Since yesterday all gods are revealed. & in this thread i want you to rank the gods & maybe a lil discussion bout it.
Here is my ranking:
1: Purphoros (Because the damage-ability can be abused very easily)
2: Thassa (Helps your draws a bit & unblockable)
3: Athreos (If the ability becomes relevant, he does A LOT)
4: Xenagos (That Ability with Trample becomes a big threat)
5: Ephara (Cause she can draw so many cards)
6: Mogis (in the right Deck both abilities hurt very much)
7: Iroas (The Combat-God)
The remaining Gods i didnt include, cause for me they belong into another league than the ones above.
Athreos, God of Passage
Ephara, God of the Polis
Erebos, God of the Dead
Heliod, God of the Sun
Iroas, God of Victory
Karametra, God of Harvests
Keranos, God of Storms
Kruphix, God of Horizons
Mogis, God of Slaughter
Nylea, God of the Hunt
Pharika, God of Affliction
Phenax, God of Deception
Purphoros, God of the Forge
Thassa, God of the Sea
Xenagos, God of Revels
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
When you can no longer run, you crawl. And when you can no longer do that, you find someone to carry you.
Well here's my ranking based on my casual views.
1. Athreos it pains me but I think he's going to see the most play
2. Iroas
3. Thassa
4. Xenagod
5. Keranos
6. Mogis
7. Nylea
8. Erebos - the correction.
9. Purphoros
10. Kruphix
11-15. Everyone else not mentioned
Iroas hasn't proven himself yet. He also does nothing on his own and is especially useless against control decks, where Mogis is good in any game that does not contain an active Elspeth.
Oh wait, we're supposed to be ranking them in an absolute vacuum? I thought we're ranking them in the current Standard environment.
Iroas hasn't proven himself yet. He also does nothing on his own and is especially useless against control decks, where Mogis is good in any game that does not contain an active Elspeth.
Actually Mogis is pretty hilarious going against Athreos as well. Either you sac a creature but get it back anyway (in an Athreos deck probably something low costed like Soldier of the Pantheon anyway so it doesn't matter too much) or THEY take 3 life. I find that interaction pretty amusing.
*edit* I guess you could get caught with your pants down without any creatures but that could happen no matter what you're playing.
1. Thassa- Easiest to cast, easiest to devote, and has a game-winning activated ability. Her repeatable scry is her weakest point, and even that's decent.
2. Athreos- Repeatable reclaim or facebolt. Two things that B/W aggro decks would love to do.
3. Purphoros- Easy-to-work combo piece. Team firebreathing is icing.
4. Ephara- Card draw with creatures. Enough said.
5-7. Erebos, Xenagos, Nylea- Easy to devote. Abilities are OK, but not stellar.
Erebos has more potential for being self-sufficient.
8-9. Mogis, Keranos- The only gods that can win by themselves with no extra costs.
10-12. Heliod, Pharika, Iroas- Their abilities are decent, but they don't have any comfortable homes. Iroas is great vs. green decks, but lame vs. heavy-removal decks. Pharika contradicts the more popular G/B decks. Heliod does as well, since small butts and Vigilance aren't great together.
13-14. Kruphix, Phenax- Here because they're not as terrible as Karametra. Phenax at least provides a win-con that some decks just can't beat, and Kruphix can set up some nut combos.
Disclaimer: I have slight biases towards the color red and MTGRadio's Erebos deck, which is a beast.
Man, big shout outs to Tom right here. If you are fans of EDH, this is one of the best, if not the best streams to check out. Theboyks is also good, but that is more of a draft stream.
Yay for advertising.
But in terms of EDH, I think Phenax is a LOT more powerful.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I fear I won't have much time to play Magic these days.
I get to watch worlds develop around me.
I get to watch great leaders, terrible oppressors, and trend setters rise and fall.
Limited, Standard, Modern, everything is a different playing field I feel I can observe, but will not actually touch.
I look forward to the stories I will hear.
And more so to the ones I will watch unfold first hand.
Isn't the unknown exciting?
Ok since everyone is choosing their own parameters ill rank them based on my EDH rank that combines power and coolness:
Xenagos (huge hits are cool)
Phenax (enables a mill deck that players wanted going with Ub's defensive style)
Kruphix (i wonder what people will float mana for but it is a colorful, powerful and flavorful card for sure)
Thassa (not useless without dudes and enables some more beatdown angles for decks like vendilion clique)
Ephara (incentive to play small creatures instead of 10 wrath effects)
Erebos (cause as much as i love cards i LOVE denying life)
Karametra (good but ramp is getting old)
Iroas (beatdown)
Nylea (combat step is cool and should be more used - the threat of activation is relevant)
Purphoros (powerful but application too obvious to be cool)
Mogis (conditional pressure and not impressive at all)
Athreos (conditional, but has political applications)
Keranos (i can see better CA engines for less mana, such as Ephara plus draw is just too mainstream for a general)
Heliod (weak abilities and doesnt bebefit from threat of activation like nylea)
Pharika (if i mill myself it will be for greater effect)
Summing up, beating with dudes it cool in EDH becuase drawing cards is too easy.
I'm going to rate the gods based on standard playability. Obviously this analysis can't be perfect, but oh well...
1. Thassa : she is strong by herself and allows any creature you control to clock your opponent. VCA + Win-Con in a single card is rather excellent.
2. Athreos : (speculation) with this in standard alongside xathrid necromancer, WB humans decks have potentially 8 cards that provide boardwipe/removal protection to all of their agressive creatures. The deck is not yet proven (and athreos probably won't be a 4 of) but I think this god will make quite the splash in standard.
3. Erebos : Indestructible greed is indestructible greed. CA really is that good...
4. Ephara : Never underestimate CA.
5. Xenagos : Standard proven. Has immediate impact even if you have very little board presence.
6. Nylea : IMO, she is one of the more underestimated gods. She makes all your creatures evasive and tips combat math in your favor. 6 power for 4 mana doesn't suck either.
7. Purphoros : Powerful, but not generically so. This needs a very special deck to be great.
8. Pharika : IMO, she is the most underestimated god. She doesn't fit into the current dredge build, but could be incredible in constellation.deck or some future GB deck that cares less about maintaining its graveyard.
9. Ioras : Powerful, but doesn't really help boros matchups at present. It feels win more to me.
10. Mogis : Powerful but giving your opponents decisions is a bad thing.
11. Keranos : Powerful, but ultimately too slow IMO. Might be useful in RWU control once sphinxs rev rotates.
12. Phenax : This will require a very special standard to be viable.
13. Karametra : I don't think anything short of eldrazi will make this god standard playable.
14. Kruphix : pretty useless in standard. Small possibility of it seeing play as a 1 of in bant control where it neither makes or breaks the deck
15. Heliod : IMO, heliod is the worst god. Its body is inefficent,its passive effect is typically irrelvant, and its token ability is over costed. Might see play with constellation, but I doubt it....
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Every time I read a comment about "Well if this card had card draw/trample/haste/indestructible/hexproof/life gain...", I think "You're missing the point." They're armchair developer comments that fail to take into account the card's role in the greater Limited and Standard environment. No, it may not be as good as whatever card you're comparing it to. There's a reason for that. Not every burn spell is Lightning Bolt, nor does it need to be or should be.
- Manite
1. Thassa - Only God that I ever expect to see 4 of play. Her being 3 Mana instead of 4 is that good. Should be a player in post RTR Standard too.
2. Athereos - Obzedat, BW Humans, etc. The potential here is absolutely huge, possibly spanning to Modern/Legacy as a 1-2 of given how efficient this is. It might even make Cartel Aristocrat playable again!
3. Pharika - 3 Mana is a huge deal. The snakes excel at grinding out creature mirrors, and incidental graveyard hate is always a nice thing to have access to. She isn't the strongest specifically, but is cheap and versatile enough to be very mainboardable.
4. Ephara - Much better for White decks than Blue decks, which have access to Bident of Thassa (generally outclasses Ephara). It's a slow engine, but still an engine nonetheless. The meta is currently hostile (******* mainboard Lifebanes) to the type of Ephara strategies I expect to see later though (Wu Aggro/Midrange).
5. Heliod - I dream of a world where Heliod sees Control deck play, as there's something very appealing about killing someone with this. It's slow, but powerful with Nykthos and a bunch of
Enchantments. Said deck becomes ever closer to a reality with more JOU spoilers.
6. Iroas - Reads very powerfully and helps Boros beat RG Monsters and other fatty green decks, which can be hard matchups for them. Doesn't do much against control, but then again you have Boros Charm/aggro creatures for that.
7. Xenagod - I respect the power level here, but it competes with Stormbreath Dragon for slots and can't really win that battle. Therefore, it sees only 1-2 of play in most lists. Still, it has immediate board impact and is insane with Trample.
8. Purphoros - Was a house in red devotion, but said deck has a bad UW matchup and died. An interesting build around with a high power level in specific decks. Didn't live up to all the hype though.
9. Mogis - Basically a milder, less demanding Purphoros. Should get better with rotation, but outclassed by lots of 4-drops right now.
10. Keranos - 5 Mana do nothing, at least until you untap. Scry is nice here, but it isn't really a build-around so much as an indestructible enchantment to help you gas out a game. Interesting one to watch going forward.
11. Erebos - Strong right now, but may not always be the best positioned of the Gods. It isn't really mainboardable outside of the specific meta we have now, and loses stock on rotation.
12. Nylea - I like this card as a 1-of and that's about it. Same with Heliod really. Giving Trample is the best quality Nylea has, helping big fat green decks slam through Elves in mirrors and crush Elspeth.
13. Kruphix - Provides an interesting Mana sink with some synergy with Sphinx's Revelation. It has plenty of potential, but seems to be designed for EDH and is a total brick in some matchups. Could break midrange/control mirrors though.
14. Phenax - Mill isn't good mill isn't good mill isn't good. Or so I'd love to say. Regardless the issue with this isn't the raw power level, rather the deckbuilding requirements. Walls.deck isn't really supported right now (Doorkeeper, Murmuring Phantasm, Hover Barrier, etc aren't versatile enough); however, cards like that 0/5 Sheep give me a bit of hope for Phenax. If there are enough big butt creatures that you want to play anyways, Phenax fort (+walkers/removal) could be an actual deck.
15. Karametra - Absolutely unplayable in Standard Constructed. Outclassed by her Dictate now (which actually looks like a promising build-around) but was always awkward, since getting more lands at 5 Mana isn't particularly exciting.
I like Heliod in the 99 in EDH with Serra's Sanctum. I'll eventually pick up a copy of Xenagos, also to run in the 99. Keranos is the only one I'm considering using as general.
1. Thassa
2. Erebos
3. Xenagos
4. Mogis
5. Aerethos
6. Iroas
7. Phenax
8. Purphoros
9. Heliod
10.Ephara
11. Kruphix
12. Nylea
13.Keranos
14. Karametra
15. Pharika-Every other God in the Theros block has some sort of a static effect, while she has only an activated ability that requires mana that I feel is pretty boring. Scavenging ooze can target any card in a graveyard, and doesn't give your opponent death touch chump blockers.
I don't see Mogis getting a lot of competitive play. Pharika, despite people's immense disappointment, is actually okay and might find a niche in a black-green aggressive archetype.
We haven't really seen what Athreos can do but he'll temporarily share the second place as he's very strong.
1: Thassa
2: Athreos/Xenagos
4: Ephara - entirely due to her colors that she beats Purphoros.
5: Purphoros
6: Erebos - strong sideboard card.
7: Iroas - very strong card, not the best colors in the meta.
8: Nylea
9: Kruphix
10: Mogis/Keranos
Both are in colors that's not very dominant atm and doesn't seem to have gained much love throughout the block. Both are good and if I really had to put one before the other I'd pick Keranos as he either deals more damage or gives CA in form of +1 land.
12: Heliod - so disappointing he is.
13: Pharika - I don't think she'll fit the general GB-deck.
14: Phenax - UB's bane...
15: Surprise surprise, Karametra
If we were to enter EDH it would look at little different, namely Karametra skyrocketing upward. Athreos, Purphoros, Mogis and Heliod going downward. Keranos, Ephara and Kruphix goes upwards. Pharika will also raise a few slots but mostly due to the others going down below her in usefulness in EDH. Thassa will be knocked down as no. 1 most likely in favor for Karametra or Kruphix. Iroas, Xenagos and Ephara will take par just below those two.
Following is mana-sinks like Nylea and Erebos. Then Keranos due to a very neat passive CA and occasional Bolt.
The rest comes pretty much in a blur as I don't know how to rank them.
Fun observation: Quite a few are in agreement about Thassa, Athreos in the top.
Well here's my ranking based on my casual views.
1. Athreos it pains me but I think he's going to see the most play
2. Iroas
3. Thassa
4. Xenagod
5. Keranos
6. Mogis
7. Nylea
8. Mogis
9. Purphoros
10. Kruphix
11-15. Everyone else not mentioned
I think for those dismissing Heliod, think again. Especially for Standard. He makes "Constellations"....
From what we have now he doesn't seem worth it. If we get a kick-ass Constellation-permanent we might change our minds but for now he sucks and is so very slow with a very poor static ability.
Well here's my ranking based on my casual views.
1. Athreos it pains me but I think he's going to see the most play
2. Iroas
3. Thassa
4. Xenagod
5. Keranos
6. Mogis
7. Nylea
8. Mogis
9. Purphoros
10. Kruphix
11-15. Everyone else not mentioned
I think for those dismissing Heliod, think again. Especially for Standard. He makes "Constellations"....
From what we have now he doesn't seem worth it. If we get a kick-ass Constellation-permanent we might change our minds but for now he sucks and is so very slow with a very poor static ability.
Ya I fixed that lol with an edit note.
As far as my choices are concerned. It's almost all biased on my color likes athreos and Thassa are strictly because I can't deny their power level over my likes. Iroas I'm a boros fan which is why athreos ranking pains me. I think hes gonna be that good. Thassa would be #2 if she was green or red/white. Lol
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Since yesterday all gods are revealed. & in this thread i want you to rank the gods & maybe a lil discussion bout it.
Here is my ranking:
1: Purphoros (Because the damage-ability can be abused very easily)
2: Thassa (Helps your draws a bit & unblockable)
3: Athreos (If the ability becomes relevant, he does A LOT)
4: Xenagos (That Ability with Trample becomes a big threat)
5: Ephara (Cause she can draw so many cards)
6: Mogis (in the right Deck both abilities hurt very much)
7: Iroas (The Combat-God)
The remaining Gods i didnt include, cause for me they belong into another league than the ones above.
Athreos, God of Passage
Ephara, God of the Polis
Erebos, God of the Dead
Heliod, God of the Sun
Iroas, God of Victory
Karametra, God of Harvests
Keranos, God of Storms
Kruphix, God of Horizons
Mogis, God of Slaughter
Nylea, God of the Hunt
Pharika, God of Affliction
Phenax, God of Deception
Purphoros, God of the Forge
Thassa, God of the Sea
Xenagos, God of Revels
RIP Batman guy. I hope somebody picks up the slack now that you are gone. Sick children need their Batman.
1. Athreos it pains me but I think he's going to see the most play
2. Iroas
3. Thassa
4. Xenagod
5. Keranos
6. Mogis
7. Nylea
8. Erebos - the correction.
9. Purphoros
10. Kruphix
11-15. Everyone else not mentioned
Edit: doing this on my phone is a pain.
Oh wait, we're supposed to be ranking them in an absolute vacuum? I thought we're ranking them in the current Standard environment.
Actually Mogis is pretty hilarious going against Athreos as well. Either you sac a creature but get it back anyway (in an Athreos deck probably something low costed like Soldier of the Pantheon anyway so it doesn't matter too much) or THEY take 3 life. I find that interaction pretty amusing.
*edit* I guess you could get caught with your pants down without any creatures but that could happen no matter what you're playing.
2. Xenagos
3. Purphoros
4. Kruphix
5. Thassa
6. Ephara
7. Karametra
8. Iroas
9. Heliod
10. Phenax
11. Nylea
12. Mogis
13. Athreos
14. Keranos
15. Pharika
Disclaimer: I have slight biases towards the color red and MTGRadio's Erebos deck, which is a beast.
2. Athreos- Repeatable reclaim or facebolt. Two things that B/W aggro decks would love to do.
3. Purphoros- Easy-to-work combo piece. Team firebreathing is icing.
4. Ephara- Card draw with creatures. Enough said.
5-7. Erebos, Xenagos, Nylea- Easy to devote. Abilities are OK, but not stellar.
Erebos has more potential for being self-sufficient.
8-9. Mogis, Keranos- The only gods that can win by themselves with no extra costs.
10-12. Heliod, Pharika, Iroas- Their abilities are decent, but they don't have any comfortable homes. Iroas is great vs. green decks, but lame vs. heavy-removal decks. Pharika contradicts the more popular G/B decks. Heliod does as well, since small butts and Vigilance aren't great together.
13-14. Kruphix, Phenax- Here because they're not as terrible as Karametra. Phenax at least provides a win-con that some decks just can't beat, and Kruphix can set up some nut combos.
15. Karametra- Terrible.
Thassa
Purphy
Erebos
Nylea/Ephara/Athreos
Xenagos
EDH?
Purphy
Erebos/Kruphix
Xenagos
Paprika/Ephara
The other formats have no place for them.
UR Melek, Izzet ParagonUR, B Shirei, Shizo's CaretakerB, R Jaya Ballard, Task MageR,RW Tajic, Blade of the LegionRW, UB Lazav, Dimir MastermindUB, UB Circu, Dimir LobotomistUB, RWU Zedruu the GreatheartedRWU, GUBThe MimeoplasmGUB, UGExperiment Kraj UG, WDarien, King of KjeldorW, BMarrow-GnawerB, WBGKarador, Ghost ChieftainWBG, UTeferi, Temporal ArchmageU, GWUDerevi, Empyrial TacticianGWU, RDaretti, Scrap SavantR, UTalrand, Sky SummonerU, GEzuri, Renegade LeaderG, WUBRGReaper KingWUBRG, RGXenagos, God of RevelsRG, CKozilek, Butcher of TruthC, WUBRGGeneral TazriWUBRG, GTitania, Protector of ArgothG
2. Conjured Currency
3. The rest of the gods
UW Ephara Hatebears [Primer], GB Gitrog Lands, BRU Inalla Combo-Control, URG Maelstrom Wanderer Landfall
Man, big shout outs to Tom right here. If you are fans of EDH, this is one of the best, if not the best streams to check out. Theboyks is also good, but that is more of a draft stream.
Yay for advertising.
But in terms of EDH, I think Phenax is a LOT more powerful.
I get to watch great leaders, terrible oppressors, and trend setters rise and fall.
Limited, Standard, Modern, everything is a different playing field I feel I can observe, but will not actually touch.
I look forward to the stories I will hear.
And more so to the ones I will watch unfold first hand.
Isn't the unknown exciting?
Xenagos (huge hits are cool)
Phenax (enables a mill deck that players wanted going with Ub's defensive style)
Kruphix (i wonder what people will float mana for but it is a colorful, powerful and flavorful card for sure)
Thassa (not useless without dudes and enables some more beatdown angles for decks like vendilion clique)
Ephara (incentive to play small creatures instead of 10 wrath effects)
Erebos (cause as much as i love cards i LOVE denying life)
Karametra (good but ramp is getting old)
Iroas (beatdown)
Nylea (combat step is cool and should be more used - the threat of activation is relevant)
Purphoros (powerful but application too obvious to be cool)
Mogis (conditional pressure and not impressive at all)
Athreos (conditional, but has political applications)
Keranos (i can see better CA engines for less mana, such as Ephara plus draw is just too mainstream for a general)
Heliod (weak abilities and doesnt bebefit from threat of activation like nylea)
Pharika (if i mill myself it will be for greater effect)
Summing up, beating with dudes it cool in EDH becuase drawing cards is too easy.
1. Thassa : she is strong by herself and allows any creature you control to clock your opponent. VCA + Win-Con in a single card is rather excellent.
2. Athreos : (speculation) with this in standard alongside xathrid necromancer, WB humans decks have potentially 8 cards that provide boardwipe/removal protection to all of their agressive creatures. The deck is not yet proven (and athreos probably won't be a 4 of) but I think this god will make quite the splash in standard.
3. Erebos : Indestructible greed is indestructible greed. CA really is that good...
4. Ephara : Never underestimate CA.
5. Xenagos : Standard proven. Has immediate impact even if you have very little board presence.
6. Nylea : IMO, she is one of the more underestimated gods. She makes all your creatures evasive and tips combat math in your favor. 6 power for 4 mana doesn't suck either.
7. Purphoros : Powerful, but not generically so. This needs a very special deck to be great.
8. Pharika : IMO, she is the most underestimated god. She doesn't fit into the current dredge build, but could be incredible in constellation.deck or some future GB deck that cares less about maintaining its graveyard.
9. Ioras : Powerful, but doesn't really help boros matchups at present. It feels win more to me.
10. Mogis : Powerful but giving your opponents decisions is a bad thing.
11. Keranos : Powerful, but ultimately too slow IMO. Might be useful in RWU control once sphinxs rev rotates.
12. Phenax : This will require a very special standard to be viable.
13. Karametra : I don't think anything short of eldrazi will make this god standard playable.
14. Kruphix : pretty useless in standard. Small possibility of it seeing play as a 1 of in bant control where it neither makes or breaks the deck
15. Heliod : IMO, heliod is the worst god. Its body is inefficent,its passive effect is typically irrelvant, and its token ability is over costed. Might see play with constellation, but I doubt it....
- Manite
2. Athereos - Obzedat, BW Humans, etc. The potential here is absolutely huge, possibly spanning to Modern/Legacy as a 1-2 of given how efficient this is. It might even make Cartel Aristocrat playable again!
3. Pharika - 3 Mana is a huge deal. The snakes excel at grinding out creature mirrors, and incidental graveyard hate is always a nice thing to have access to. She isn't the strongest specifically, but is cheap and versatile enough to be very mainboardable.
4. Ephara - Much better for White decks than Blue decks, which have access to Bident of Thassa (generally outclasses Ephara). It's a slow engine, but still an engine nonetheless. The meta is currently hostile (******* mainboard Lifebanes) to the type of Ephara strategies I expect to see later though (Wu Aggro/Midrange).
5. Heliod - I dream of a world where Heliod sees Control deck play, as there's something very appealing about killing someone with this. It's slow, but powerful with Nykthos and a bunch of
Enchantments. Said deck becomes ever closer to a reality with more JOU spoilers.
6. Iroas - Reads very powerfully and helps Boros beat RG Monsters and other fatty green decks, which can be hard matchups for them. Doesn't do much against control, but then again you have Boros Charm/aggro creatures for that.
7. Xenagod - I respect the power level here, but it competes with Stormbreath Dragon for slots and can't really win that battle. Therefore, it sees only 1-2 of play in most lists. Still, it has immediate board impact and is insane with Trample.
8. Purphoros - Was a house in red devotion, but said deck has a bad UW matchup and died. An interesting build around with a high power level in specific decks. Didn't live up to all the hype though.
9. Mogis - Basically a milder, less demanding Purphoros. Should get better with rotation, but outclassed by lots of 4-drops right now.
10. Keranos - 5 Mana do nothing, at least until you untap. Scry is nice here, but it isn't really a build-around so much as an indestructible enchantment to help you gas out a game. Interesting one to watch going forward.
11. Erebos - Strong right now, but may not always be the best positioned of the Gods. It isn't really mainboardable outside of the specific meta we have now, and loses stock on rotation.
12. Nylea - I like this card as a 1-of and that's about it. Same with Heliod really. Giving Trample is the best quality Nylea has, helping big fat green decks slam through Elves in mirrors and crush Elspeth.
13. Kruphix - Provides an interesting Mana sink with some synergy with Sphinx's Revelation. It has plenty of potential, but seems to be designed for EDH and is a total brick in some matchups. Could break midrange/control mirrors though.
14. Phenax - Mill isn't good mill isn't good mill isn't good. Or so I'd love to say. Regardless the issue with this isn't the raw power level, rather the deckbuilding requirements. Walls.deck isn't really supported right now (Doorkeeper, Murmuring Phantasm, Hover Barrier, etc aren't versatile enough); however, cards like that 0/5 Sheep give me a bit of hope for Phenax. If there are enough big butt creatures that you want to play anyways, Phenax fort (+walkers/removal) could be an actual deck.
15. Karametra - Absolutely unplayable in Standard Constructed. Outclassed by her Dictate now (which actually looks like a promising build-around) but was always awkward, since getting more lands at 5 Mana isn't particularly exciting.
—Mowagh the Gwyllion, Fang Skulkin
2. Erebos
3. Xenagos
4. Mogis
5. Aerethos
6. Iroas
7. Phenax
8. Purphoros
9. Heliod
10.Ephara
11. Kruphix
12. Nylea
13.Keranos
14. Karametra
15. Pharika-Every other God in the Theros block has some sort of a static effect, while she has only an activated ability that requires mana that I feel is pretty boring. Scavenging ooze can target any card in a graveyard, and doesn't give your opponent death touch chump blockers.
2. Athreos
3. Erebos
4. Iroas
5. Purphoros
6. Xenagos
7. Ephara
8. Nylea
9. Keranos
10. Mogis
11. Pharika
12. Heliod
13. Phenax
14. Kruphix
15. Karametra
I don't see Mogis getting a lot of competitive play. Pharika, despite people's immense disappointment, is actually okay and might find a niche in a black-green aggressive archetype.
1: Thassa
2: Athreos/Xenagos
4: Ephara - entirely due to her colors that she beats Purphoros.
5: Purphoros
6: Erebos - strong sideboard card.
7: Iroas - very strong card, not the best colors in the meta.
8: Nylea
9: Kruphix
10: Mogis/Keranos
Both are in colors that's not very dominant atm and doesn't seem to have gained much love throughout the block. Both are good and if I really had to put one before the other I'd pick Keranos as he either deals more damage or gives CA in form of +1 land.
12: Heliod - so disappointing he is.
13: Pharika - I don't think she'll fit the general GB-deck.
14: Phenax - UB's bane...
15: Surprise surprise, Karametra
If we were to enter EDH it would look at little different, namely Karametra skyrocketing upward. Athreos, Purphoros, Mogis and Heliod going downward. Keranos, Ephara and Kruphix goes upwards. Pharika will also raise a few slots but mostly due to the others going down below her in usefulness in EDH. Thassa will be knocked down as no. 1 most likely in favor for Karametra or Kruphix. Iroas, Xenagos and Ephara will take par just below those two.
Following is mana-sinks like Nylea and Erebos. Then Keranos due to a very neat passive CA and occasional Bolt.
The rest comes pretty much in a blur as I don't know how to rank them.
Fun observation: Quite a few are in agreement about Thassa, Athreos in the top.
UR Melek, Izzet ParagonUR, B Shirei, Shizo's CaretakerB, R Jaya Ballard, Task MageR,RW Tajic, Blade of the LegionRW, UB Lazav, Dimir MastermindUB, UB Circu, Dimir LobotomistUB, RWU Zedruu the GreatheartedRWU, GUBThe MimeoplasmGUB, UGExperiment Kraj UG, WDarien, King of KjeldorW, BMarrow-GnawerB, WBGKarador, Ghost ChieftainWBG, UTeferi, Temporal ArchmageU, GWUDerevi, Empyrial TacticianGWU, RDaretti, Scrap SavantR, UTalrand, Sky SummonerU, GEzuri, Renegade LeaderG, WUBRGReaper KingWUBRG, RGXenagos, God of RevelsRG, CKozilek, Butcher of TruthC, WUBRGGeneral TazriWUBRG, GTitania, Protector of ArgothG
Edit:
From what we have now he doesn't seem worth it. If we get a kick-ass Constellation-permanent we might change our minds but for now he sucks and is so very slow with a very poor static ability.
Ya I fixed that lol with an edit note.
As far as my choices are concerned. It's almost all biased on my color likes athreos and Thassa are strictly because I can't deny their power level over my likes. Iroas I'm a boros fan which is why athreos ranking pains me. I think hes gonna be that good. Thassa would be #2 if she was green or red/white. Lol