So I was playing a game last night and came across some things with dungeon of the mad mage I had questions about.
Exile top 2 cards of your library, you may play them
I understand this only applies to this one time, in that I won't be able to cast these creatures from exile after this point if I so choose not to cast them once the dungeon ability is resolved, correct?
Secondly, I got to the very last trigger of the dungeon anddddd drew 3 lands. This occurred after I had already played a land that turn, and we reasoned since the trigger states you may play a card without paying its cost, and lands don't cost anything to cast, that i couldn't use the ability to play a land anyways. Is this the case? Can I play a land this way, what about a second land?
Lastly, for both situations, the exiled cards, or the 3 cards drawn at the last trigger, if this occurs on opponents turn can I play a land? Or is that completely trumped by the never play a land on an opponents turn?
So I was playing a game last night and came across some things with dungeon of the mad mage I had questions about.
Exile top 2 cards of your library, you may play them
I understand this only applies to this one time, in that I won't be able to cast these creatures from exile after this point if I so choose not to cast them once the dungeon ability is resolved, correct?
Yes, you are given an option to do a thing with either or both and if you decline then that's the end of the effect.
Secondly, I got to the very last trigger of the dungeon anddddd drew 3 lands. This occurred after I had already played a land that turn, and we reasoned since the trigger states you may play a card without paying its cost, and lands don't cost anything to cast, that i couldn't use the ability to play a land anyways. Is this the case? Can I play a land this way, what about a second land?
You can't cast lands, only spells. Lands are played.
Lastly, for both situations, the exiled cards, or the 3 cards drawn at the last trigger, if this occurs on opponents turn can I play a land? Or is that completely trumped by the never play a land on an opponents turn?
You can never play a land on another player's turn. CR305.3
Also, you cannot play a land if you've played as many lands as you're allowed to play this turn (usually 1).
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Epic banner by Erasmus of æтђєг.
Awesome avatar provided by Krashbot @ [Epic Graphics].
So, at least it seems we did everything correctly, but I did learn from your post to differentiate between the wording "cast" vs. "Play", so when It says you may cast one of the 3, lands are excluded.
So basically, by drawing 3 lands as the last trigger I was royally screwed over. Lovely!
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Exile top 2 cards of your library, you may play them
I understand this only applies to this one time, in that I won't be able to cast these creatures from exile after this point if I so choose not to cast them once the dungeon ability is resolved, correct?
Secondly, I got to the very last trigger of the dungeon anddddd drew 3 lands. This occurred after I had already played a land that turn, and we reasoned since the trigger states you may play a card without paying its cost, and lands don't cost anything to cast, that i couldn't use the ability to play a land anyways. Is this the case? Can I play a land this way, what about a second land?
Lastly, for both situations, the exiled cards, or the 3 cards drawn at the last trigger, if this occurs on opponents turn can I play a land? Or is that completely trumped by the never play a land on an opponents turn?
Yes, you are given an option to do a thing with either or both and if you decline then that's the end of the effect.
You can't cast lands, only spells. Lands are played.
You can never play a land on another player's turn. CR305.3
Also, you cannot play a land if you've played as many lands as you're allowed to play this turn (usually 1).
Awesome avatar provided by Krashbot @ [Epic Graphics].
So basically, by drawing 3 lands as the last trigger I was royally screwed over. Lovely!