So say I play Numbing Dose on my opponent's creature. Then, later on in their turn/a few turns later, they play Asceticism. What happens to my Enchantment?
1) It stays and continues to do everything.
2) It stays, but they may still untap their creature during the upkeep step, and their controller takes 1 damage.
3) It stays and nothing happens.
4) It dies.
5) I lose.
6) They lose.
7) We all lose.
W may only be paid with white mana. U may only be paid with blue mana. B may only be paid with black mana. R may only be paid with red mana. G may only be paid with green mana. C may only be paid with colorless mana. 1 may be paid with white, blue, black, red, green, or clolorless mana.
It's worth noting, I feel, that giving that creature protection from the color of the aura will destroy the aura.
This is technically wrong, although it has the same effect in most cases. What actually happens is that state-based actions will cause the aura to become unattached from the creature, following which they will put the aura into its owner's graveyard because auras aren't allowed to be on the battlefield without being attached to anything.
So because of the state-based effects, any auras on a creature before asceticism comes out, would be therefor unattached from the creature... because they target the creature still? My brother has found forums that say the enchantment, aura, doesn't target the creature no more therefor wont be affected by asceticism play onto the battlefield, which i disagree with because the enchantment, like equipments and other cards, are attached to the creature, therefor targeting the creature that has the enchantment, artifact, or any other card that could attach itself to it...
That's incorrect. An aura spell only targets while on the stack. An aura permanent is not targeting the thing it's attached to. It would only become unattached if the "Enchant [thing]" becomes invalid (e.g., an aura with "Enchant Creature" is on an animated Inkmoth Nexus that stops being a creature when the turn ends), or the thing it's attached to gains protection from a quality of that aura (e.g., Mind Control on a creature that later gains protection from blue).
Being attached to something is not the same as targeting something. A permanent can never target something, though a permanent is often the source of an ability that targets something.
Private Mod Note
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Level 3 Judge
This FAQ answers many of the common questions asked in the MTGS Rulings forum. Take a look!
I'm the editor/content manager of the Magic Rules Tips Blog - Bookmark this site for daily tips about game and tournament rules.
"Abstract concepts of perfect judging run headlong into the realities of how people play the game." - Toby Elliott (papa_funk)