Why are we even talking about this? It doesn't help our wincon, simple as that. Each townie would have a 1/5 chance of winning and a 4/5 chance of losing, versus getting to actually choose my top suspect.
If Megs is town and he's advocating this plan, it's because he's not confident in his ability to accuse scum after a mislynch (like, less than random chance probability), or he's saying that he'd rather lose the game than see the scum have a chance at winning.
I call bull***** on both of those scenarios. Megs is scum trying too hard to look like someone who hates mafia.
oh cool DV added to townreads. scum dv probably doesnt admit to having fun watching megs get attacked for something that (probably) isnt alignment indicative. dv is probably getting close to huntzilla levels of me overthinking reads on him but that feels right.
that said, im not even sure if its funnier if megs ends up being scum or not.
last time i was scum in a micro i posted nonsense the whole game, so i need to play against meta and post good content here
I suppose the only way everyone else is right and you aren't scum is if this "plan" stuff was an elaborate, unfunny joke that went over my head... yet you've done nothing else so far. My vote stays
I can't make my points against Megs clearer than they already are, and nobody is interested. While I have a hard time agreeing with everyong about giving him the benefit of the doubt as a townie who wasted the first half of the entire game with a fluff posts and a joke-plan, I'll turn my attention elsewhere.
cyth having bad feels about me and rhand when rhand had one post and i had 3 one of which he presumably agreed on since it was about rhand and that's a little weird. vote cythare
It's ironic that you'd vote Cythare for disliking both you and Rhand. It means you yourself dislike both Cythare and Rhand, which is essentially the same situation, no?
not that savage is alignment indicative for rhand afaik.
that sentence would have been a huge towntell for ophidia or a moderate scumtell for newcomb though
@other tom ima need you to back up that cythare townread.
Ima need you to back up that cythare sscumread. So far all I see is you voting him for reasons that are hypocritical.
huntz wagon sucks. hes null as ****.
There are less than 3 days left and he's done nothing despite showing up to make posts. I don't know if that's his M.O., but I ignore meta anyway on principle.
Megs is worse and my first choice of a lynch, but I can see that it won't happen as of now.
whats hypocritical @tom?
cythare gave two reads at the same time that didnt match, i gave a read and then gave a different read in response to stimulus
I guess we should be lynching soon if we want a bit of accusation time too? vote: Huntzilla
I think he's a good bet, and if he's a mislynch, he's probably the best one to not have around toMorrow because he's not weighing in on stuff.
I still think it's Tom (not sloger) because of the fear mongering of time, and the way he's actively posting. Why would actively posting be a bad thing you ask? Scum know that there's only a few days (meatworld) to this gane and the easiest play is to skate by until the end. Scum will be hyper- vigilant this game in order to avoid lynch/end suspicion. I don't think Tom cares about finding real scum, just sowing dissension amongst us all.
But, you could make that argument for Sloger too.
I think Cyth is just coming back frtom an absence and doing his thing.
Megs is, well, Megs. New-age Seppel.
DV sounds like his usual self.
Rhand is feisty. Which is a good town tell usually.
I'm willing to lynch in the Toms right now, but not Sloger is worlds apart the better choice.
I still think it's Tom (not sloger) because of the fear mongering of time, and the way he's actively posting. Why would actively posting be a bad thing you ask? Scum know that there's only a few days (meatworld) to this gane and the easiest play is to skate by until the end. Scum will be hyper- vigilant this game in order to avoid lynch/end suspicion. I don't think Tom cares about finding real scum, just sowing dissension amongst us all.
This is ridiculous. You just described what town behavior should be in a game like this.
I think Cyth is just coming back frtom an absence and doing his thing.
Indeed. He strikes me as flippant town more than scum in the two posts to his name. He's gotta post more but that's all I have against him.
Glad my vote got Hunt to do something, but I can't see him as scum, despite him thinking I'm "worlds apart the scummiest in the game for actually trying".
Assuming a no-go on Megs I'm interested in lynching Rhand or tomsloger.
tomsloger because post 34 stinks, and an ISO reveals that it is surprisingly his only real contribution to the game.
Rhand because his ISO reveals bad reasoning for pretty much everything. His first two votes are just easy gimmie votes that in reality stink, he then proceeds to leave his options open even with Cythare (who he hasn't mentioned except for being one of his 3 suspects), then hops on Hunt wagon to L-1 with the intention of lynching, followed by no unvote after Hunt finally gives thoughts. Vote: Rhand
@Tom: I was waiting for Huntz to react to what I said about you before deciding if I'm moving my vote.
About Cythare: he isn't really doing anything, and remains on my POE.
It actually gives me a lower than 50% chance because I can't win if people accuse me the most.
How would it be hgher?
And how is that a reason to vote me?
It actually gives me a lower than 50% chance because I can't win if people accuse me the most.
How would it be hgher?
And how is that a reason to vote me?
Well, you have 3 people on your POE. If the mafia is lynched D1, then that's a win. Then after that, you would have a 50/50 shot. It's a vote largely because the use of stats/numbers for little reason feels scummy to me - it adds a veneer of confidence that isn't actually there.
[3] Rhand - Tom, Cythare, tomsloger (L-1)
[1] Cythare - D_V
[1] Huntzilla - Rhand
[1] Tom - Huntzilla
Not Voting: Megiddo
7 alive, 4 to lynch.
Reminder: There will be no deadline extension or night phase. After the lynch, we will immediately proceed to the accusations phase (unless the mafia is lynched).
If that happens, please submit your accusations to Prophylaxis and myself in private via PM or Discord DM.
Deadline for both phases is 5:30 PM Eastern on August 19th, 2017.
You may freely change your accusations until the deadline.
You don't know my lyfe.
Sold.
@Tom
I didn't read that as a town thing. I read that as Megs being Megs.
Also why is no one taking my bait.
Unvote Vote Cythare
Yeah I'd never play ball.
you guys are no fun but that's ok
Why though its bad.
also its kinda bad.
If Megs is town and he's advocating this plan, it's because he's not confident in his ability to accuse scum after a mislynch (like, less than random chance probability), or he's saying that he'd rather lose the game than see the scum have a chance at winning.
I call bull***** on both of those scenarios. Megs is scum trying too hard to look like someone who hates mafia.
Vote Count 4
[2] Cythare - tomsloger, D_V
[1] Megiddo - Tom
[1] Huntzilla - Cythare
[1] Tom - Huntzilla
[1] tomsloger - Rhand
Not Voting: Megiddo
it would be funny, but this seems not to be the goal for most of you...?
I mean.
Its kind of funny.
Its also funny watching you get attacked for it.
Thoughts on the actual game state though?
that said, im not even sure if its funnier if megs ends up being scum or not.
I haven't played in months, so my meta's pretty rusty. Still stand by putting my vote on you either way. How is your proposed plan "fun" tho? It's like...the worst kingmaker variant possible? I mean, it will work mechanically, which is separate from players not going along with it.
Draft my cube! (630 cards)
I suppose the only way everyone else is right and you aren't scum is if this "plan" stuff was an elaborate, unfunny joke that went over my head... yet you've done nothing else so far. My vote stays
My point was, Megs isn't.
Quite frankly, neither are you.
What is a CFD?
Tom is up there for the continued push.
Tomslogger seems town.
I want to lynch Hunt so hes town.
Megs is town.
Rhand is Rhand.
Have you read Megs' posts?
We? I don't remember you being part of that conversation.
I think it's either Hunt, tomsloger or Cythare.
If I'm right and we lynch one of them, that gives me a 50% win chance
It's ironic that you'd vote Cythare for disliking both you and Rhand. It means you yourself dislike both Cythare and Rhand, which is essentially the same situation, no?
This sums up your gameplay. Vote: Huntzilla
Cythare and D_V strike me as town.
Why not other Tom though?
[2] Cythare - tomsloger, D_V
[2] Huntzilla - Cythare, Tom
[1] Tom - Huntzilla
[1] tomsloger - Rhand
Not Voting: Megiddo
dont really believe rhand is that confident.
huntz wagon sucks. hes null as ****.
this is pretty savage btw
that sentence would have been a huge towntell for ophidia or a moderate scumtell for newcomb though
Ima need you to back up that cythare sscumread. So far all I see is you voting him for reasons that are hypocritical.
There are less than 3 days left and he's done nothing despite showing up to make posts. I don't know if that's his M.O., but I ignore meta anyway on principle.
Megs is worse and my first choice of a lynch, but I can see that it won't happen as of now.
cythare gave two reads at the same time that didnt match, i gave a read and then gave a different read in response to stimulus
and yeah not really doing stuff is just huntz
vote: Huntzilla
I think he's a good bet, and if he's a mislynch, he's probably the best one to not have around toMorrow because he's not weighing in on stuff.
But yeah, you're going down that meta-hole pretty hard.
But, you could make that argument for Sloger too.
I think Cyth is just coming back frtom an absence and doing his thing.
Megs is, well, Megs. New-age Seppel.
DV sounds like his usual self.
Rhand is feisty. Which is a good town tell usually.
I'm willing to lynch in the Toms right now, but not Sloger is worlds apart the better choice.
This is ridiculous. You just described what town behavior should be in a game like this.
Indeed. He strikes me as flippant town more than scum in the two posts to his name. He's gotta post more but that's all I have against him.
Glad my vote got Hunt to do something, but I can't see him as scum, despite him thinking I'm "worlds apart the scummiest in the game for actually trying".
Assuming a no-go on Megs I'm interested in lynching Rhand or tomsloger.
tomsloger because post 34 stinks, and an ISO reveals that it is surprisingly his only real contribution to the game.
Rhand because his ISO reveals bad reasoning for pretty much everything. His first two votes are just easy gimmie votes that in reality stink, he then proceeds to leave his options open even with Cythare (who he hasn't mentioned except for being one of his 3 suspects), then hops on Hunt wagon to L-1 with the intention of lynching, followed by no unvote after Hunt finally gives thoughts. Vote: Rhand
About Cythare: he isn't really doing anything, and remains on my POE.
[2] Cythare - tomsloger, D_V
[2] Huntzilla - Cythare, Rhand
[1] Tom - Huntzilla
[1] Rhand - Tom
Not Voting: Megiddo
Cythare has been prodded.
I think I'm going to hop here. Vote Rhand
Draft my cube! (630 cards)
How would it be hgher?
And how is that a reason to vote me?
And yet...
Vote rhand
That's L-1
Draft my cube! (630 cards)
[3] Rhand - Tom, Cythare, tomsloger (L-1)
[1] Cythare - D_V
[1] Huntzilla - Rhand
[1] Tom - Huntzilla
Not Voting: Megiddo
7 alive, 4 to lynch.
Reminder: There will be no deadline extension or night phase. After the lynch, we will immediately proceed to the accusations phase (unless the mafia is lynched).
If that happens, please submit your accusations to Prophylaxis and myself in private via PM or Discord DM.
Deadline for both phases is 5:30 PM Eastern on August 19th, 2017.
You may freely change your accusations until the deadline.
Meh. I don't agree.
What makes you say otherwise?
You are our scum, aren't you?
vote: tomsloger
no hammer from dv
@megs?