I recall reading somewhere that Magic R&D hates the concept of non-creature tokens, but maybe they'd be willing to break out of that mold (again) with the new Ajani?
I recall reading somewhere that Magic R&D hates the concept of non-creature tokens, but maybe they'd be willing to break out of that mold (again) with the new Ajani?
While I don't see Ajani making enchantment creatures (that's more of a god's thing) I could see him making enchantment tokens with effects like "Creatures you control get +0/+1." It would be a nice way to synergize with his chosen.
While I don't see Ajani making enchantment creatures (that's more of a god's thing) I could see him making enchantment tokens with effects like "Creatures you control get +0/+1." It would be a nice way to synergize with his chosen.
I think Aura tokens would fit Ajani more. Planeswalker-made global enchantment tokens seem a little too close to emblems. Here's my guess:
Aurajani3GW
+2: Gain 3 life for each enchantment and enchanted creatures you control on the battlefield.
0: Put a green and white aura enchantment token on the battlefield attached to a target creature you control. That aura has "Enchanted creature gets +1/+1 and has lifelink"
^ That would mean you would gain 6 life for one normal creature with an aura enchantment attached. Wouldn't it be simpler (and less powerful) to say "for each enchantment you control"?
I could also see him destroying enchantments. So maybe
Ajani, Auramancer 3GW
+1 Gain 2 life for each enchantment you control
-2 Destroy target enchantment
-8 Destroy all enchantments you do not control, put that number of enchantment tokens with "target creature gets +1/+1" onto the battlefield attached to creatures you control
Ajani,
GW3
5 loyalty
+1 creatures you control gain +1+1 and gain (lifelink,vigilance, or trample) until eot
-2 (exile or bottem of library) to target creature
-8 exile each artifact,creature, and enchantment you dont control, (draw a card or put a 2/2 cat) for each card exiled this way.
ajani being my favorite walker this is along the lines of what id like to see. im going to guess that he will be a 5 drop considering planeswalkers max versions with same cost seems to be 2.
Totally agree we are gonna see a GW Ajani, but in that I would say we might see a calmer/wiser Ajani. Since he was already vegeant (w/R) and after fighting bolas, which probably took a lot out, I think the reasoning for him adopting G, would be to act more as a assisting planeswalker. Everyone has already seen the art for Journey into Nyx, and it shows Ajani, behind our Elspeth, not beside. So maybe his abilities could actually coincide with hers;
Ajani, the Resolute 2GW
-1; Exile target Enchantment.
0; Whenever an enchantment enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a 2/2 GW cat creature token with hexproof onto to the battlefield.
-3; Ajani, the Resolute becomes a 3/3 Enchantment Creature with Indestructible and Bestow GW, whenever enchanted creature attacks you gain 3 life.
Enchanted creature gets +3/+3
0; Whenever an enchantment enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a 2/2 GW cat creature token with hexproof onto to the battlefield.
-3; Ajani, the Resolute becomes a 3/3 Enchantment Creature with Indestructible and Bestow GW, whenever enchanted creature attacks you gain 3 life.
Enchanted creature gets +3/+3
Loyalty 4
Your abilities doesn't make sense.
First of all why would a resolute person have no + ability and essentially only focuses on separating the loyalty-tie with the summoning planeswalker -> something we've only seen on a Mad person.
Second, your ability-order is off. Your -1 would be the middle-ability and not the first.
Thirdly, your only non-negative ability is a triggered one, so it doesn't have any effect without another element -> that's not good design as it makes the planeswalker dependent on your hand to have any influence at all.
For the fourth, your ultimate ability doesn't really work.
First you make Ajani a creature enchantment (not in addition to his other types so he stops being a planeswalker and thus you transformed a planeswalker into a generic creature -> bad design). Then you give him Bestow (which only matters on the hand, so it's utterly redundant) and want him to act like an Aura.
Overall the ability you want cannot be made. A fix could be to have Ajani create an Aura-token, which we haven't had yet and I wouldn't expect we'd get one. In addition he could create a token creature so they could be connected if you want to or have the Aura-token enchant another target.
First of all why would a resolute person have no + ability and essentially only focuses on separating the loyalty-tie with the summoning planeswalker -> something we've only seen on a Mad person.
Second, your ability-order is off. Your -1 would be the middle-ability and not the first.
Thirdly, your only non-negative ability is a triggered one, so it doesn't have any effect without another element -> that's not good design as it makes the planeswalker dependent on your hand to have any influence at all.
For the fourth, your ultimate ability doesn't really work.
First you make Ajani a creature enchantment (not in addition to his other types so he stops being a planeswalker and thus you transformed a planeswalker into a generic creature -> bad design). Then you give him Bestow (which only matters on the hand, so it's utterly redundant) and want him to act like an Aura.
Overall the ability you want cannot be made. A fix could be to have Ajani create an Aura-token, which we haven't had yet and I wouldn't expect we'd get one. In addition he could create a token creature so they could be connected if you want to or have the Aura-token enchant another target.
Criticism accepted; However; A resolute person is firm/steadfast/purposeful. So even though he's not directly attacking; a God walks in, Ajani boots him/her out next turn (exile over destroy:nod:). For the second; I was kind of going for a wall effect here; Ajani blocks; Elspeth attacks; pretty sure it's going to be a team up.
Also, I was just scanning over the planeswalker cards, and saw a 0 in the middle, but I understand my etiquette error; honestly didn't really catch it, my bad.
On the last part; kind of pulling from Gideon, Champion of Justice here; basically turning a planeswalker into an almost unblockable/unkillable creature with an unlimited life building ability; hence "Indestructible" and +3 life every attack. Maybe my way describing it was off, but it's what I would like to see in a Theros Ajani.
Drawing inspiration from his past versions and the "Soul's _____" mini cycle, I was thinking a (non-enchantment based) G/W Ajani would be something like this:
Ajani, 3GW
+2 Put a 2/2 white cat token onto the battlefield
-3 Put a +1/+1 counter on each creature you control. Gain life equal to the number of +1/+1 counters placed this way.
-7 Put X +1/+1 counters on each creature you control, where X is that creature's power.
Starting Loyality: 4
I stick with my guns and say he is still red. Maybe I'm wrong (trust me, it happens), but the switch from Red (anger, destruction) to green (peace, renewal, nature) is far too large of a shift. Who knows, maybe we won't see Ajani till NYX and he will be a RWG. A few people think the next set (Warlords of Khanar is the lead suspect) is gonna be a shard plane. He could be the seed.
tl,dr: I think RW, might be wrong. Next set could be shards, leading to a RWG.
^ Ajani's from Naya. Nacatls are primarily green. Why would you think otherwise. Even though if he's albino, it doesn't say a thing about him. What we know about Ajani is he's definitely white, but there's no reason to dismiss green.
I don't know why everybody thinks he will be an enchantment planeswalker. Just because it would make sense during the block doesn't mean they would do one. Vraska didn't become the graveyard walker but, then again they had an artifact walker in scars of mirrodin, but he was only because he was an artifact walker earlier. So idk if he will. But I personnaly think he won't.
+1: Search you library for an enchantment card and reveal that card. Shuffle your library, then put the card on top of it.
-X: Put a 2/2 white Cat creature token onto the battlefield. You may put an aura card with converted mana cost X from you hand onto the battlefield attached to that creature.
-8: You get an Emblem with "Enchantments you control and creatures you control that are enchanted have hexproof and indestructible."
Loyalty: 4
Your first two abilities work really well in Theros. -X to put an aura into play synergizes super-well with bestow creatures. Maybe that could be the bestow "enabler" we've been waiting for. I like.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
MODERN Blue Lantern, UBx Tezzerator. OLD SCHOOL 93/94 «The Pain Train» Black Sligh, Esper «Machine Gun» Artifacts, Jund «Psycho» Ponza-Disko.
Your first two abilities work really well in Theros. -X to put an aura into play synergizes super-well with bestow creatures. Maybe that could be the bestow "enabler" we've been waiting for. I like.
Eh... no? Enchantment creatures aren't auras. You have to cast it for its bestow cost in order for it to "turn" into an aura.
And that Planeswalker is too powerful to see print.
I don't know why everybody thinks he will be an enchantment planeswalker. Just because it would make sense during the block doesn't mean they would do one. Vraska didn't become the graveyard walker but, then again they had an artifact walker in scars of mirrodin, but he was only because he was an artifact walker earlier. So idk if he will. But I personnaly think he won't.
They won't make an enchantment walker, because it makes them more vulnerable and less special. Karn wasn't an artifact planeswalker because it would just annoy people to play Karn and have it Naturalized or smelted.
^ Ajani's from Naya. Nacatls are primarily green. Why would you think otherwise. Even though if he's albino, it doesn't say a thing about him. What we know about Ajani is he's definitely white, but there's no reason to dismiss green.
If he is from Naya, then Red is in his color identity. Note how I also recognized I could be wrong, and how I also threw in a potential compromise, where he is all of Naya's colors.
I'm sorry but I gotta disagree with you. Wizards have stated that they don't check on color combinations nor do they seek to complete color cycles. HOWEVER, there's a rational/logical part in them that screams balancing and spreading colors evenly. We don't need to skew too much such that we cannot enjoy playing other colors on an even keel.
I stick with my guns and say he is still red. Maybe I'm wrong (trust me, it happens)
tl,dr: I think RW, might be wrong. Next set could be shards, leading to a RWG.
We trust that you be wrong? So why push for the notion that Ajani's still red? You're just trying to cover all grounds and that makes your argument a little weak.
Many previous posters have supported and added on to the notion of a g/w Ajani. It's on the OP, for God's sake! Common sense really.
-Too many red walkers in standard.
-No G/W combination ever
-Ajani's has always been white
-We knew his R/W version was his "earliest" form. He was seeking a path of vengeance then. He's alot calmer now.
-He's from Naya. A shard that's predominantly green.
-Hes a Nacatl. Albino. Known for healing magic and sort of a "seer" among his tribe.
-Healing/life is also in the realms of green
Which connects us to enchantments (indirectly), given that Theros is in town and is big on enchantments. People draw heuristics from what they experience (like Legacy Enchantress) in the past. Logic and common sense also dictates how the human mind reacts and behaves with each sequence or pattern, and thus we draw simple conclusions.
So how does this not scream more green than red to you?
You might have noticed that all of the allied colors got a mythic rare except for GW. Instead, a BW mythic was printed. It's likely that, because there will be a GW walker in the following set, the BW mythic and the GW mythic from Theros and Born of the Gods were switched.
This is true, does not confirm Ajani, but does confirm that BNG has a GW mythic that was for some reason not in THS. The switch means that there was a flavor/storyline issue, so either a legendary with story significance or a walker.
I'm not sold on G/W being the colours of Ajani, nor that Born of the Gods is necessarily the set in which he appears.
I think we can assume that he will appear somewhere in the block based on the art, but but I don't see any definite reason why those has to be his colours, nor why he has to appear in the middle set of the block.
It could be correct, but he could also be some other colour(s) and in Journey into Nyx.
If he did turn up G/W, would he then be the first planeswalker to appear in three different colour-combinations?
If he is from Naya, then Red is in his color identity. Note how I also recognized I could be wrong, and how I also threw in a potential compromise, where he is all of Naya's colors.
Red is not in his color identity, he was RW when avenging his brother, then after he calmed down he switched to just white. Red was no longer his color identity, as he was never red in his personality, only while seeking revenge for his brothers murder. However, Naya and Leonin are primarily green. Green is in his color identity, red is not.
He will not be 3 colors, and he will most likely(95%) not be mono-white because of Elspeth. Him being in BNG is likely, but not certain. It is possible that BNG will feature God Xenagos as the villain, then Ajani comes in during last set to help defeat him.
The mythic rare distribution means that he will likely be in BNG, putting both hero's in the block, as well as the villain, then have the villain ascend in the last set to create the climax. This would also leave the anticipated god walker for the last set.
We trust that you be wrong? So why push for the notion that Ajani's still red? You're just trying to cover all grounds and that makes your argument a little weak.
Apparently admitting to being wrong previously means that I must always be wrong and should not voice my opinion? When I said tust me I have been wrong before, that was my way of acknowledging the fact that I could be mistaken on him being Red in this next form.
Why push for him still being red? Couldn't i ask the same of everyone pushing for green? You want reasons for me thinking he will retain (or regain) red? Let's see:
-Naya is Green, with white and RED as supporting colors
-Ajani has only ever showed White consistently, and had red thrown in when he was giving into his anger
-The only belonging he holds dear is his double sided axe, created by fusing his brothers weapon with his own. The JiN poster shows that it is broken.
-Let me say that again, HIS BROTHERS AXE IS GONE. His one tie back to his brother, who he already went red for, is gone.
-We can't have 2 mono-white walkers, WotC won't do it, and we would all be angry at them for doing it.
-Logically, that means a second color for Ajani.
He has been red before, so already my evidence is actual evidence. What everyone saying GW Ajani has is circumstantial at best. "He is green because auras" or "he is green because Naya" are easily refuted. White has some domain over Auras, and Naya is not pure green. There are a plethora of white cats. That's all that Ajani interacts with cardwise. Never has he been green before, and just because he is from Naya doesn't automatically gain him the title of green walker.
Covering all of your bases is never a sign of a weak argument, if anything it is a sign of a strong one. It shows that I have enough insight into the argument to offer rebuttals to potential counter arguments. You don't just state one thing and hope to defend it by saying nothing else. You state your opinion, and then you give not only your supporting evidence, but also any potential lines of counter arguments and rebuttal them as best you can.
Honestly, if you are going to try and pounce on my opinion (one that I stated on a much earlier page as well) just because it doesn't line up with yours, demand evidence and answers, and then offer none of your own, then you are narrow-minded and ignorant.
For the record I mostly disagree with your arguments Verox but I really want Ajani to be RGW so I hope you're right about him having Red in his cost.
Regarding Ajani's axe(s) - we cannot see his other hand nor his front. He might have split up the axes again prior to the fight with Xenagos.
He might have let go of his brother's axe in a symbolic way of "letting him go" - speaking for his calm personality-change (which is very likely to have happened considering his story-arch).
What I mean to say: We cannot be sure about anything so presenting one's arguments as possibilities is the furthest we can go, where it seems to me that you're very convinced with your own arguments - "The JiN poster shows that it is broken." - "HIS BROTHERS AXE IS GONE".
So if we could just keep this thing to post ideas on why one and the other and discuss this in an orderly fashion, ...
:embarrass:My apologies Tzefick. Thank for giving me a cyber Gibbs smack. I tend to need those from time to time. And you make a good point, he may have split the axes, but I have to politely disagree with the letting go of the other half for two reasons. 1) It is a way of reminding him of what he stands for. 2) It looks way more badass as a double sided axe.
:embarrass:My apologies Tzefick. Thank for giving me a cyber Gibbs smack. I tend to need those from time to time. And you make a good point, he may have split the axes, but I have to politely disagree with the letting go of the other half for two reasons. 1) It is a way of reminding him of what he stands for. 2) It looks way more badass as a double sided axe.
There's also the whole "Gods changed the nature of the weapon", as Heliod did with Elspeth's sword.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Maro seems open to the idea:
http://markrosewater.tumblr.com/post/63536159060/will-we-ever-see-noncreature-tokens-maybe-lands-or
While I don't see Ajani making enchantment creatures (that's more of a god's thing) I could see him making enchantment tokens with effects like "Creatures you control get +0/+1." It would be a nice way to synergize with his chosen.
Aurajani 3GW
+2: Gain 3 life for each enchantment and enchanted creatures you control on the battlefield.
0: Put a green and white aura enchantment token on the battlefield attached to a target creature you control. That aura has "Enchanted creature gets +1/+1 and has lifelink"
-9: Super duper ultimate.
{3}
I could also see him destroying enchantments. So maybe
GW3
5 loyalty
+1 creatures you control gain +1+1 and gain (lifelink,vigilance, or trample) until eot
-2 (exile or bottem of library) to target creature
-8 exile each artifact,creature, and enchantment you dont control, (draw a card or put a 2/2 cat) for each card exiled this way.
ajani being my favorite walker this is along the lines of what id like to see. im going to guess that he will be a 5 drop considering planeswalkers max versions with same cost seems to be 2.
Ajani, the Resolute 2GW
-1; Exile target Enchantment.
0; Whenever an enchantment enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a 2/2 GW cat creature token with hexproof onto to the battlefield.
-3; Ajani, the Resolute becomes a 3/3 Enchantment Creature with Indestructible and Bestow GW, whenever enchanted creature attacks you gain 3 life.
Enchanted creature gets +3/+3
Loyalty 4
First of all why would a resolute person have no + ability and essentially only focuses on separating the loyalty-tie with the summoning planeswalker -> something we've only seen on a Mad person.
Second, your ability-order is off. Your -1 would be the middle-ability and not the first.
Thirdly, your only non-negative ability is a triggered one, so it doesn't have any effect without another element -> that's not good design as it makes the planeswalker dependent on your hand to have any influence at all.
For the fourth, your ultimate ability doesn't really work.
First you make Ajani a creature enchantment (not in addition to his other types so he stops being a planeswalker and thus you transformed a planeswalker into a generic creature -> bad design). Then you give him Bestow (which only matters on the hand, so it's utterly redundant) and want him to act like an Aura.
Overall the ability you want cannot be made. A fix could be to have Ajani create an Aura-token, which we haven't had yet and I wouldn't expect we'd get one. In addition he could create a token creature so they could be connected if you want to or have the Aura-token enchant another target.
Criticism accepted; However; A resolute person is firm/steadfast/purposeful. So even though he's not directly attacking; a God walks in, Ajani boots him/her out next turn (exile over destroy:nod:). For the second; I was kind of going for a wall effect here; Ajani blocks; Elspeth attacks; pretty sure it's going to be a team up.
Also, I was just scanning over the planeswalker cards, and saw a 0 in the middle, but I understand my etiquette error; honestly didn't really catch it, my bad.
On the last part; kind of pulling from Gideon, Champion of Justice here; basically turning a planeswalker into an almost unblockable/unkillable creature with an unlimited life building ability; hence "Indestructible" and +3 life every attack. Maybe my way describing it was off, but it's what I would like to see in a Theros Ajani.
Ajani, 3GW
+2 Put a 2/2 white cat token onto the battlefield
-3 Put a +1/+1 counter on each creature you control. Gain life equal to the number of +1/+1 counters placed this way.
-7 Put X +1/+1 counters on each creature you control, where X is that creature's power.
Starting Loyality: 4
tl,dr: I think RW, might be wrong. Next set could be shards, leading to a RWG.
When asking for if something was stolen on Kamigawa:
Have some irony:
UR Melek, Izzet ParagonUR, B Shirei, Shizo's CaretakerB, R Jaya Ballard, Task MageR,RW Tajic, Blade of the LegionRW, UB Lazav, Dimir MastermindUB, UB Circu, Dimir LobotomistUB, RWU Zedruu the GreatheartedRWU, GUBThe MimeoplasmGUB, UGExperiment Kraj UG, WDarien, King of KjeldorW, BMarrow-GnawerB, WBGKarador, Ghost ChieftainWBG, UTeferi, Temporal ArchmageU, GWUDerevi, Empyrial TacticianGWU, RDaretti, Scrap SavantR, UTalrand, Sky SummonerU, GEzuri, Renegade LeaderG, WUBRGReaper KingWUBRG, RGXenagos, God of RevelsRG, CKozilek, Butcher of TruthC, WUBRGGeneral TazriWUBRG, GTitania, Protector of ArgothG
Your first two abilities work really well in Theros. -X to put an aura into play synergizes super-well with bestow creatures. Maybe that could be the bestow "enabler" we've been waiting for. I like.
OLD SCHOOL 93/94 «The Pain Train» Black Sligh, Esper «Machine Gun» Artifacts, Jund «Psycho» Ponza-Disko.
Eh... no? Enchantment creatures aren't auras. You have to cast it for its bestow cost in order for it to "turn" into an aura.
And that Planeswalker is too powerful to see print.
UR Melek, Izzet ParagonUR, B Shirei, Shizo's CaretakerB, R Jaya Ballard, Task MageR,RW Tajic, Blade of the LegionRW, UB Lazav, Dimir MastermindUB, UB Circu, Dimir LobotomistUB, RWU Zedruu the GreatheartedRWU, GUBThe MimeoplasmGUB, UGExperiment Kraj UG, WDarien, King of KjeldorW, BMarrow-GnawerB, WBGKarador, Ghost ChieftainWBG, UTeferi, Temporal ArchmageU, GWUDerevi, Empyrial TacticianGWU, RDaretti, Scrap SavantR, UTalrand, Sky SummonerU, GEzuri, Renegade LeaderG, WUBRGReaper KingWUBRG, RGXenagos, God of RevelsRG, CKozilek, Butcher of TruthC, WUBRGGeneral TazriWUBRG, GTitania, Protector of ArgothG
They won't make an enchantment walker, because it makes them more vulnerable and less special. Karn wasn't an artifact planeswalker because it would just annoy people to play Karn and have it Naturalized or smelted.
When asking for if something was stolen on Kamigawa:
Have some irony:
If he is from Naya, then Red is in his color identity. Note how I also recognized I could be wrong, and how I also threw in a potential compromise, where he is all of Naya's colors.
When asking for if something was stolen on Kamigawa:
Have some irony:
We currently have Chandra, Pyromaster, Domri Rade, and Xenagos the Reveler. Why are you so vehement on the idea that Ajani would be red/x? And as you said (QFT)
We trust that you be wrong? So why push for the notion that Ajani's still red? You're just trying to cover all grounds and that makes your argument a little weak.
Many previous posters have supported and added on to the notion of a g/w Ajani. It's on the OP, for God's sake! Common sense really.
-Too many red walkers in standard.
-No G/W combination ever
-Ajani's has always been white
-We knew his R/W version was his "earliest" form. He was seeking a path of vengeance then. He's alot calmer now.
-He's from Naya. A shard that's predominantly green.
-Hes a Nacatl. Albino. Known for healing magic and sort of a "seer" among his tribe.
-Healing/life is also in the realms of green
Which connects us to enchantments (indirectly), given that Theros is in town and is big on enchantments. People draw heuristics from what they experience (like Legacy Enchantress) in the past. Logic and common sense also dictates how the human mind reacts and behaves with each sequence or pattern, and thus we draw simple conclusions.
So how does this not scream more green than red to you?
UR Melek, Izzet ParagonUR, B Shirei, Shizo's CaretakerB, R Jaya Ballard, Task MageR,RW Tajic, Blade of the LegionRW, UB Lazav, Dimir MastermindUB, UB Circu, Dimir LobotomistUB, RWU Zedruu the GreatheartedRWU, GUBThe MimeoplasmGUB, UGExperiment Kraj UG, WDarien, King of KjeldorW, BMarrow-GnawerB, WBGKarador, Ghost ChieftainWBG, UTeferi, Temporal ArchmageU, GWUDerevi, Empyrial TacticianGWU, RDaretti, Scrap SavantR, UTalrand, Sky SummonerU, GEzuri, Renegade LeaderG, WUBRGReaper KingWUBRG, RGXenagos, God of RevelsRG, CKozilek, Butcher of TruthC, WUBRGGeneral TazriWUBRG, GTitania, Protector of ArgothG
This is true, does not confirm Ajani, but does confirm that BNG has a GW mythic that was for some reason not in THS. The switch means that there was a flavor/storyline issue, so either a legendary with story significance or a walker.
Red is not in his color identity, he was RW when avenging his brother, then after he calmed down he switched to just white. Red was no longer his color identity, as he was never red in his personality, only while seeking revenge for his brothers murder. However, Naya and Leonin are primarily green. Green is in his color identity, red is not.
He will not be 3 colors, and he will most likely(95%) not be mono-white because of Elspeth. Him being in BNG is likely, but not certain. It is possible that BNG will feature God Xenagos as the villain, then Ajani comes in during last set to help defeat him.
The mythic rare distribution means that he will likely be in BNG, putting both hero's in the block, as well as the villain, then have the villain ascend in the last set to create the climax. This would also leave the anticipated god walker for the last set.
Apparently admitting to being wrong previously means that I must always be wrong and should not voice my opinion? When I said tust me I have been wrong before, that was my way of acknowledging the fact that I could be mistaken on him being Red in this next form.
Why push for him still being red? Couldn't i ask the same of everyone pushing for green? You want reasons for me thinking he will retain (or regain) red? Let's see:
-Naya is Green, with white and RED as supporting colors
-Ajani has only ever showed White consistently, and had red thrown in when he was giving into his anger
-The only belonging he holds dear is his double sided axe, created by fusing his brothers weapon with his own. The JiN poster shows that it is broken.
-Let me say that again, HIS BROTHERS AXE IS GONE. His one tie back to his brother, who he already went red for, is gone.
-We can't have 2 mono-white walkers, WotC won't do it, and we would all be angry at them for doing it.
-Logically, that means a second color for Ajani.
He has been red before, so already my evidence is actual evidence. What everyone saying GW Ajani has is circumstantial at best. "He is green because auras" or "he is green because Naya" are easily refuted. White has some domain over Auras, and Naya is not pure green. There are a plethora of white cats. That's all that Ajani interacts with cardwise. Never has he been green before, and just because he is from Naya doesn't automatically gain him the title of green walker.
Covering all of your bases is never a sign of a weak argument, if anything it is a sign of a strong one. It shows that I have enough insight into the argument to offer rebuttals to potential counter arguments. You don't just state one thing and hope to defend it by saying nothing else. You state your opinion, and then you give not only your supporting evidence, but also any potential lines of counter arguments and rebuttal them as best you can.
Honestly, if you are going to try and pounce on my opinion (one that I stated on a much earlier page as well) just because it doesn't line up with yours, demand evidence and answers, and then offer none of your own, then you are narrow-minded and ignorant.
When asking for if something was stolen on Kamigawa:
Have some irony:
For the record I mostly disagree with your arguments Verox but I really want Ajani to be RGW so I hope you're right about him having Red in his cost.
Regarding Ajani's axe(s) - we cannot see his other hand nor his front. He might have split up the axes again prior to the fight with Xenagos.
He might have let go of his brother's axe in a symbolic way of "letting him go" - speaking for his calm personality-change (which is very likely to have happened considering his story-arch).
What I mean to say: We cannot be sure about anything so presenting one's arguments as possibilities is the furthest we can go, where it seems to me that you're very convinced with your own arguments - "The JiN poster shows that it is broken." - "HIS BROTHERS AXE IS GONE".
So if we could just keep this thing to post ideas on why one and the other and discuss this in an orderly fashion, ...
When asking for if something was stolen on Kamigawa:
Have some irony:
There's also the whole "Gods changed the nature of the weapon", as Heliod did with Elspeth's sword.