Tordeck, so you mean that you are not telling us if you are town or not.
Great. That is very mafia.
That's not good logic. Think about it a bit and get back to me as to why...
I have been trying to decide if I should hard counterclaim Seppel or not, but the more I think about it, the more I believe he and I are just similar parts of the town cog and it isn't a counterclaim. He claimed bodyguard so I will let you all figure out what I might be claiming here, it doesn't take a rocket scientist.
Because I think spewing information into the thread for the mafia to exploit is a bad thing? Yeah that makes me so scummy.
Can you see how coordination would be more helpful to town than scum though? I don't think people should be talking about their abilities, but lining everything up so that we get them seems at least useful.
@Hunt: Are you trying to breadcrumb or just being deliberately coy? I'd have preferred you not say anything at all, especially a counterclaim to seppel, who I don't even believe on his abilities. There are only two reasons to claim the way he did:
A: draw the nightkill because you don't have a power role
B: avoid a lynch as scum.
At this point I don't see him as scummy, so option A seems more likely (or the Wine of it anyway).
Because I think spewing information into the thread for the mafia to exploit is a bad thing? Yeah that makes me so scummy.
Can you see how coordination would be more helpful to town than scum though? I don't think people should be talking about their abilities, but lining everything up so that we get them seems at least useful.
2011: Best Mafia Performance (Individual) - Best Newcomer
2012: Best (False?) Role Claim - Worst Town Performance (Group) - Best Mafia Performance (Group) - Best SK Performance - Best Overall Player
2013: Best Non-SK Neutral Performance
2014: Best Town Performance (Individual) - Best Town Performance (Group) - Most Interesting Role - Best Game - Best Overall Player
2015: Worst Mafia Performance (Group) - Best Read
2016: Best Town Performance (Group) - Best Town Player - Best Overall Player
Hm. I'm not necessarily sold on Ophidia being clear due to asking how many mafia there are.
Tordeck is kinda posting defensively and seems frustrated at the idea of town trying to coordinate by fearmonering it as "giving mafia too much information."
Because I think spewing information into the thread for the mafia to exploit is a bad thing? Yeah that makes me so scummy.
Can you see how coordination would be more helpful to town than scum though? I don't think people should be talking about their abilities, but lining everything up so that we get them seems at least useful.
@Hunt: Are you trying to breadcrumb or just being deliberately coy? I'd have preferred you not say anything at all, especially a counterclaim to seppel, who I don't even believe on his abilities. There are only two reasons to claim the way he did:
A: draw the nightkill because you don't have a power role
B: avoid a lynch as scum.
At this point I don't see him as scummy, so option A seems more likely (or the Wine of it anyway).
That's way more than a crumb, and there was nothing coy about it. Blatant if you ask me.
Why don't you believe Seppel's abilities? Why can't those two abilities go together specifically?
Hm. I'm not necessarily sold on Ophidia being clear due to asking how many mafia there are.
Tordeck is kinda posting defensively and seems frustrated at the idea of town trying to coordinate by fearmonering it as "giving mafia too much information."
That is not scum!Tordeck though. That is town!Tordeck. Scum!Tordeck let's the whole situation happen and uses it to his advantage, all the while not denouncing the idea. Saw it happen once in an off-site game where Tordeck was scum.
@Hunt: fair enough, I still think you would have just done better to open claim of you were going to anyway, but that's neither here nor there.
It's not that I don't believe Seppel's role is possible, even in combination with another power role (like what I think you mean), it's that claiming in his first post of an exceptionally strong power role feels more like reaction baiting than open claiming. That and it draws some serious heat for a nightkill. So yeah, it could be wine, but that seems less likely without having a feel of the group.
@Tordeck: what are your thoughts on Zomg and his claim?
Tordeck called me out as 3rd on seppel wagon. When i vote seppel every time. It's my ****in meta.
Tordeck pointing out a detail like that screams scum to me. Esspecially if he sees it as a bad thing. I don't care who i vote for in RVS. I vote you and move on.
You even know this.
unvote vote Seppel
@Fuq and Tordeck: Why is me being 3rd vote on Seppel RVS scummy? Or pings your radar or whatever.
I feel like it's another OTG happening.
I will not stand idle.
VIVA LA RISISTANCE
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Thank you for choosing
Rodemy Pizza
It’s not the best choice, but it’s a choice nonetheless
@Rodemy: how is this another speed lynch happening if the only person even voting you is Seppel? That's not like OTG2 at all...
@Vaimes: On Zomg claiming neutral, thoughts?
@Everyone: let's try and kick this game into gear, things have definitely slowed down. So what are everyone's thoughts on the amount of info already in this thread, too much, too little?
2011: Best Mafia Performance (Individual) - Best Newcomer
2012: Best (False?) Role Claim - Worst Town Performance (Group) - Best Mafia Performance (Group) - Best SK Performance - Best Overall Player
2013: Best Non-SK Neutral Performance
2014: Best Town Performance (Individual) - Best Town Performance (Group) - Most Interesting Role - Best Game - Best Overall Player
2015: Worst Mafia Performance (Group) - Best Read
2016: Best Town Performance (Group) - Best Town Player - Best Overall Player
@Vaimes: I kind of agree, I'm pretty certain Oph is town, you can only fake so many derp clears. Especially since I had him as town lean already. I'm not sure if Rodemy's clocking him is from a scum mindset or just a Rodemy mindset.
@Vaimes: I kind of agree, I'm pretty certain Oph is town, you can only fake so many derp clears. Especially since I had him as town lean already. I'm not sure if Rodemy's clocking him is from a scum mindset or just a Rodemy mindset.
Def the latter.
I mean think about it.
You'd think he'd include a guy he accused of being scum in his "list"
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Thank you for choosing
Rodemy Pizza
It’s not the best choice, but it’s a choice nonetheless
Rodemy also flags for me as the third vote on that wagon.
oh hell no.
I vote sepple every. Time.
Trying to build up a mislynch there, buddy?
I see you tryin with ophi.
VOTE TORDECK
How did none of you realize that the third vote on the seppel wagon was from Hunt and not from Rod?
And seriously people, let's get some action going here. vote Fuquet talk to me about where you're at this game. Impressions on people?
Oh I'm slightly dumb, Rodemy's vote was the third, but then Oph unvoted. It still seems odd that you all said nothing about Hunt being another vote ton that wagon though.
We have completely stalemate. We need a flip to get this game rolling.
@shadow. Why wouldn't I vote someone I wanted to counterclaim? Why does where a vote happen on a wagon matter? Seppel didn't get lynched either which means a few things if you think about it.
Ewwww again.
@Seppel
You need to tell me why this is newb town not noob scum. Pretty please.
If I'm your top scum read, yes.
Win if I'm Janken' town.
Lose if I'm Janken' Mafia.
You're doing it wrong. That's not good logic. Think about it a bit and get back to me as to why...
I have been trying to decide if I should hard counterclaim Seppel or not, but the more I think about it, the more I believe he and I are just similar parts of the town cog and it isn't a counterclaim. He claimed bodyguard so I will let you all figure out what I might be claiming here, it doesn't take a rocket scientist.
Nope.
Unvote, vote rodemy
I answered his "elaborate please*
Seppel stop this nonsence. Hunt is not top scum read.
Can you see how coordination would be more helpful to town than scum though? I don't think people should be talking about their abilities, but lining everything up so that we get them seems at least useful.
@Hunt: Are you trying to breadcrumb or just being deliberately coy? I'd have preferred you not say anything at all, especially a counterclaim to seppel, who I don't even believe on his abilities. There are only two reasons to claim the way he did:
A: draw the nightkill because you don't have a power role
B: avoid a lynch as scum.
At this point I don't see him as scummy, so option A seems more likely (or the Wine of it anyway).
The Family
Fuquetlauncher (1): zomgarcwind
zomgarcwind (1): Fuquetlauncher
Seppel (2): Vaimes, Huntzilla
Ophidia (1): Tordeck
Tordeck (2): Rodemy, Ophidia
Rodemy (1): Seppel
With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.
{мы, тьма}
2012: Best (False?) Role Claim - Worst Town Performance (Group) - Best Mafia Performance (Group) - Best SK Performance - Best Overall Player
2013: Best Non-SK Neutral Performance
2014: Best Town Performance (Individual) - Best Town Performance (Group) - Most Interesting Role - Best Game - Best Overall Player
2015: Worst Mafia Performance (Group) - Best Read
2016: Best Town Performance (Group) - Best Town Player - Best Overall Player
I'm going to reread and try to at least make an actual post before bed.
zomgarcwind
Seppel
shadowlancerx
Huntzilla
Ophidia
Fuquetlauncher
Rodemy
Tordeck
---
Hm. I'm not necessarily sold on Ophidia being clear due to asking how many mafia there are.
Tordeck is kinda posting defensively and seems frustrated at the idea of town trying to coordinate by fearmonering it as "giving mafia too much information."
Why don't you believe Seppel's abilities? Why can't those two abilities go together specifically?
It's not that I don't believe Seppel's role is possible, even in combination with another power role (like what I think you mean), it's that claiming in his first post of an exceptionally strong power role feels more like reaction baiting than open claiming. That and it draws some serious heat for a nightkill. So yeah, it could be wine, but that seems less likely without having a feel of the group.
@Tordeck: what are your thoughts on Zomg and his claim?
I was about to tell Vaimes that Tordeck was the mod.
Never mind, Hunt is town.
Rodemy covered for Fuq
so..
ZOMG, shadow, Hunt, Vaimes, and myself are town. Ophidia is neutral.
Rodemy and Fuq are buddying, and ganging up on Tordeck.
Tordeck seems town but nothing conclusive there.
I'm all for straight up lynching Rodemy and Fuq.
MTGS is eating data and serving poisoned ads, so my time here on mobile will be less than usual.
Lynch Rodemy and Fuq.
I think he is scum.
Tordeck called me out as 3rd on seppel wagon. When i vote seppel every time. It's my ****in meta.
Tordeck pointing out a detail like that screams scum to me. Esspecially if he sees it as a bad thing. I don't care who i vote for in RVS. I vote you and move on.
You even know this.
unvote vote Seppel
@Fuq and Tordeck: Why is me being 3rd vote on Seppel RVS scummy? Or pings your radar or whatever.
I feel like it's another OTG happening.
I will not stand idle.
VIVA LA RISISTANCE
@Vaimes: On Zomg claiming neutral, thoughts?
@Everyone: let's try and kick this game into gear, things have definitely slowed down. So what are everyone's thoughts on the amount of info already in this thread, too much, too little?
Due to the holiday, I will extend the deadline by 3 days.
{мы, тьма}
2012: Best (False?) Role Claim - Worst Town Performance (Group) - Best Mafia Performance (Group) - Best SK Performance - Best Overall Player
2013: Best Non-SK Neutral Performance
2014: Best Town Performance (Individual) - Best Town Performance (Group) - Most Interesting Role - Best Game - Best Overall Player
2015: Worst Mafia Performance (Group) - Best Read
2016: Best Town Performance (Group) - Best Town Player - Best Overall Player
I don't really want to lynch zomg. He doesn't strike me as the "mafia fakeclaiming Neutral for no reason" type.
The Family
Hunt, you're gonna have to try harder to convince me that Tordeck is town.
Iffy: Ophidia, Fuq, Hunt
Maf: Tordeck
There.
Im town tho. And I would like to survive this night.
Wait. I'm not on this list.
but
I posted once since then.
You'd think you'd at least remember to put me on there.
Unless you don't actually care who you think is scum.
unvote
Vote ophi
Back tomorrow for some words
Or: Pairing Toddlers against Panthers
Very violent stuff
Ophi, why did you put yourself into the iffy category? Also, I'm not on this list either.
Rod is iffy and shadow is town.
DONT. YOU. DARE.
Def the latter.
I mean think about it.
You'd think he'd include a guy he accused of being scum in his "list"
Kekeke
Vote Seppel
:finger:
How did none of you realize that the third vote on the seppel wagon was from Hunt and not from Rod?
And seriously people, let's get some action going here.
vote Fuquet talk to me about where you're at this game. Impressions on people?
@Hunt: you owe us a post.
We have completely stalemate. We need a flip to get this game rolling.
@shadow. Why wouldn't I vote someone I wanted to counterclaim? Why does where a vote happen on a wagon matter? Seppel didn't get lynched either which means a few things if you think about it.
Rodemy needs to be sorted.
Unvote
VOTE Rodemy