I'll probably do this some time later tonight, but gonna pull up the posts where Proph narrows his suspects down to X, Y, and Terry.
Also, given that Grapefruit is BP, it's entirely possible that there's a strongman of some sort on the mafia team.
What's your take on double overlapping role pairs?
I never looked deeply into it, tbh. I find the neighborizer role scummy enough on its own. Also, just thinking about it now, AG's role somewhat revolves around communication, too. And all are day shot abilities, so...
And oh my god I'm so dumb... If AG is scum, all he'll have to do is give his ability to his buddies... Or kill the person who receives the shot... Or both (claims he gave the shot to the person who dies but actually didn't.) But eh, maybe he's not actually scum.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
When the point of no return appears, it is already behind you.
I don't understand how you all think scum should act for that to be a Town-tell for all of you. I seriously can't recall more than three vaguely-Townie posts from Terry in this entire game. My vote is most likely not moving until he's dead.
Well.. we can have a discussion about it? I can tell you my reasoning as to why I think Terry is town (I think? Please be town Terry) and then you can come in with your reasoning as to why you think JT is scum and we can reach a conclusion?
Yeah, you two have got to be buddies. This is your weakest read by far.
@Proph: Wanna talk about it being suspicious that Town-firmed people would be alive this long? Then what's up with Grapefruit and Terry both being alive into MyLo, when QH is the toughest lynch in the game because he's so widely Town-read, and Terry is the second toughest lynch in the game because he's being magically Town-read for scum-tells?
What is the town-firmed people we have in this game?
I'm not sure why Grapefruit and Terry are still alive. Why is QH so widely town read?
And I told you before, we can talk about Terry and come to a agreement/compromise on reads because I think it's strange that you're reading the gamestate differently than I am.
The overlaps are Grape who claims BP and Rhand who flipped Death Guard as well as Shadow who claims neighborizer and Shin who flipped announcer. Grape and Rhand both appear to be protective roles, but rhand is confirmed town and grapes is just a claim that I don't buy. Shin and Shadow both appear to be communication roles as shin is confirmed and shadow has only claimed to chat with grape and proph. Mafia games tend to be built with balances in mind and it doesn't strike me as balanced to have a BP town, a second protection role in rhand, a neighborizer and an announcer all on the same team.
I don't understand how you all think scum should act for that to be a Town-tell for all of you. I seriously can't recall more than three vaguely-Townie posts from Terry in this entire game. My vote is most likely not moving until he's dead.
Well.. we can have a discussion about it? I can tell you my reasoning as to why I think Terry is town (I think? Please be town Terry) and then you can come in with your reasoning as to why you think JT is scum and we can reach a conclusion?
Yeah, you two have got to be buddies. This is your weakest read by far.
@Proph: Wanna talk about it being suspicious that Town-firmed people would be alive this long? Then what's up with Grapefruit and Terry both being alive into MyLo, when QH is the toughest lynch in the game because he's so widely Town-read, and Terry is the second toughest lynch in the game because he's being magically Town-read for scum-tells?
What is the town-firmed people we have in this game?
I'm not sure why Grapefruit and Terry are still alive. Why is QH so widely town read?
And I told you before, we can talk about Terry and come to a agreement/compromise on reads because I think it's strange that you're reading the gamestate differently than I am.
Are you implying I'm scum buddies with grape and have stuck my neck out questioning the truthfulness of grapes BP claim while, like several people, it would be much easier to just buy his claim and give him a free pass?
The overlaps are Grape who claims BP and Rhand who flipped Death Guard as well as Shadow who claims neighborizer and Shin who flipped announcer. Grape and Rhand both appear to be protective roles, but rhand is confirmed town and grapes is just a claim that I don't buy. Shin and Shadow both appear to be communication roles as shin is confirmed and shadow has only claimed to chat with grape and proph. Mafia games tend to be built with balances in mind and it doesn't strike me as balanced to have a BP town, a second protection role in rhand, a neighborizer and an announcer all on the same team.
I can't agree or disagree with this. But I don't think for all these roles to be on the same alignment is an impossibility. If the person Shadow decides to chat with is either Proph or Grape, or if the person he does chat with dies, I will be very, very suspicious. But the same way I won't allow someone with a certain role to be cleared, I also won't allow them to be convicted of it. Of course, unless the claim is highly suspicious, but Grape's and shadow's are not (after I got over my initial paranoia).
#2364 - How did you come to that conclusion? I'm saying you and Proph are scumbuddies. Not you and Grape.
...
I'll use my second shot of paranoia, for funsies and it actually bugs me that we didn't lynch today. Erm, I kind of remember my friend telling me about the effed up thing that happened to Clarice at the end of the series. Well, that wasn't too related, but somehow I get the feeling Grape is survivor. /paranoia
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
When the point of no return appears, it is already behind you.
Also, based on the fact Terry claimed vanilla, I don't think AG is scum (or more accurately, aligned with him). AG could give the shot out to a buddy, or simply not give out the shot at all.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
When the point of no return appears, it is already behind you.
Random thought before twilight if Rhand is a Bodyguard it isn't a protective so much as a redirection role similar to a busdriver. Never has the potential to prevent a kill.
Also, based on the fact Terry claimed vanilla, I don't think AG is scum (or more accurately, aligned with him). AG could give the shot out to a buddy, or simply not give out the shot at all.
Just from a play style standpoint, there's plenty of reason to give the shot to town; proves your role, doesn't tie you to your buddies, etc. like, sure you could give it to a buddy and never claim it, but that just seems less fun and kind of lame. I dunno, I just don't think it's smart to create dichotomies based on how "optimal" play would be.
Also, based on the fact Terry claimed vanilla, I don't think AG is scum (or more accurately, aligned with him). AG could give the shot out to a buddy, or simply not give out the shot at all.
Just from a play style standpoint, there's plenty of reason to give the shot to town; proves your role, doesn't tie you to your buddies, etc. like, sure you could give it to a buddy and never claim it, but that just seems less fun and kind of lame. I dunno, I just don't think it's smart to create dichotomies based on how "optimal" play would be.
Sure, you could simplify it like that. But the timing is worth noting. It looked like Terry wanted to claim before someone used the shot on him. I mean, if you thought MY claim was random, this goes way beyond that. It felt almost like a nervous claim, especially after I noted that his attempt to clear me (and someone else, can't remember) for using Town Vanilla instead of Vanilla Town made it appear as if he was not actually VT but a PR (or scum). This should not have been an issue if AG is on the same alignment as Terry.
I'm too lazy to read back a page. What are your thoughts on Terry?
...
Eh, I don't need an answer, I feel like I know it anyway. In case I die, be very, very wary of shadow.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
When the point of no return appears, it is already behind you.
Also, based on the fact Terry claimed vanilla, I don't think AG is scum (or more accurately, aligned with him). AG could give the shot out to a buddy, or simply not give out the shot at all.
Just from a play style standpoint, there's plenty of reason to give the shot to town; proves your role, doesn't tie you to your buddies, etc. like, sure you could give it to a buddy and never claim it, but that just seems less fun and kind of lame. I dunno, I just don't think it's smart to create dichotomies based on how "optimal" play would be.
Sure, you could simplify it like that. But the timing is worth noting. It looked like Terry wanted to claim before someone used the shot on him. I mean, if you thought MY claim was random, this goes way beyond that. It felt almost like a nervous claim, especially after I noted that his attempt to clear me (and someone else, can't remember) for using Town Vanilla instead of Vanilla Town made it appear as if he was not actually VT but a PR (or scum). This should not have been an issue if AG is on the same alignment as Terry.
I'm too lazy to read back a page. What are your thoughts on Terry?
...
Eh, I don't need an answer, I feel like I know it anyway. In case I die, be very, very wary of shadow.
Excuse me?! Are you trying to throw shade at me, or just leverage my lynch if/when you don't die ("Scum!shadow couldn't kill me after that list, cause it incriminates him")?
Also, based on the fact Terry claimed vanilla, I don't think AG is scum (or more accurately, aligned with him). AG could give the shot out to a buddy, or simply not give out the shot at all.
Just from a play style standpoint, there's plenty of reason to give the shot to town; proves your role, doesn't tie you to your buddies, etc. like, sure you could give it to a buddy and never claim it, but that just seems less fun and kind of lame. I dunno, I just don't think it's smart to create dichotomies based on how "optimal" play would be.
Sure, you could simplify it like that. But the timing is worth noting. It looked like Terry wanted to claim before someone used the shot on him. I mean, if you thought MY claim was random, this goes way beyond that. It felt almost like a nervous claim, especially after I noted that his attempt to clear me (and someone else, can't remember) for using Town Vanilla instead of Vanilla Town made it appear as if he was not actually VT but a PR (or scum). This should not have been an issue if AG is on the same alignment as Terry.
I'm too lazy to read back a page. What are your thoughts on Terry?
...
Eh, I don't need an answer, I feel like I know it anyway. In case I die, be very, very wary of shadow.
Excuse me?! Are you trying to throw shade at me, or just leverage my lynch if/when you don't die ("Scum!shadow couldn't kill me after that list, cause it incriminates him")?
I do not like this post, not one bit.
No, I'm saying to be wary of you in case I'm not around to do it. That's why I said "in case" instead of "if"?
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
When the point of no return appears, it is already behind you.
Shadow, I'm not ever going to lynch you before final 3. If that loses me the game so be it, but unless you're alive then I'm not going to look into the option. I'm very aware you could have seriously pocketed me, but I've been trying to compare to Overwatch and I just don't think this is the same.
Also, based on the fact Terry claimed vanilla, I don't think AG is scum (or more accurately, aligned with him). AG could give the shot out to a buddy, or simply not give out the shot at all.
Just from a play style standpoint, there's plenty of reason to give the shot to town; proves your role, doesn't tie you to your buddies, etc. like, sure you could give it to a buddy and never claim it, but that just seems less fun and kind of lame. I dunno, I just don't think it's smart to create dichotomies based on how "optimal" play would be.
Sure, you could simplify it like that. But the timing is worth noting. It looked like Terry wanted to claim before someone used the shot on him. I mean, if you thought MY claim was random, this goes way beyond that. It felt almost like a nervous claim, especially after I noted that his attempt to clear me (and someone else, can't remember) for using Town Vanilla instead of Vanilla Town made it appear as if he was not actually VT but a PR (or scum). This should not have been an issue if AG is on the same alignment as Terry.
I'm too lazy to read back a page. What are your thoughts on Terry?
...
Eh, I don't need an answer, I feel like I know it anyway. In case I die, be very, very wary of shadow.
Excuse me?! Are you trying to throw shade at me, or just leverage my lynch if/when you don't die ("Scum!shadow couldn't kill me after that list, cause it incriminates him")?
I do not like this post, not one bit.
No, I'm saying to be wary of you in case I'm not around to do it. That's why I said "in case" instead of "if"?
I just...it seems like you created a no win scenario for me by casting ethereal suspicion on me due to WIFOM.
I just...it seems like you created a no win scenario for me by casting ethereal suspicion on me due to WIFOM.
People would have to be crazy or scum to use that alone against you. I sometimes say it hoping it'd allow me to survive the night, sadly doesn't always work.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
When the point of no return appears, it is already behind you.
I know it's only been a couple hours, but the lack of hardly post hammer is definitely telling. We got one Boyz!
I'm going to bring this up because it bothers me now more than ever. Why exactly would the lack of posts mean we got scum? That is the weirdest conclusion to come to. Right now, this post seems to me to serve one purpose: to make you look town by being dead wrong.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
When the point of no return appears, it is already behind you.
Shadow, I'm not ever going to lynch you before final 3. If that loses me the game so be it, but unless you're alive then I'm not going to look into the option. I'm very aware you could have seriously pocketed me, but I've been trying to compare to Overwatch and I just don't think this is the same.
I appreciate that, and I hope if it does come down to it, we can have a glorious mindmeld and win.
I just...it seems like you created a no win scenario for me by casting ethereal suspicion on me due to WIFOM.
People would have to be crazy or scum to use that alone against you. I sometimes say it hoping it'd allow me to survive the night, sadly doesn't always work.
Fair enough, I concede that I may have overreacted, I just don't want to be the reason we lose.
I know it's only been a couple hours, but the lack of hardly post hammer is definitely telling. We got one Boyz!
I'm going to bring this up because it bothers me now more than ever. Why exactly would the lack of posts mean we got scum? That is the weirdest conclusion to come to. Right now, this post seems to me to serve one purpose: to make you look town by being dead wrong.
I had assumed that no posts meant that scum had shut up to avoid any spew, something I've seen before, and I was pretty darn happy because I actually got the person I'd suspected for days to be lynched.
I know it's only been a couple hours, but the lack of hardly post hammer is definitely telling. We got one Boyz!
I'm going to bring this up because it bothers me now more than ever. Why exactly would the lack of posts mean we got scum? That is the weirdest conclusion to come to. Right now, this post seems to me to serve one purpose: to make you look town by being dead wrong.
I had assumed that no posts meant that scum had shut up to avoid any spew, something I've seen before, and I was pretty darn happy because I actually got the person I'd suspected for days to be lynched.
But it could equally apply to a town being lynched? The reason I believed nobody talked was because aside from QH and EL, everyone thought/pretended that Shinichi was scum. There was nothing left to say, any resistance, any thought that might imply someone knew Shinichi's alignment before the flip would be incriminating.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
When the point of no return appears, it is already behind you.
I know it's only been a couple hours, but the lack of hardly post hammer is definitely telling. We got one Boyz!
I'm going to bring this up because it bothers me now more than ever. Why exactly would the lack of posts mean we got scum? That is the weirdest conclusion to come to. Right now, this post seems to me to serve one purpose: to make you look town by being dead wrong.
I had assumed that no posts meant that scum had shut up to avoid any spew, something I've seen before, and I was pretty darn happy because I actually got the person I'd suspected for days to be lynched.
But it could equally apply to a town being lynched? The reason I believed nobody talked was because aside from QH and EL, everyone thought/pretended that Shinichi was scum. There was nothing left to say, any resistance, any thought that might imply someone knew Shinichi's alignment before the flip would be incriminating.
People talk after a lynch, even a lynch that's been widely agreed upon, they just do. So when they didn't, it looked suspect, and I got excited.
I know it's only been a couple hours, but the lack of hardly post hammer is definitely telling. We got one Boyz!
I'm going to bring this up because it bothers me now more than ever. Why exactly would the lack of posts mean we got scum? That is the weirdest conclusion to come to. Right now, this post seems to me to serve one purpose: to make you look town by being dead wrong.
I had assumed that no posts meant that scum had shut up to avoid any spew, something I've seen before, and I was pretty darn happy because I actually got the person I'd suspected for days to be lynched.
But it could equally apply to a town being lynched? The reason I believed nobody talked was because aside from QH and EL, everyone thought/pretended that Shinichi was scum. There was nothing left to say, any resistance, any thought that might imply someone knew Shinichi's alignment before the flip would be incriminating.
People talk after a lynch, even a lynch that's been widely agreed upon, they just do. So when they didn't, it looked suspect, and I got excited.
Interesting. An ongoing game I'm in would suggest otherwise.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
When the point of no return appears, it is already behind you.
I'm going to bring this up because it bothers me now more than ever. Why exactly would the lack of posts mean we got scum? That is the weirdest conclusion to come to. Right now, this post seems to me to serve one purpose: to make you look town by being dead wrong.
I had assumed that no posts meant that scum had shut up to avoid any spew, something I've seen before, and I was pretty darn happy because I actually got the person I'd suspected for days to be lynched.
But it could equally apply to a town being lynched? The reason I believed nobody talked was because aside from QH and EL, everyone thought/pretended that Shinichi was scum. There was nothing left to say, any resistance, any thought that might imply someone knew Shinichi's alignment before the flip would be incriminating.
People talk after a lynch, even a lynch that's been widely agreed upon, they just do. So when they didn't, it looked suspect, and I got excited.
Interesting. An ongoing game I'm in would suggest otherwise.
1. Don't reference ongoing games
2. And? This isn't like a unchanging rule, it's a trend I've noticed.
I have to hop off for a bit, if you have any more questions let me know, I'll try and answer them before eod. I was going to offer to give the answers to my chat partner for night in case I died, but if I die then you won't really need them
#2364 - How did you come to that conclusion? I'm saying you and Proph are scumbuddies. Not you and Grape.
But you're also saying that EL and Proph are scum buddies and I think if anything is abundantly clear in this game it should be that EL and I are not scum buddies, so that makes what you're suggesting nearly impossible and the reason why I was confused.
Also, based on the fact Terry claimed vanilla, I don't think AG is scum (or more accurately, aligned with him). AG could give the shot out to a buddy, or simply not give out the shot at all.
Because you're assuming I'm scum? I'm pretty sure I've been advocating an AG Lynch longer than most.
This no lynch hammer before we get replacements really sucks.
I'm sorry about that, I really didn't intend to hammer that. I was for it and thought that if we no lynched it wouldn't be a huge deal because I think not was the right play for today and might save Cantrip looking for a replacement for EL, because I really see no way he is not town. The only reason he was alive was to fight with me, who should have been just as obvious town. No way scum kills either of us while we were fighting like that especially after EL demonstrated his ability to lead a mislynch. I won't be killed tonight because it's very clear that at least one person on the scum team is angling for my Lynch already. I'm not sure who is the scum doing that and who are the town sheep, but it's happening, which is why I full claimed. I felt like it explained a lot of my play this game and was not random as RE implied because as soon as I suggested Grape was fake-claiming I saw the tide turn against me. If you actually bothered to read my explanation you would see why I made it sound like I did. To suggest I"m scum buddies with AG is really far fetched. Not as far fetch as it would be to suggest I'm buddies with EL or you, but still pretty far fetched.
This no lynch hammer before we get replacements really sucks.
I'm sorry about that, I really didn't intend to hammer that. I was for it and thought that if we no lynched it wouldn't be a huge deal because I think not was the right play for today and might save Cantrip looking for a replacement for EL, because I really see no way he is not town. The only reason he was alive was to fight with me, who should have been just as obvious town. No way scum kills either of us while we were fighting like that especially after EL demonstrated his ability to lead a mislynch. I won't be killed tonight because it's very clear that at least one person on the scum team is angling for my Lynch already. I'm not sure who is the scum doing that and who are the town sheep, but it's happening, which is why I full claimed. I felt like it explained a lot of my play this game and was not random as RE implied because as soon as I suggested Grape was fake-claiming I saw the tide turn against me. If you actually bothered to read my explanation you would see why I made it sound like I did. To suggest I"m scum buddies with AG is really far fetched. Not as far fetch as it would be to suggest I'm buddies with EL or you, but still pretty far fetched.
Whoops, I just realized I forget to clarify that I was responding to RE in the second half of that post. God, that makes that post confusing. Here's an EBWOP:
I'm sorry about that, I really didn't intend to hammer that. I was for it and thought that if we no lynched it wouldn't be a huge deal because I think not was the right play for today and might save Cantrip looking for a replacement for EL, because I really see no way he is not town. The only reason he was alive was to fight with me, who should have been just as obvious town. No way scum kills either of us while we were fighting like that especially after EL demonstrated his ability to lead a mislynch. I won't be killed tonight because it's very clear that at least one person on the scum team is angling for my Lynch already. I'm not sure who is the scum doing that and who are the town sheep, but it's happening, which is why I full claimed. I felt like it explained a lot of my play this game and was not random as RE implied because as soon as I suggested Grape was fake-claiming I saw the tide turn against me.
@RE #2366: If you actually bothered to read my explanation you would see why I made it sound like I did. To suggest I"m scum buddies with AG is really far fetched. Not as far fetch as it would be to suggest I'm buddies with EL or you, but still pretty far fetched.
Hi, am here, apologies for not posting near EoD Yesterday.
Going to catch up the past couple of pages and try to do a full thread reread since we are in lylo. Feel free to @ me if you need to me answer any pressing questions.
So I was LnGrrrR's target for the vanilla cop last night, but I'm going to wait to reveal my target. Read into that what you will.
FoS: QH
I know you have a bit more time for this one now. Going to need to see it because I think you're scum just based on PoE. And that's before I get into the behavioral reasons.
I have thoughts in general but don't want to start sharing before I hear from others. People know where I stand and I don't want to lead the thread anymore right now.
Curious about people's thoughts on the fact that LnGrrrR and Shadow are both still alive.
Curious about people's thoughts on the fact that LnGrrrR and Shadow are both still alive.
LnGrrrR - the fact that their username contains "grrr" is frightening...
But they just replaced, I doubt they were going to be the target anyway. As for EL, well, a pity kill, perhaps. Comparing those two, EL was far less likely to ever be (mis)lynched in the future.
shadow is possibly/probably scum. JS.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
When the point of no return appears, it is already behind you.
I never looked deeply into it, tbh. I find the neighborizer role scummy enough on its own. Also, just thinking about it now, AG's role somewhat revolves around communication, too. And all are day shot abilities, so...
And oh my god I'm so dumb... If AG is scum, all he'll have to do is give his ability to his buddies... Or kill the person who receives the shot... Or both (claims he gave the shot to the person who dies but actually didn't.) But eh, maybe he's not actually scum.
3 overlapers? I know it's shadow and me? And who else?
Terry, you're digging your own grave. You're no longer scum hunting at this point, you're throwing shade.
Why are you so eager to dismiss JT as scum?
I can't agree or disagree with this. But I don't think for all these roles to be on the same alignment is an impossibility. If the person Shadow decides to chat with is either Proph or Grape, or if the person he does chat with dies, I will be very, very suspicious. But the same way I won't allow someone with a certain role to be cleared, I also won't allow them to be convicted of it. Of course, unless the claim is highly suspicious, but Grape's and shadow's are not (after I got over my initial paranoia).
#2364 - How did you come to that conclusion? I'm saying you and Proph are scumbuddies. Not you and Grape.
...
I'll use my second shot of paranoia, for funsies and it actually bugs me that we didn't lynch today. Erm, I kind of remember my friend telling me about the effed up thing that happened to Clarice at the end of the series. Well, that wasn't too related, but somehow I get the feeling Grape is survivor. /paranoia
Sure, you could simplify it like that. But the timing is worth noting. It looked like Terry wanted to claim before someone used the shot on him. I mean, if you thought MY claim was random, this goes way beyond that. It felt almost like a nervous claim, especially after I noted that his attempt to clear me (and someone else, can't remember) for using Town Vanilla instead of Vanilla Town made it appear as if he was not actually VT but a PR (or scum). This should not have been an issue if AG is on the same alignment as Terry.
I'm too lazy to read back a page. What are your thoughts on Terry?
...
Eh, I don't need an answer, I feel like I know it anyway. In case I die, be very, very wary of shadow.
People never learn (I include myself). It doesn't matter if we know who the scum are, if we can't vote properly, then town has basically lost.
I do not like this post, not one bit.
No, I'm saying to be wary of you in case I'm not around to do it. That's why I said "in case" instead of "if"?
1. Proph
2. Terry
It's just the third option is where I'm having the most difficulty. And I don't like that I'm stuck between QH and AG.
People would have to be crazy or scum to use that alone against you. I sometimes say it hoping it'd allow me to survive the night, sadly doesn't always work.
I'm going to bring this up because it bothers me now more than ever. Why exactly would the lack of posts mean we got scum? That is the weirdest conclusion to come to. Right now, this post seems to me to serve one purpose: to make you look town by being dead wrong.
But it could equally apply to a town being lynched? The reason I believed nobody talked was because aside from QH and EL, everyone thought/pretended that Shinichi was scum. There was nothing left to say, any resistance, any thought that might imply someone knew Shinichi's alignment before the flip would be incriminating.
Interesting. An ongoing game I'm in would suggest otherwise.
2. And? This isn't like a unchanging rule, it's a trend I've noticed.
Sorry, it was really tempting.
I'm sorry about that, I really didn't intend to hammer that. I was for it and thought that if we no lynched it wouldn't be a huge deal because I think not was the right play for today and might save Cantrip looking for a replacement for EL, because I really see no way he is not town. The only reason he was alive was to fight with me, who should have been just as obvious town. No way scum kills either of us while we were fighting like that especially after EL demonstrated his ability to lead a mislynch. I won't be killed tonight because it's very clear that at least one person on the scum team is angling for my Lynch already. I'm not sure who is the scum doing that and who are the town sheep, but it's happening, which is why I full claimed. I felt like it explained a lot of my play this game and was not random as RE implied because as soon as I suggested Grape was fake-claiming I saw the tide turn against me.
@RE #2366: If you actually bothered to read my explanation you would see why I made it sound like I did. To suggest I"m scum buddies with AG is really far fetched. Not as far fetch as it would be to suggest I'm buddies with EL or you, but still pretty far fetched.
End of Day 4 will occur shortly.
Deadline to submit Night actions is on Monday, August 21st, at 4pm, MDT.
My apologies for the delay.
Deadline is set for Monday, September 4th, at 9am MDT (slightly longer Day than rules indicate as I will be somewhat unavailable that weekend).
Please remember to check your PMs before posting in the thread, and let me know if there are any questions.
Going to catch up the past couple of pages and try to do a full thread reread since we are in lylo. Feel free to @ me if you need to me answer any pressing questions.
FoS: QH
I know you have a bit more time for this one now. Going to need to see it because I think you're scum just based on PoE. And that's before I get into the behavioral reasons.
I have thoughts in general but don't want to start sharing before I hear from others. People know where I stand and I don't want to lead the thread anymore right now.
Curious about people's thoughts on the fact that LnGrrrR and Shadow are both still alive.
LnGrrrR - the fact that their username contains "grrr" is frightening...
But they just replaced, I doubt they were going to be the target anyway. As for EL, well, a pity kill, perhaps. Comparing those two, EL was far less likely to ever be (mis)lynched in the future.
shadow is possibly/probably scum. JS.
RE, tell me why you don't like proph. He seemed pretty certain you were town yesterday. Are you bus bluffing right now?