I'm new to this forum and could use a little help. My partner has the sword of feast and famine card and is using it in a green deck. Is that legal? Creature has protection from black and green but the Creature itself is green....any help would be great.
This should be in the Rulings Forum as you will get a much quicker response. Also, please use card tags: Sword of Feast and Famine.
Sword has a colorless color identity. It can go into any deck. Having color words do not affect color identity at all so they could have had it in a mono-Blue deck if they wanted. Animar, Soul of Elements wouldn't make sense otherwise as a Temur general.
If the concern is about putting it onto a green creature because you think Protection will make it fall off, that is incorrect as well. Protection applies to the creature so their green creature now has Protection from Green and Black but the Sword remains because the Sword is colorless. Creatures can have protection from their own colors just fine.
If there is still something more in terms of why you think that wouldn't be legal, let us know so we can address that concern specifically.
Sword has a colorless color identity. It can go into any deck. Having color words do not affect color identity at all so they could have had it in a mono-Blue deck if they wanted. Animar, Soul of Elements wouldn't make sense otherwise as a Temur general.
If the concern is about putting it onto a green creature because you think Protection will make it fall off, that is incorrect as well. Protection applies to the creature so their green creature now has Protection from Green and Black but the Sword remains because the Sword is colorless. Creatures can have protection from their own colors just fine.
If there is still something more in terms of why you think that wouldn't be legal, let us know so we can address that concern specifically.