mr Montangie.