Thanks wheat for the update. Welcome Osie! Hopefully adding you will help bring life back to the game. I wish you could answer the questions that I raised in regards to the previous player in your slot, but I know you cannot tell me what was going through his mind.
I'll look back at your posts directly and see what I can intuit. I should PBPA each of a few players anyways, yourself included, just to see how certain I am on my reads of y'all.
@osieorb18: I resent that! I am not a yoctogram - I am clearly a zeptoliter. That being said, welcome! Also, what is that first GIF of? I could swear it's something I've seen before, but I cannot for the life of me think of where it's from.
It's from My Hero Academia (anime). Also, I'll precursor my catch-up post with asking you to talk to me in detail about Mog, about Vaimes, and about your interactions with ELph.
@Mograppler: I would like to hear from you about BE, Vaimes, and your interactions with ELph.
Okay, page 7 before the breaking of the social contract, and I remembered just how significant that garbage was in the later part of page 6. The rest of page 6 was almost just skimming. It's
1. ELphidia slot AND D_V slot are conftown, unless post 315 was an amazingly well-acted lie.
2. NINE players ALL ignored this? Like, I get that the game breaking sucks, but ignoring what actually happened seems extremely bad.
-----
I've gotten this far and while I was willing to forgive it to a degree, I'm too bothered by how long this gut + logic match has gone on. I'm willing to change this if something leaps out to me in PBPA or the later pages of the game, but this is the only user who I've maintained a nearly constant scumread on...
Vote: Mograppler
Some of the early stuff can be explained away by being newish, and I'm not going to harp on the no-lynch crap, especially because EL's wagon on that was awful.
But Mog's buddying up bothered me a lot. And I saw only a few posts from Mog that I liked. Like, in a strange twist of fate, I agree with D_V to a degree in that it's very hard to read him as town.
Heck, I might agree too much with D_V. Not that that's necessarily a bad thing.
Okay, page 7 before the breaking of the social contract, and I remembered just how significant that garbage was in the later part of page 6. The rest of page 6 was almost just skimming. It's
1. ELphidia slot AND D_V slot are conftown, unless post 315 was an amazingly well-acted lie.
2. NINE players ALL ignored this? Like, I get that the game breaking sucks, but ignoring what actually happened seems extremely bad.
Like, I'm sorry for being that guy and poking the elephant in the room, but I'm incredibly confused as to why anybody was still voting for either D_V or EL/Ophidia after this point.
@Blues your luck only pushed me so far as I lost in the finals. So close, yet so far.
@KingTorg my previous vote was with you on fug, before all of the D_V fallout. I know at one point when we were going through all of the replacements, etc., I was asked if there was a lead I'd be interested in following up on (I can't recall who asked, apologies), and that said, this would be my answer.
Guys, we are just a few days out from the deadline. We have got to communicate more than we are now.
Wheat, can we get a vote count along with a timeline for deadline?
Vaimes, I'm worried too that we're going to get no where at this rate. It feels like only a few are invested in the game at this point.
I'm trying and will post more in the next few day. My kids are getting back to school, so am I and work decided that they weren't going to look at my new availability do I got scheduled close to forty hours this week and last.
@osieorb18: Thanks for answering about the GIF - I've never seen the anime, so I've probably seen the GIF itself somewhere before.
Regarding Mog, I don't think there's much more that I can say there which I haven't already covered. While early on I was looking at him due to his desire to push the no-lynch option, his actions since then have kept him on the scum end of my reads - his voting has, in nearly every case, consisted of seeing a popular wagon and riding it, while he parrots the reasoning of others as to why he's voting. I wouldn't look at it as a concern if it were just once, but three times is a bit much for me to see it as anything less than a pattern.
Vaimes is a curiosity for me at the moment - before he replaced in, I wasn't sure if the Olli*** slot was scum or not. Since his replacement, he's seemed more focused on Ophidia than anything, while I'm convinced that the slot is town. The fact that he's only voiced opinions on a small number of players is concerning, as it suggests that he might be trying to push an agenda with those players. I'm not sure if I'm reading to much into things here - that he is town and is just trying to focus on his possible scumreads - or if he's scum trying to push his own agenda. Bears further watching, to say the least.
Regarding ELphidia, I originally had him pegged as town. His thought processes seemed to match mine in many areas. His blowup with D_V was surprising, but the fact that EL got himself replaced out of the game solidifies the slot as town for me - I don't see scum being willing to push that far on much of anything. At this point, I'm going to go on record and say that I consider ELphidia to be locked town - enough so that I would sooner vote myself than him (her? it?).
And regarding the outside information on D_V - we didn't have any way of confirming that the outside information was, in fact, accurate. Wheat confirmed that there was an issue with outside information, and that it was addressed and determined to be a 'no-fault' situation in this case, but nothing was said that confirms or denies the accuracy of the information.
As for the rest of the field, I will note that Megnami is probably the next highest on my scum list after Mog, though that's more due to Audio's actions than anything Meg has done. Not sure who else out there would be possible scum, but Nago always read as town to me, and Osie hasn't done anything to change that opinion, so right now I'm really looking at Ophidia, Osie and myself as a town core to work from, with Bloodmoon as a town read as well.
@JulsSkogs: Tough break at the tourney. But if you lost in the finals, you still got something out of it, right? I hope the next one goes well! You mention your vote is on Vaimes based largely on your prior reads on Olli***. Is there anything from Vaimes himself that you're seeing as scummy? And who would you peg as Vaimes's scumbuddies?
@Ophidia: Going to China, huh? Nice... I hope you enjoy whatever you're doing over there! And yeah, it somehow wasn't registering to me there that Rhand flipped town. Anyway, if you think Mog is newscum, and you've at least implied that you think Torg is likely scum as well, who would you think is #3 on the scumteam? And if I'm wrong regarding your opinion on Torg, who would you think is scum in his place?
@Everyone else: Hi, I've only skimmed parts of this game and read the most recent page, so I will have to do a real catchup.
I'm unwilling to clear EL/Ophidia based on the emotional outburst. I don't have an actual read, but I will not lock town the slot because of that, and I'm not willing to discuss why.
@Bloodmoon: You want more communication, how do you plan to push for it?
@Osie: Who did you replace, and give me a birds eye view on why I should trust you this game.
Interesting statement blues. Why would you ever say that you trust someone more than yourself? Makes no logical sense to me. Especially when you were the one stating that self voting is scummy. You know what role you have, but don't know what role ELphidia has. I was going to ask you why you suspected meg, but then I remembered that meg was Audio.
Btw; we have had 7 of the 12 players be subbed if anyone was wondering...
@Shadow: You should trust me because I am Progenitus. (It's not as exciting as being Merlin, but oh well...) I replaced into vanilla town, as I'm guessing you did as well. I'm currently scumleaning on Vaimes and King Torg, beyond a scumread of Mog. Bloodmoon seems likely town. If the game break was NAI, then ELph could go either way for me. Blues is rather null for me right now; there's a lot there and much of it WIFOM's the hell out of me.
I replaced Nagobcnik, who was mostly being pretty analytical as well. I'm guessing he was busy IRL.
Besides, I'm still only a town lean on your slot, and now that you're playing it, I'm significantly more wary, because as we all know, you're very wolfy.
Like, Blues could be a goat, but I don't like their interactions with Mog or ELph. Though if ELph is in fact town, then the lock is a little risky. But less so in this game than other games since a scum!Blues can play the long game there. I do get the feeling that a duck is a duck, though, and Blues is just town. Which leaves me with the group I mentioned before unless I see more cues.
Damnit. I'm going to take game break as NAI. Looking at Ophidia then pushes that slot to more aggressively problematic than Mog, who could just be newb town. That argument sucks, but Vaimes is right. Shadow, try ISOing ELphidia and tell me what you see.
Shadow, I intend to push more discussion by asking questions, which leads me to ask, can we get your current take on one of the things that has me somewhat confused. Which would be the current game position for Mog. Some are reading him as town, while others are reading him as scum. And it feels like they are reading him as either for the exact same reasons. Does that seem to be what it looks like as well to you? What's your current take on it? I know that you said that you are catching up, but I would like to know where you end up standing on this issue.
Like, Blues could be a goat, but I don't like their interactions with Mog or ELph. Though if ELph is in fact town, then the lock is a little risky. But less so in this game than other games since a scum!Blues can play the long game there. I do get the feeling that a duck is a duck, though, and Blues is just town. Which leaves me with the group I mentioned before unless I see more cues.
Osie, what jumped out at you that made you not like the interactions there? I'm trying to get the whole picture so that I can see what is being saw by you.
Megs, you still haven't replied as to why you are voting for Blues. Could you please answer as to why you are?
I still feel like Nago's 180 (Now Osie) was scummy, but I want to hear more from Osie since he's participating. And since I do want to hear more from him and it looks highly unlikely he's getting lynched today, I'm going to move to the other person who I suspected the most.
unvote vote ophidia
We are just over 48 hours from the lynch, so we are going to have to start coming together on votes.
@Shadow: You should trust me because I am Progenitus. (It's not as exciting as being Merlin, but oh well...) I replaced into vanilla town, as I'm guessing you did as well. I'm currently scumleaning on Vaimes and King Torg, beyond a scumread of Mog. Bloodmoon seems likely town. If the game break was NAI, then ELph could go either way for me. Blues is rather null for me right now; there's a lot there and much of it WIFOM's the hell out of me.
I replaced Nagobcnik, who was mostly being pretty analytical as well. I'm guessing he was busy IRL.
Besides, I'm still only a town lean on your slot, and now that you're playing it, I'm significantly more wary, because as we all know, you're very wolfy.
Damnit. I'm going to take game break as NAI. Looking at Ophidia then pushes that slot to more aggressively problematic than Mog, who could just be newb town. That argument sucks, but Vaimes is right. Shadow, try ISOing ELphidia and tell me what you see.
Well, at this point, it looks like there's not much I can do to stop people from lynching Ophidia. At the end of the game, I'm going to be asking our more experienced players to look back on this and let me know if there's something I should've done differently here, and it's my play that's lacking, or whether this is just a hopeless mislynch.
I'm still not sure what to think of regarding Vaimes, though I want to hear his thoughts still on the rest of the field.
@Bloodmoon0324: You mention that you want to hear more from Osie and Ophidia both, and are voting for Ophidia because you don't think Osie will get lynched today. When Ophidia flips town, who will you be looking at as scumteam? And what are your thoughts on Vaimes specifically?
@Vaimes: When Ophidia flips town, who do you read as scum?
@Osieorb18: You go from scumread on Mog in #493 to 'newb town' on Mog in #495. Please explain. Also, when Ophidia flips town, who are your picks for scumteam?
Scum
Osie
King Torg@Blues: Can you just tell me your alignment so I don't have to read your iso? So many walls. Have you played Mafia before?
@Juls: have you played Mafia elsewhere?
@Vaimes: Talk to me about Ophi/EL, what's your impression of his first 15 or so posts?
@Bloodmoon: kinda think Mogs is slightly more likely town than scum, but if he's scum, I want a very close look at Oph-slot again.
@Osie: Regarding EL's iso, I'd say town with a couple of reservations. Hey, any specific reason you're "guessing you replaced into a VT slot" but also "only town lean on your slot, and wary because [you're a good scum player]" kinda seems like you're both hedging a read on me and role fishing.
Vote King Torg
@Everyone: Lynching Oph is a bad idea, slot's nowhere close to most likely scum even if you think he's not even town.
@shadowlancerx: My only Mafia experience prior to this has been playing on the Starcraft 2 Mafia map - I will say that it's an entirely different experience. Real-time, much shorter day/night cycles (roughly 10 min/5 min), more roles, mostly open setups (meaning that you can math out a lot of people's alignments), etc. Overall, much more mechanic-driven than interaction-driven gameplay. So I'll freely admit that I'm not necessarily good at forum Mafia yet.
As for alignment, I'm town - though I'm aware that my saying it doesn't mean that much as I don't think there's anyone who you could ask that question to that would claim otherwise. And yes, I was wall-heavy, particularly early on - I'm making an effort to try and temper that tendency since I've noticed that it does make it easier for points to get lost within the text.
I get that my push on mogg, D_V and EL's stuff mark me as scum in some scenarios, but Mogg and king torg are much higher priority targets. As for the third slot, I have no concrete suspect yet, but it will (probably) be between meg, shadow, and julz.
You know what? I'm just going to claim now and hope that people are willing to listen (or at least to lynch me first, rather than the one other person in this game I can guarantee is town). And yes, I fully expect everyone to tell me this is a horrible move - but oh well. It's the only thing I have at this point which will properly explain my conviction regarding this.
I am Thraximundar, Town 1-Shot Cop. I investigated Ophidia last night - with D_V flipping town, I decided that it was best to check and see if the other slot that had a major role in that was town (since I knew I was). This is why I'm absolutely certain that they are town. Lynch me if you think I'm lying - the ability's not going to do me any more good at this point anyway.
@Blues: Well that does change things. Given that I do believe you, I trust that Ophidia is town, so I'm listening. To answer another question of yours, I have no clue how to read Vaimes. I'm inclined to go with town, but given that I thought Ophidia was scum I could be wrong. I feel like the Scum team is somewhere in King, Osie, and potentially Mog and Megs.
@Shadow: Since I was also scum reading King, what did you see that makes you think he is scum?
Given the circumstances, I am going to go back to where I was before.
vote: Osie
Also, @Megs: I now have two tabs open because I'm afraid of getting ninja'ed by you.
catching up; decided to read up on the D_V lynch. i miss him.
was about to suggest an EL lynch but apparently we have a peek on that slot so lol?
blue: when you say "a major role in that" what exactly do you mean?
I mean that EL and myself were the two who were most strongly pushing the case on D_V. I already knew I was town, so with D_V flipping town I decided to check the slot for other person leading the charge (so to speak) there.
Attention all yoctograms, Osieorb18 is present and abiding. Have no fear, for I am here!
Will be doing a full catch up tonight/tomorrow morning; I already read over the game a while ago but need to take better notes, and get my T/S list going.
Let me know if you guys want me to address anything specific.
Heart, Heart, Wink, and Point! Over and out.
now that I've officially read one of your posts
vote: osieorb18
gottem, better luck next game.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Can we have Megiddo removed from the forum forever please?
i'm pretty sure i can find your ***** online within 3 minutes
Scum
Osie
King Torg@Blues: Can you just tell me your alignment so I don't have to read your iso? So many walls. Have you played Mafia before?
@Juls: have you played Mafia elsewhere?
@Vaimes: Talk to me about Ophi/EL, what's your impression of his first 15 or so posts?
@Bloodmoon: kinda think Mogs is slightly more likely town than scum, but if he's scum, I want a very close look at Oph-slot again.
@Osie: Regarding EL's iso, I'd say town with a couple of reservations. Hey, any specific reason you're "guessing you replaced into a VT slot" but also "only town lean on your slot, and wary because [you're a good scum player]" kinda seems like you're both hedging a read on me and role fishing.
Vote King Torg
@Everyone: Lynching Oph is a bad idea, slot's nowhere close to most likely scum even if you think he's not even town.
yes hmm tell me more
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Can we have Megiddo removed from the forum forever please?
i'm pretty sure i can find your ***** online within 3 minutes
in case I get NK'd, the plan for Today is to lynch osi. if he's scum, 100% of the time without fail you lynch mograppler Tomorrow. Third will hopefully be caught by this point. look at shadowlancer but also, like, other people.
any unclaimed town PRs should claim two Days from now as part of POE, but not yet.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Can we have Megiddo removed from the forum forever please?
i'm pretty sure i can find your ***** online within 3 minutes
Megs, it's laughable that you're talking about gettin NK'd when we have a CLAIMED COP and a TOWN PEEK.
And my scum lean has nothing to do with you and everything to do with your slot, but go ahead and OMGUS, it's cute, and worked oh so well in your last scum game against me.
Megs, it's laughable that you're talking about gettin NK'd when we have a CLAIMED COP and a TOWN PEEK.
And my scum lean has nothing to do with you and everything to do with your slot, but go ahead and OMGUS, it's cute, and worked oh so well in your last scum game against me.
lmao
you were my distant third spec scum pick. but what is this post, man? trying to set up the discredit already??? v. transparent. Also what game are you even referring to?
look, literally just vote for osiorb Today. If I'm wrong on that you can come at me with whatever you want. do you have any disagreements on that particular read?
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Can we have Megiddo removed from the forum forever please?
i'm pretty sure i can find your ***** online within 3 minutes
I'll look back at your posts directly and see what I can intuit. I should PBPA each of a few players anyways, yourself included, just to see how certain I am on my reads of y'all.
It's from My Hero Academia (anime). Also, I'll precursor my catch-up post with asking you to talk to me in detail about Mog, about Vaimes, and about your interactions with ELph.
@Mograppler: I would like to hear from you about BE, Vaimes, and your interactions with ELph.
1. ELphidia slot AND D_V slot are conftown, unless post 315 was an amazingly well-acted lie.
2. NINE players ALL ignored this? Like, I get that the game breaking sucks, but ignoring what actually happened seems extremely bad.
-----
I've gotten this far and while I was willing to forgive it to a degree, I'm too bothered by how long this gut + logic match has gone on. I'm willing to change this if something leaps out to me in PBPA or the later pages of the game, but this is the only user who I've maintained a nearly constant scumread on...
Vote: Mograppler
Some of the early stuff can be explained away by being newish, and I'm not going to harp on the no-lynch crap, especially because EL's wagon on that was awful.
But Mog's buddying up bothered me a lot. And I saw only a few posts from Mog that I liked. Like, in a strange twist of fate, I agree with D_V to a degree in that it's very hard to read him as town.
Heck, I might agree too much with D_V. Not that that's necessarily a bad thing.
Like, I'm sorry for being that guy and poking the elephant in the room, but I'm incredibly confused as to why anybody was still voting for either D_V or EL/Ophidia after this point.
@KingTorg my previous vote was with you on fug, before all of the D_V fallout. I know at one point when we were going through all of the replacements, etc., I was asked if there was a lead I'd be interested in following up on (I can't recall who asked, apologies), and that said, this would be my answer.
Vote: Vaimes
UW Control
UWR Geist
UWR Control
Sorry.
@ people voting me: do you have questions for me, or are you just parking.
Like, that's reasonable in and of itself, or we just treat it as an innocent Child and move on.
Wheat, can we get a vote count along with a timeline for deadline?
Vaimes, I'm worried too that we're going to get no where at this rate. It feels like only a few are invested in the game at this point.
I'm trying and will post more in the next few day. My kids are getting back to school, so am I and work decided that they weren't going to look at my new availability do I got scheduled close to forty hours this week and last.
Votecount!
Vaimes - 2 (King Torg, JulsSkogs)
Mograppler - 2 (BluesEclipse, osieorb18)
Ophidia - 1 (Vaimes)
osieorb18 - 1 (Bloodmoon0324)
BluesEclipse - 1 (Megiddo)
Not Voting - 3 (Ophidia, Mograppler, shadowlancerx)
Deadline is on Thursday, 8/10 at 7PM CST
If the game picks up and more time is needed, it will be provided. But only if things pick up.
Regarding Mog, I don't think there's much more that I can say there which I haven't already covered. While early on I was looking at him due to his desire to push the no-lynch option, his actions since then have kept him on the scum end of my reads - his voting has, in nearly every case, consisted of seeing a popular wagon and riding it, while he parrots the reasoning of others as to why he's voting. I wouldn't look at it as a concern if it were just once, but three times is a bit much for me to see it as anything less than a pattern.
Vaimes is a curiosity for me at the moment - before he replaced in, I wasn't sure if the Olli*** slot was scum or not. Since his replacement, he's seemed more focused on Ophidia than anything, while I'm convinced that the slot is town. The fact that he's only voiced opinions on a small number of players is concerning, as it suggests that he might be trying to push an agenda with those players. I'm not sure if I'm reading to much into things here - that he is town and is just trying to focus on his possible scumreads - or if he's scum trying to push his own agenda. Bears further watching, to say the least.
Regarding ELphidia, I originally had him pegged as town. His thought processes seemed to match mine in many areas. His blowup with D_V was surprising, but the fact that EL got himself replaced out of the game solidifies the slot as town for me - I don't see scum being willing to push that far on much of anything. At this point, I'm going to go on record and say that I consider ELphidia to be locked town - enough so that I would sooner vote myself than him (her? it?).
And regarding the outside information on D_V - we didn't have any way of confirming that the outside information was, in fact, accurate. Wheat confirmed that there was an issue with outside information, and that it was addressed and determined to be a 'no-fault' situation in this case, but nothing was said that confirms or denies the accuracy of the information.
As for the rest of the field, I will note that Megnami is probably the next highest on my scum list after Mog, though that's more due to Audio's actions than anything Meg has done. Not sure who else out there would be possible scum, but Nago always read as town to me, and Osie hasn't done anything to change that opinion, so right now I'm really looking at Ophidia, Osie and myself as a town core to work from, with Bloodmoon as a town read as well.
@JulsSkogs: Tough break at the tourney. But if you lost in the finals, you still got something out of it, right? I hope the next one goes well! You mention your vote is on Vaimes based largely on your prior reads on Olli***. Is there anything from Vaimes himself that you're seeing as scummy? And who would you peg as Vaimes's scumbuddies?
@Ophidia: Going to China, huh? Nice... I hope you enjoy whatever you're doing over there! And yeah, it somehow wasn't registering to me there that Rhand flipped town. Anyway, if you think Mog is newscum, and you've at least implied that you think Torg is likely scum as well, who would you think is #3 on the scumteam? And if I'm wrong regarding your opinion on Torg, who would you think is scum in his place?
@Everyone else: Hi, I've only skimmed parts of this game and read the most recent page, so I will have to do a real catchup.
I'm unwilling to clear EL/Ophidia based on the emotional outburst. I don't have an actual read, but I will not lock town the slot because of that, and I'm not willing to discuss why.
@Bloodmoon: You want more communication, how do you plan to push for it?
@Osie: Who did you replace, and give me a birds eye view on why I should trust you this game.
@Megs: Where you at?
Btw; we have had 7 of the 12 players be subbed if anyone was wondering...
I replaced Nagobcnik, who was mostly being pretty analytical as well. I'm guessing he was busy IRL.
Besides, I'm still only a town lean on your slot, and now that you're playing it, I'm significantly more wary, because as we all know, you're very wolfy.
@Mog: What are you doing?
Unvote, Vote Ophidia.
Osie, what jumped out at you that made you not like the interactions there? I'm trying to get the whole picture so that I can see what is being saw by you.
Megs, you still haven't replied as to why you are voting for Blues. Could you please answer as to why you are?
I still feel like Nago's 180 (Now Osie) was scummy, but I want to hear more from Osie since he's participating. And since I do want to hear more from him and it looks highly unlikely he's getting lynched today, I'm going to move to the other person who I suspected the most.
unvote vote ophidia
We are just over 48 hours from the lynch, so we are going to have to start coming together on votes.
Did I miss something.
Well, at this point, it looks like there's not much I can do to stop people from lynching Ophidia. At the end of the game, I'm going to be asking our more experienced players to look back on this and let me know if there's something I should've done differently here, and it's my play that's lacking, or whether this is just a hopeless mislynch.
I'm still not sure what to think of regarding Vaimes, though I want to hear his thoughts still on the rest of the field.
@Bloodmoon0324: You mention that you want to hear more from Osie and Ophidia both, and are voting for Ophidia because you don't think Osie will get lynched today. When Ophidia flips town, who will you be looking at as scumteam? And what are your thoughts on Vaimes specifically?
@Vaimes: When Ophidia flips town, who do you read as scum?
@Osieorb18: You go from scumread on Mog in #493 to 'newb town' on Mog in #495. Please explain. Also, when Ophidia flips town, who are your picks for scumteam?
Shadow
Vaimes
Town lean
Bloodmoon
Oph
Mixed
Mogs
Juls
Scum lean
Megs
Scum
Osie
King Torg
@Blues: Can you just tell me your alignment so I don't have to read your iso? So many walls. Have you played Mafia before?
@Juls: have you played Mafia elsewhere?
@Vaimes: Talk to me about Ophi/EL, what's your impression of his first 15 or so posts?
@Bloodmoon: kinda think Mogs is slightly more likely town than scum, but if he's scum, I want a very close look at Oph-slot again.
@Osie: Regarding EL's iso, I'd say town with a couple of reservations. Hey, any specific reason you're "guessing you replaced into a VT slot" but also "only town lean on your slot, and wary because [you're a good scum player]" kinda seems like you're both hedging a read on me and role fishing.
Vote King Torg
@Everyone: Lynching Oph is a bad idea, slot's nowhere close to most likely scum even if you think he's not even town.
As for alignment, I'm town - though I'm aware that my saying it doesn't mean that much as I don't think there's anyone who you could ask that question to that would claim otherwise. And yes, I was wall-heavy, particularly early on - I'm making an effort to try and temper that tendency since I've noticed that it does make it easier for points to get lost within the text.
@Blues, are you townreading Ophidia outside of the EL thing, or what?
I get that my push on mogg, D_V and EL's stuff mark me as scum in some scenarios, but Mogg and king torg are much higher priority targets. As for the third slot, I have no concrete suspect yet, but it will (probably) be between meg, shadow, and julz.
I am Thraximundar, Town 1-Shot Cop. I investigated Ophidia last night - with D_V flipping town, I decided that it was best to check and see if the other slot that had a major role in that was town (since I knew I was). This is why I'm absolutely certain that they are town. Lynch me if you think I'm lying - the ability's not going to do me any more good at this point anyway.
was about to suggest an EL lynch but apparently we have a peek on that slot so lol?
blue: when you say "a major role in that" what exactly do you mean?
@Blues: Well that does change things. Given that I do believe you, I trust that Ophidia is town, so I'm listening. To answer another question of yours, I have no clue how to read Vaimes. I'm inclined to go with town, but given that I thought Ophidia was scum I could be wrong. I feel like the Scum team is somewhere in King, Osie, and potentially Mog and Megs.
@Shadow: Since I was also scum reading King, what did you see that makes you think he is scum?
Given the circumstances, I am going to go back to where I was before.
vote: Osie
Also, @Megs: I now have two tabs open because I'm afraid of getting ninja'ed by you.
http://www.mtgsalvation.com/forums/community-forums/mafia/779230-maelstrom-of-alara-mafia-91-day-2-oh-baby-a-triple?comment=332
^ this one's more likely scum post than not.
and
http://www.mtgsalvation.com/forums/community-forums/mafia/779230-maelstrom-of-alara-mafia-91-day-2-oh-baby-a-triple?comment=354
^ this is scum almost every time.
http://www.mtgsalvation.com/forums/community-forums/mafia/779230-maelstrom-of-alara-mafia-91-day-2-oh-baby-a-triple?comment=362
^ My First Chainsaw Defense™
my two picks so far.
read the "scum every time" post and then read this post. then vote osieorb.
I mean that EL and myself were the two who were most strongly pushing the case on D_V. I already knew I was town, so with D_V flipping town I decided to check the slot for other person leading the charge (so to speak) there.
I just wrapped up a game that was about thirty seven thousand posts without voting once. And I survived quite a long time, too.
But in reality I'm just not going to vote until I've finished catching up. Like I said, I haven't even read a single one of Osieorb's posts yet
vote: osieorb18
gottem, better luck next game.
in case I get NK'd, the plan for Today is to lynch osi. if he's scum, 100% of the time without fail you lynch mograppler Tomorrow. Third will hopefully be caught by this point. look at shadowlancer but also, like, other people.
any unclaimed town PRs should claim two Days from now as part of POE, but not yet.
And my scum lean has nothing to do with you and everything to do with your slot, but go ahead and OMGUS, it's cute, and worked oh so well in your last scum game against me.
you were my distant third spec scum pick. but what is this post, man? trying to set up the discredit already??? v. transparent. Also what game are you even referring to?
look, literally just vote for osiorb Today. If I'm wrong on that you can come at me with whatever you want. do you have any disagreements on that particular read?
so calling it OMGUS is just clearly false in the first place.