@Zomg: Are you neutrally aligned? "Don't see me winning this one."
@Vaimes: I'm assuming you target someone at night, then whatever they picked the previous night is matched with what you picked the previous night, and you win or lose based on that, then pick rock/paper/scissors for the next night.
That's the only way I can think of it where we had to pick on night zero.
Wait then, by currency are we talking coins, cause that makes a lot more sense then.
Zomg, what is your role and win con? In a smaller game like this, neutrals are a little more risky to just let coast.
Anyone who wants to give me coins would be lovely :D. I can't use them, but it's better for town if I have them.
Ick to a neutral in a mini that leaves the game. I find it ironic that you're townier as a claimed neutral than as town.
Why are you assuming I'm not rock? You picked Rock didn't you?
Im gonna do the math between rounds tonight but I believe it's extremely hard for me to win.
And im making no assumptions i just want to see if we can scratch each others tie itch. This is my third neutral game and ive never done well in them before trying to hide the fact im neutral
I'm saying Ick to a neutral in the setup rather than to you specifically. And assuming no doc or revive shenanigans, we are looking at F3 by day 4, so you have 3 nights to succeed at things. Granted, you leaving when you win means 2 by day 4, which is very bad for town unless we achieve only one mislynch.
Buh. I'm really hoping there is something setup to counteract you leaving. I can't guarantee agreeing to ties with you every night, cause that really could end poorly, but at least today I'll claim if you do. I'd like to claim second of the two of us since I claimed needing to tie before you did.
@Oph: Being that it's a closed setup, we don't know the roles even in the game. Claiming neutral early in the game, and when he's being pretty solidly town read by several people doesn't raise any red flags for me. Granted, it is still in our best interest to not ignore his behavior, as he did just see two neutrals win in another game.
I will not divuldge my role any more than what i have.
Pushing that will only be scummy.
Shadow, all you need to know is what i told you.
I feel like i was clear on that.
Why so curious?
I don't actually want you divulge your role, I was just interested in clarification. But no worries.
I'm curious because quite frankly I think united we are stronger than divided. Six members of the town all getting the best results from their actions far outweighs 2 scum/1 neutral. So if we coordinate to set every single person up for success, we either:
A. all have ideal night actions and are better off because of it
B. Find scum that lied about their picks.
I feel like this setup presents a very real chance for town to corroborate together.
I will not divuldge my role any more than what i have.
Pushing that will only be scummy.
Shadow, all you need to know is what i told you.
I feel like i was clear on that.
Why so curious?
I don't actually want you divulge your role, I was just interested in clarification. But no worries.
I'm curious because quite frankly I think united we are stronger than divided. Six members of the town all getting the best results from their actions far outweighs 2 scum/1 neutral. So if we coordinate to set every single person up for success, we either:
A. all have ideal night actions and are better off because of it
B. Find scum that lied about their picks.
I feel like this setup presents a very real chance for town to corroborate together.
2011: Best Mafia Performance (Individual) - Best Newcomer
2012: Best (False?) Role Claim - Worst Town Performance (Group) - Best Mafia Performance (Group) - Best SK Performance - Best Overall Player
2013: Best Non-SK Neutral Performance
2014: Best Town Performance (Individual) - Best Town Performance (Group) - Most Interesting Role - Best Game - Best Overall Player
2015: Worst Mafia Performance (Group) - Best Read
2016: Best Town Performance (Group) - Best Town Player - Best Overall Player
@Everyone: what are your thoughts on Zomg being neutral? Do you believe his claim?
Zomg is very much suspect to me. Irregular vibes since I started. (Yes, I am new to the game and in between work and adult stuff, trying to learn the ropes.)
You're welcome.
Since I am a complete noob to forum mafia, how many mafs do we have?
Tordeck has been accusing people lately, so [b]Vote Tordeck[/b].
O.o what are you getting held up by? Also, would you prefer to win or lose or tie your games?
My role is weird and very specific.
If my target is town, I want to lose.
If my target is scum, I want to win.
Ties result in nothing.
@Vaimes: I'm assuming you target someone at night, then whatever they picked the previous night is matched with what you picked the previous night, and you win or lose based on that, then pick rock/paper/scissors for the next night.
That's the only way I can think of it where we had to pick on night zero.
I don't know what sort of currency your role has, but my guess is that part is specific to you.
Depending on if I win or lose.
there was no particular order to that list.
Did you want me to vote you?
My role is more player based.
Lose against me is good for you
Tie is nothing
Winning against me is bad for scum.
I work much better with coins.
Or just busy? Slow your swag there, buddy.
Zomg, what is your role and win con? In a smaller game like this, neutrals are a little more risky to just let coast.
Anyone who wants to give me coins would be lovely :D. I can't use them, but it's better for town if I have them.
Why are you assuming I'm not rock? You picked Rock didn't you?
Also, I still think everyone should tell me if they want to win/lose/tie. Launcher/hunt/tordeck are our hold outs.
Rodemy, can you clarify if it's beneficial for someone to target you and win, or for you to target someone and lose?
I'm saying Ick to a neutral in the setup rather than to you specifically. And assuming no doc or revive shenanigans, we are looking at F3 by day 4, so you have 3 nights to succeed at things. Granted, you leaving when you win means 2 by day 4, which is very bad for town unless we achieve only one mislynch.
Buh. I'm really hoping there is something setup to counteract you leaving. I can't guarantee agreeing to ties with you every night, cause that really could end poorly, but at least today I'll claim if you do. I'd like to claim second of the two of us since I claimed needing to tie before you did.
Iso never mentioned we having a neutral role.
Is zom claiming Neutral to escape notice?
Pushing that will only be scummy.
Shadow, all you need to know is what i told you.
I feel like i was clear on that.
Why so curious?
I don't actually want you divulge your role, I was just interested in clarification. But no worries.
I'm curious because quite frankly I think united we are stronger than divided. Six members of the town all getting the best results from their actions far outweighs 2 scum/1 neutral. So if we coordinate to set every single person up for success, we either:
A. all have ideal night actions and are better off because of it
B. Find scum that lied about their picks.
I feel like this setup presents a very real chance for town to corroborate together.
New to this charade and work unusual hours. Thanks. I'm off now and have a few hours to read and analyze.
Concur.
What is particularly scummy about me, good sir?
This
Care to elaborate?
He agreed on the post that i think tordeck is scummy for.
Seeing he is new, he could be looking for a quick tag along until he gets the ropes.
Sighhh.. if only
♡
{мы, тьма}
2012: Best (False?) Role Claim - Worst Town Performance (Group) - Best Mafia Performance (Group) - Best SK Performance - Best Overall Player
2013: Best Non-SK Neutral Performance
2014: Best Town Performance (Individual) - Best Town Performance (Group) - Most Interesting Role - Best Game - Best Overall Player
2015: Worst Mafia Performance (Group) - Best Read
2016: Best Town Performance (Group) - Best Town Player - Best Overall Player
Can i request superpowers? I wanna have superpowers.
@oph
Same question.
@Everyone: what are your thoughts on Zomg being neutral? Do you believe his claim?
Top Scum Reads:
Huntzilla
Tordeck/Rodemy
Vaimes have not posted in ages, so idk yet.
Y'all are being fools and spilling way to much info into the thread so I am staying as far away as possible least i catch a case of the dumbs.
The Family
Great. That is very mafia.
Tordeck isn't someone i'd coop with.
The Family
Unwillingness to disclose any info about oneself is also scummy.
Zomg is very much suspect to me. Irregular vibes since I started. (Yes, I am new to the game and in between work and adult stuff, trying to learn the ropes.)
Second that.
They might simply prefer privacy.