So I was playing Duels 2012 and I had Elixir of Immortality in play and Aether Tradewinds in my hand. I thought that putting the Elixir ability on the stack and then responding with the Winds would allow me to gain the 5 life, bounce a permanent my opponent controlled, and keep the Elixir in my hand. Instead, I gained the life and the Elixir and my graveyard were shuffled into my library. Am I in the wrong or was this a game mistake?
This is one of those times. What you expected to happen is what should have happened.