MTG Salvation

Quote from Cantripmancer

I'm leading the organization of October's MCC; if you are interested in helping design the rounds and answer questions for that month, please PM me. Participation as an organizer will, of course, disqualify you from playing for the month, so we encourage all organizers to also judge, but that is not a requirement.

I could help with October. I have never helped organize before, so just shoot me a pm with details.

The second challenge for Round 2 requires: "No keyword abilities". I assume that this does not cover ability words like Chroma and Hellbent, and that these are still fair game, right?

Yeah, they're okay.

I forgot how do you post the hybrid colorless and colored mana symbols in the text card?

or [MANA]{2w}[/MANA] becomes (2/W)

Quote from Cantripmancer

I'm leading the organization of October's MCC; if you are interested in helping design the rounds and answer questions for that month, please PM me. Participation as an organizer will, of course, disqualify you from playing for the month, so we encourage all organizers to also judge, but that is not a requirement.

I was planning on judging next month, so if you need help organizing I'm up for it.

Quote from Moss_Elemental

or [mana]{2w}[/mana] becomes (2/W)

Thanks Moss

The second round challenge specifies abilities, so keyworded actions like Regenerate or Sacrifice don't qualify, correct?

Regenerate is a keyword action. Sacrifice is a "defined" word, so sacrifice is fine. Regenerate probably isn't, but wait for Moss_Elemental to give a definite answer.

Regenerate and Sacrifice are okay, for the reasons Aurora stated.

Out of curiosity is my judge an actual judge or an entry because he has an entry.

Kensei is a judge. The "Hypothetical Entry" is something Megiddo originally did in June. Then after that point, I started doing it every month when I judged, and now Kensei's continuing with it here. It's a "what I would do if I was playing" thing; it's not a real entry. I'm judging his card, and he's also judging mine (even though they're not counted within the actual scores for the players).

Ok cool i was just a bit confused a bit there.

My Sept. Round 2 judging are DONE.

Darn i wish flavor was still a major judging category it was always my way of racking up those points, but hey next month is my birthday month so who knows my talent that got me to a finals in the old FCC may appear. Good luck to the winners of my group.

For september round 2 judgings click here.

For the results of my bracket, as well as the story why there aren't detailed judgings present (yet), clickety here.

Quote from Kronik

For september round 2 judgings click here.

This has got to be, like, the highest scoring bracket ever...

Quote from Kronik

For september round 2 judgings click here.

Just a note: a card you gave the perfect score has a (small) templating issue.

Quote from zweet

Just a note: a card you gave the perfect score has a (small) templating issue.

Actually, there are several "small" templating mistakes (in bold):

Karlos von Nebelheim - :1mana::symu::symb::symb:
Legendary Creature - Vampire Rogue Wizard
When Karlos von Nebelheim enters the battlefield, put a mist counter on all each Vampires creature you control. Vampires creatures with mist counters on them have "If this creature would be destroyed, instead it phases out instead.".
Don't be fooled by his seemingly youthful and fragile appearance. He has traversed the marshland mists for generations... (Non-MtG-technical english isn't my strong point, but I'm almost sure that there should be a period, not a comma.)
1/1

You actually missed the biggest issue: if its ability is ment to work only while Karlos is on the battlefield, second sentence must be on a separate line; otherwise it should be reworded to resemble Aven Mimeomancer.

Yes, Sir. I missed that because I didn't read paid attention to what the card does. Just corrected the more obvious ones.

Damn! Why did I missed that? Question: Is it allowed to modify the judgings after they've been posted but before the deadline is over? I feel that I should straighten this out.

They are your judgings so you can do whatever you want before the deadline. Especially if it would change something in the final outcome.