What does "cast" mean?

  • #1
    Mostly I'm thinking about how older cards used to say a spell had to be "successfully cast"....which I thought meant resolve. I just want to make sure I CAN use Momir Vig's first ability whenever I play a green critter.

    You need card tags in future posts. Read the Forum Guidelines.
    - Woapalanne
    Last edited by Woapalanne: 7/8/2010 11:20:22 AM
    Mirri, Cat Warrior counts as a Cat Warrior.
  • #2
    'Cast' means the process of moving a card or copy of a card onto the stack, choosings modes, division of damage, targets and so forth, and paying it's costs. What older cards used to say doesn't really matter. As far as I can make out, the 'successfully' bit was in case you cast a spell illegally and had to take it back. It certainly had nothing to do with resolving.

    EDIT: Apparently I was wrong on that last point. Hey, I started in 2002, I'm a comparative newbie! Redface
    Last edited by viperesque: 7/8/2010 8:43:56 AM
    My sig broke.
  • #4
    Casting a spell means putting it on the stack, making all the required choices for it, and paying its costs if any. Once that process is done, the spell is considered cast, and before players would get priority to respond to the spell, abilities that trigger "Whenever you cast a spell" trigger and go on the stack.

    The old pre-6th edition "successfully" wording, if I recall well, really made it so that the triggered ability didn't happen (those didn't use the stack back then, anyway nothing did since there was no stack). There was what was called the "Interrupt window" that would open right after each spell each was cast, allowing other players to respond with Interrupts such as counterspells, and the "when you successfully cast" abilities would happen only if the spell "passed" that window (I think).
    Last edited by MadMageQc: 7/8/2010 8:29:58 AM
    DCI Lvl 1 Judge

    Madness, My Sadness
    I Am My Own Savior
    -Iced Earth
  • #5
    Yeah, old cards that triggered on "successfully cast" didn't trigger if the spell was countered by an interrupt. All of this is, of course, long since history.
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.
Posts Quoted:
Clear All Quotes