Does Adventure work with Rebound?
1) If I have Narset Transcendent and activate her -2 and then I cast Giant Killer for his Adventure "Chop Down", may I put it into exile as it resolves and cast it again in my next upkeep due to Rebound and may I then, after resolving another "Chop Down" successfully, put it into exile again and cast it as creature from there?
2) Same example, but when I cast the Rebounded Giant Killer in my upkeep, may I cast the creature part instead of the instant Adventure part? So do I get to choose what to cast in that Rebound cast?
If the Adventure replacement effect exiles an Adventure spell instead of putting it into its owner's graveyard as it resolves (the effect is thus similar to rebound's [C.R. 702.88a], but note that it's not optional in this respect), the resulting card can be cast by whoever that spell's controller was, but not as an Adventure, "[f]or as long as that card remains exiled" (C.R. 716.3d).
In general, if two or more replacement effects would affect where a spell would go, that spell's controller chooses one of them to apply (C.R. 616.1). If you're that player and those replacement effects are rebound (C.R. 702.88a) and the replacement effect for Adventures, you choose one and the other will be inapplicable since the spell is no longer going to the graveyard (C.R. 616.1, 616.1d-e). Notably:
If the rebound replacement effect is chosen this way, you may cast the resulting card "at the beginning of your next upkeep", and in general, in the case of adventurer cards, you can do so either normally or as an Adventure, regardless of what card types it has (C.R. 608.2f, under C.R. 702.88a, rebound doesn't limit what a player can cast that card as).
If the Adventure replacement effect is chosen this way, you may cast the resulting card from exile, but not as an Adventure (C.R. 716.3d), but it can be cast this way "[f]or as long as that card remains exiled" (C.R. 716.3d), not just "at the beginning of your next upkeep", and, in general, only any time you could normally cast a card of its type (without regard to its Adventure part) (C.R. 117.1a for spells).
See also this thread, which explains the timing rules that apply to certain effects that let a player cast a spell.
EDIT (Oct. 1): Edited to conform to rules update with Throne of Eldraine.
EDIT (Nov. 3): Correctness edit and clarification.
EDIT (Dec. 4): Correctness edit.
EDIT (Aug. 1): Added new and relevant link, among other things.
EDIT (Jun. 5): Edited, including to update rule renumberings.
Also note that you can use Rebound - then cast the Adventure part (for free) from the rebound trigger - THEN it'll sit in exile and wait for you to cast the creature later
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Does Adventure work with Rebound?
1) If I have Narset Transcendent and activate her -2 and then I cast Giant Killer for his Adventure "Chop Down", may I put it into exile as it resolves and cast it again in my next upkeep due to Rebound and may I then, after resolving another "Chop Down" successfully, put it into exile again and cast it as creature from there?
2) Same example, but when I cast the Rebounded Giant Killer in my upkeep, may I cast the creature part instead of the instant Adventure part? So do I get to choose what to cast in that Rebound cast?
In general, if two or more replacement effects would affect where a spell would go, that spell's controller chooses one of them to apply (C.R. 616.1). If you're that player and those replacement effects are rebound (C.R. 702.88a) and the replacement effect for Adventures, you choose one and the other will be inapplicable since the spell is no longer going to the graveyard (C.R. 616.1, 616.1d-e). Notably:
See also this thread, which explains the timing rules that apply to certain effects that let a player cast a spell.
EDIT (Oct. 1): Edited to conform to rules update with Throne of Eldraine.
EDIT (Nov. 3): Correctness edit and clarification.
EDIT (Dec. 4): Correctness edit.
EDIT (Aug. 1): Added new and relevant link, among other things.
EDIT (Jun. 5): Edited, including to update rule renumberings.