Should have been an increase of two per ability not one.this guy has one job and he fails at it unless you have a bunch in play. At least give him two toughness so Chandra can't ping him easily.
Not liking white in this set
They tend to be a little conservative when they print hate drops with new design space. If this one doesn't make a splash they'll probably feel more confident in printing a one drop version or a two drop with a larger tax as you propose.
Fun effect but I wish this was blue instead. IMO blue has the harder time getting rid of walkers since white has effective creatures and exile spells.
Keep yo grubby blue hands off mah white taxing!
I would be in favor of a blue version with a more in-color approach to hosing planeswalkers though. Like a 1/1 flying Bird token for each activation.
Oh I hate blue the most, just saying out easy to get rid of walkers blue has counter spells and creatures in which its the worst creature color where white has exile effects and is the second best creature color. A more in color effect for blue would also be welcome.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
“There are no weak Jews. I am descended from those who wrestle angels and kill giants. We were chosen by God. You were chosen by a pathetic little man who can't seem to grow a full mustache"
"You can tell how dumb someone is by how they use Mary Sue"
Should have been an increase of two per ability not one.this guy has one job and he fails at it unless you have a bunch in play. At least give him two toughness so Chandra can't ping him easily.
Not liking white in this set
They tend to be a little conservative when they print hate drops with new design space. If this one doesn't make a splash they'll probably feel more confident in printing a one drop version or a two drop with a larger tax as you propose.
Fun effect but I wish this was blue instead. IMO blue has the harder time getting rid of walkers since white has effective creatures and exile spells.
Keep yo grubby blue hands off mah white taxing!
I would be in favor of a blue version with a more in-color approach to hosing planeswalkers though. Like a 1/1 flying Bird token for each activation.
Oh I hate blue the most, just saying out easy to get rid of walkers blue has counter spells and creatures in which its the worst creature color where white has exile effects and is the second best creature color. A more in color effect for blue would also be welcome.
Yep, I definitely agree you're right about blue needing more options against planeswalkers and planeswalker hate in general.
Not that great. I'll just pay 1 to set off my Planeswalker ultimate that wins the game whether it be on the spot, in a few turns or inevitably in the long run.
Creatures are already anti-planeswalker anyway in their ability to attack them.
I love this I’m wondering why this wasn’t in war of the spark
There's no Eidolons in Ravnica.
Ironically eidolons saw their very first cards in a ravnica set, guildpact.
I think it is a sideboard card at most, although i love the concept. 2 mana creatures already has a much better answer to PWs in the form of phyrexian revoker, this card would be much better as a functional reprint. Even if it only worked on PWs, which would still be a bad card. If a superfriends deck were to become teir one this card would be ok out the board in a deck with pressure. If oko were still around standard, he would look at this and laugh then pay one to elk it, or just laugh and ignore it other than an easy tax.
Oh I hate blue the most, just saying out easy to get rid of walkers blue has counter spells and creatures in which its the worst creature color where white has exile effects and is the second best creature color. A more in color effect for blue would also be welcome.
"You can tell how dumb someone is by how they use Mary Sue"
|| UW Jace, Vyn's Prodigy UW || UG Kenessos, Priest of Thassa (feat. Arixmethes) UG ||
Cards I still want to see created:
|| Olantin, Lost City || Pavios and Thanasis || Choryu ||
Yep, I definitely agree you're right about blue needing more options against planeswalkers and planeswalker hate in general.
Creatures are already anti-planeswalker anyway in their ability to attack them.
Ironically eidolons saw their very first cards in a ravnica set, guildpact.
I think it is a sideboard card at most, although i love the concept. 2 mana creatures already has a much better answer to PWs in the form of phyrexian revoker, this card would be much better as a functional reprint. Even if it only worked on PWs, which would still be a bad card. If a superfriends deck were to become teir one this card would be ok out the board in a deck with pressure. If oko were still around standard, he would look at this and laugh then pay one to elk it, or just laugh and ignore it other than an easy tax.
I think its a very great set, just not this card.