MTG Salvation

I like this at uncommon, looking forward to Limited shenanigans.

Quote from Marquisd »

https://www.facebook.com/FaceToFaceGamesToronto/app/957366404318304/



Here have a servo I'll take your Emrakul

"Hey, your negotiations are shrewd, but I'm not that dumb! Emrakul isn't an artifact! This is an unfair trade!"

EDIT: Wow, I'm a maroon. I completely skipped over "Or creature." A thousand apologies.

This seems more likely to be a thing than, say, Switcheroo or Shifting Loyalties.

But we're talking like a 1.5% chance instead of a 1% chance.

Hmmmm. Here's my Servo. I'd like your Emrakul please!

That art is so cute.

That's going to be a good in artifact edh decks

Memnarch comes to mind. Do the spell then get it back with the ability.

In limited this will be crazy, play Some random Puzzleknot, get a tiny effect, swap it for their bomb?

Can't wait to give you my servo token in exchange for your limited bomb.

Selling an artifact to buy, potentially, a creature? The implication is that Kaladesh has a slave trade, then? I don't think I've seen any other indications of that, but I haven't been following the plane's story too carefully just yet.

Combos with Bronze Bombshell

Can I target something with this, targeting my clue or puzzleknot, and pop the knot in response, and they get nothing? I know it would cost 7 or 8, but do I get their thing?

Quote from Bork »

Can I target something with this, targeting my clue or puzzleknot, and pop the knot in response, and they get nothing? I know it would cost 7 or 8, but do I get their thing?

No. Exchanges don't occur unless both sides remain valid.

701.8a A spell or ability may instruct players to exchange something (for example, life totals or control of two permanents) as part of its resolution. When such a spell or ability resolves, if the entire exchange can’t be completed, no part of the exchange occurs.

Plant for cursed artifacts stolen out of tombs in Amonkhet!

I think I prefer switcheroo just because of the name

Quote from Dynamite_Private »

Plant for cursed artifacts stolen out of tombs in Amonkhet!

RETURN THE SLAAAAAAAB.

OR SUFFER MY CUUUUUUUURSE.

Quote from Azurhawk »

Geeze... get a clue!

I joined this thread just to say "Here, let me give you a Clue." but you beat me to it.

Quote from Bork »

Can I target something with this, targeting my clue or puzzleknot, and pop the knot in response, and they get nothing? I know it would cost 7 or 8, but do I get their thing?

I'm pretty sure, in that case, the game would see nothing to exchange for their permanent and thus their Emrakul (or whatever you were trying to steal) will just sit where it is. Nice try though.

EDIT- I was mostly right, but also kind of wrong. Ruling from Switcheroo:

If one of the target creatures is an illegal target when Switcheroo resolves, the exchange won’t happen. If both creatures are illegal targets, Switcheroo will be countered. (Source- http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=253704)

So, since you sac'd your thing in response, it won't be a legal target when the spell resolves and thus the spell will fizzle.

Was going to say this is a slightly worse Legerdemain but I noticed you can exchange an aritfact for a creature. So I like this card... here have this mana rock that's just wasting away in my field and let me get something cooler from you buddy!

Pretty decent card. This set is looking interesting so far.

Here,take my Immortal Coil and I'll have whatever.

So now I can take someone's Emrakul,
and tell them to get a clue?

Hah, now that's good flavor.

In other hand, Shifting Loyalties was a junk uncommon...
Steel Golem, anyone?

T4 Thought-Knot Seer, T5 Shrewd Negotiation, Clutch of Currents, T6 Thought-Knot?

EDIT: misread the mana cost... feeling dumb...

Emrakul, the Aeons Torn can't be targeted by this spell. Emrakul, the Promised End can, but I'm not sure which one you guys are talking about.