Nah, in magic there are things that can be stretch through...
Especially death from astral world and alternate parallel.
Saying Ravinica has no underworld or Gideon soul is traped in Ravnica is lack of understanding with that plane.
Spirits, Zombie, Spectre and etc are once dead people. And those creatures type were among the most popular in Ravnica.
Concluding something that is a fantasy fiction is poor analogy.
Does a dead planeswalker even loses his spark lol? Can spirits be planeswalkers? Can they planeswalk, There so many possibilties, loop holes and open ended conclusion.
They could even pulled in that Gids wasnt dead and the whole thing was change because "a wizard did it" ... jace or whatsoever. It was sn illusion..
Or gideon is on suspended animation or what ever dreaming endlessly like superman in a coma or like cap trapped in a huge icebergs.
But justifying that a new gideon card would never be printed again as an mtg card is poor analogy and probably never knew the history of fantasy and fiction in magic not just the plane.
It's like saying wolverine is dead because a particular perspective was introduce but later another perspective was reveal that undid the other. In other words retcon like what a happened originally to Bolas.
Also they added so much bull***** lately (planeswalking dogs, planeswalking trees, twin sparks TWICE, artificial nyxborn with a spark, being able to take someone with you as you planeswalk because you are Kaya) that the soul of Gideon travelling to Theros postmortem isn't even close
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
How i feel about competitive players and casual players in EDH: The competitive are german tourists, the casual are italian tourists, both in a italian beach. The italians asking themselves "why are the germans here?" make a legitimate question, the answer is because the beach is beautiful, no matter the country you came from. The italians wanting to ban the germans are dumb, because if the germans pay for their stay and follow the rules like everyone else, they have the right to be in the beach. Hovewer, if the germans started to ask themselves "why are the italians here?"... they would be dumb as hell.
There is a big monowhite hole in Theros pantheon right now. If they don't fill it with Gideon, they are doing it wrong.
I mean, seeing how theran apotheosis works, he wouldn't need to be resurrected or anything, people just have to believe in the idea of him and the god created this way will have features and characteristics of Gideon (or may even identify as him) without actually being the same person. It could happen, he just needs a big enough cult following him... this card indicates that something like this may already be starting.
Also the whole "once you're a god you've always been a god" thing, so technically gideon has always been the white god.
Elspeth was back after were introduced how the theoros underworld works. Which we view differently before.
Ixalan and Inistrad has it after death. Same as Ravnica from
The thing about Gideon being special on Theros was just recently introduced, but in initial presentation it wasn't.
It make sense that Gideon had a strong follwing have been in Ravnica not in Theros.
Its weird that they choose Theros when he was supposed to be just great but not something that equals his Ravnica momements, since his in the initial theros escapade not something to fit those following.
And his greates moments is either in Zendikar or Ravnica.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Especially death from astral world and alternate parallel.
Saying Ravinica has no underworld or Gideon soul is traped in Ravnica is lack of understanding with that plane.
Spirits, Zombie, Spectre and etc are once dead people. And those creatures type were among the most popular in Ravnica.
Concluding something that is a fantasy fiction is poor analogy.
Does a dead planeswalker even loses his spark lol? Can spirits be planeswalkers? Can they planeswalk, There so many possibilties, loop holes and open ended conclusion.
They could even pulled in that Gids wasnt dead and the whole thing was change because "a wizard did it" ... jace or whatsoever. It was sn illusion..
Or gideon is on suspended animation or what ever dreaming endlessly like superman in a coma or like cap trapped in a huge icebergs.
But justifying that a new gideon card would never be printed again as an mtg card is poor analogy and probably never knew the history of fantasy and fiction in magic not just the plane.
It's like saying wolverine is dead because a particular perspective was introduce but later another perspective was reveal that undid the other. In other words retcon like what a happened originally to Bolas.
Do even people believe that Bolas would never ever return? I dont even believe he would be even killed. Lol
Also the whole "once you're a god you've always been a god" thing, so technically gideon has always been the white god.
Ixalan and Inistrad has it after death. Same as Ravnica from
The thing about Gideon being special on Theros was just recently introduced, but in initial presentation it wasn't.
It make sense that Gideon had a strong follwing have been in Ravnica not in Theros.
Its weird that they choose Theros when he was supposed to be just great but not something that equals his Ravnica momements, since his in the initial theros escapade not something to fit those following.
And his greates moments is either in Zendikar or Ravnica.