MTG Salvation

(Double-faced) creature card, because this is a great opportunity to get that Legendary Werewolf!!

What I want to see is Chains of Mephistopheles on legs, so I voted artifact.

I just love Lands... I couldn't resist. I think this is a great way for us (the community) to create an amazing land

We could make Barry's Land! Force them to give us a tap for grey EDH land finally!

Now I'm torn between Fblthp or that..

One should note that they're still going to develop the card, so it won't truly be a broken 1R

I voted land... we've already made a creature, artifact, and instant. I figure that a land is more interesting than an enchantment.

I chose land because I so desperately want Geomantic Bluff to be an actual thing, and will pretend this has any chance of making it one.

Voted enchantment... I'd like to see them push enchantments some. Artifacts are very broad,. There's still lots of room for development on lands, honestly I think Wizards is capable expanding on that on their own. We need to show wizards the interesting things they should be willing to do with enchantments. Color restrictions allow for more interesting gameplay in general. I want to see an enchantment that does something fresh or does something more efficiently - to the point that people feel a need to react to it immediately.

I don't want to see enchantments that turn into creatures til EOT, or create tokens...or are just some kind of Seal...i don't want to create some impossible to comprehend repeatable effect that gets bigger and becomes a mind numbing threat that causes your opponent to scoop.

I want a threat on the table and I want it to cost 3 or less.

I don't even like enchantments that much, though I think it has something to do with their weaker design. I know the result may not necessarily be based on our votes and if we go too far, Wizards will ignore those ... more outrageous requests, but we have the potential to make this interesting.

Enchantment for me. They're often cards you can build around and definitely have the most potential for cool unusual effects.

This is a chance for Red to get a 2 Drop creature on par w/ goyf!

Enchantment. Too long since we had a relevant enchantment. I miss stuff like The Abyss...

I want a contraption!

I see people are taking my sig into account ;).

Quote from WacKy ZacKy

This is a chance for Red to get a 2 Drop creature on par w/ goyf!

Ugh. Can people stop saying things like this.

Wizards has stated that every card in the pseudocycle was a mistake on the part of R&D. The only one I'm not absolutely sure of being publicly denounced by them is confidant, and I can't see them standing behind Bob.

Contrary to popular conspiracies Wizards doesn't intentionally make imbalanced cards. It isn't in the best interest of the game's health.

I voted "land." Lands are just too handy!

I wasn't paying attention to ymtc the last two times, how is the rules text determined?

Quote from Belgareth

If we are going to complete imaginary card cycles I'd much rather have a land than a red creature.
Hell why don't we shoot for a black version of the tolarian academy , gaeas cradle serra sanctum type while we are at it that taps for number of cards in graveyard.

They are not going to let people design some overpowered bonkers card unless it happens to happen by utter mistake, but don't vote thinking that is what you will get.

Cabal Coffers and Crypt of Agadeem are mad that you missed them. What we really need is a red big mana land.

i voted land due to lands being my favorite card type and the most important card type in magic. here's to hoping a planeswalker ymtc in the future even though it likely wwill never happen

Land. Just something along the lines of Tectonic Edge/Horizon Canopy power level, not necessarily land destruction or card drawing.

It was close for me, but I went with land. I wanted to vote instant/sorcery because I hate how that card type has been getting overshadowed so strongly by creatures in modern card design. On the other hand, we desperately need a good Wasteland analogue for modern to punish greedy manabases. In a format where many decks are trying to break the turn 4 kill mark, Tectonic Edge doesn't cut it. I don't have much hope of any land we design actually stepping up and providing that service, but would still be nice to see.

I went with Land, I would interested in seeing what unique Land can come from this and would love to see a new Manland or a design like Urami

Maybe like reflecting pool:
Tap add 1 Color any land you control could produce
5, tap all other lands you control: ~ Becomes a 5/5 Flying, Lifelink creature of all colors until eot

Obviously I chose creature so that we can finally make a rigger that can actually assemble a contraption!

(Steamflogger Boss)

So...we make Fortress of Will?

Voted for Artifact.

I want another strong Equipment for Commander.

A land making all colors with some restriction like city of brass or pillar of the paruns would be nice.