Okay, off of a quick reread, I'm much more confident in a zomg lynch. He's spend a lot of time trying to get other people to comment on each other and "find the assassin" without committing to much.
Okay, off of a quick reread, I'm much more confident in a zomg lynch. He's spend a lot of time trying to get other people to comment on each other and "find the assassin" without committing to much.
Again? won't yall ever learn? lol.
Alot of my "without committing to much" is we are on page 3 in a 6 player game and there hasnt been alot of analyzing being done by anyone. I think Bur could be scum, but no one else is sticking out... maybe Az? Like most everything has been RVS/Fluff so far
I'm actually feeling like you are playing this game different, which is part of why I'm more confident. We will see though.
I don't believe you're stupid, far from it in fact. Obviously you're going to play differently, one game to another, but the differences I'm seeing feel more motive based, rather than style based.
Also, I've got stronger town reads from everyone else thus far, which I'll admit could be my mistake. I'm curious to see everyone else weigh in when they reread.
What bothers me the most is not what there is but what there isn't.
Like, I get this feeling that zomg isn't even on the same page as the rest of us and that unnerves me.
Vote: zomg
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from Prophylaxis »
Also modgaming Bur setups is kind of treading down a dark path
It's a terrible lynch. Don't know why it came up. Absolutely horrendous idea. Anyone voting for him should be counter-wagoned tomorrow. Vote Zomgarcwind
The assembled marshmallows and balloons debated long and hard which of them was the pointiest.
It's not clear why they all thought that mattered, but they rooted out the pointiest.
zomgarcwind was:
broom hatter, a guard
oh wait
thats not quite right...
oh well.
as the less pointy members of the party tore him broom from hat, one saw his opportunity and didn't hesitate. Azrael revealed himself to be:
Kirby, the assassin
Ophidia has died
He was:
Waddle Dee, a guard
The game is over. ShadowlancerX, king dedede has survived.
Also, in post 63, Vaimes claimed to be Noddy, and that was why I knew he was town, it was such a natural claim, and that much work for a secret claim was not something I would expect from town. My pointed comment at the top of page three about sleepiness was meant to draw out a reaction from Vaimes but totally didn't work
Bur's "Your vote saddens me the most" to shadow is why I started townreading him.
Biggest neon "I KNOW YOU'RE THE KING" sign ever.
Yup, I totally knew he was town, and I really thought I was gonna eat a bullet for that. Then Vaimes your reaction to my revoting you cemented your town status to me. It felt very "Hey, but can get the king to know his alignment but I can't?! What is this crap?"
I'm glad you went for Oph. I very specifically isn't interact with him at all, and everyone else Did the same.
There were a number of things like that Vaimes comment that I didn't put much stock in, because I figured people would be planting red herrings in that vein. So instead I looked for shared themes, like ignoring Oph, 'cause town wouldn't possibly be tricksy enough to each coordinate that kind of a false tell...
Flavor claims are not really something this setup can handle, and it probably needs to either be unique flavor every time or just generic role PMs
Vaimes didn't even claim but other guards could tell he wasnt the assassin and azrael knew he wasnt the king.
I didnt even think about a mass claim, thinking it just outs the king.
But, like, who is gonna CC the king?
So it's pretty gamebreaking with known flavor.
Okay, to be honest, I don't know what I should do here. With this setup, town has more info than scum, so it's not really a good idea to scumhunt. Especially if you genuinely suspect more than one person; the Assassin can probably deduce whether or not you're faking a scumread on the King, etc., etc. So like ??? what do.
I read the last game that just happened, and what sticks out to me the most is that Azrael posted a /lot/ more and was obviously trying to solve the game, while being fluffy and fun. I'd kill him for being boring here and not spamming it up and getting an infraction on behalf of the kingdom.
I don't think Ophidia is the Assassin, comparing his posts here to last game. I don't think shadow is the Assassin, he honestly seems to want to hear what I have to say. Bur is basically nonexistent ("What if I told you my vote on Vaimes was for srs?" -vanishes-). I have a reeeally weak townread on zomg for reasons I'm not going to discuss ever.
"But Vaimes, you're scumreading the people voting for you! Isn't that a scumtell?" Probably, but those are the reads I'm going with.
I thought Vaimes flavour claimed earlier, but since I couldn't pinpoint his claim, I kinda forgot it.
I see I was wrong about Az, but oh well. We still won.
I was really sure that Az had either figured out or knew the identity of our king due to his reaction to Oph's chainsaw vote (after Zomg voted shadow).
So, I thought that either Az is town or he's the assassin and we have already lost, so better just to think of him as town.
@Tom: I had really intricate plans for breaking the game with flavour claims, but none of them seemed to work perfectly so I abandoned those plans.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from Prophylaxis »
Also modgaming Bur setups is kind of treading down a dark path
If someone wants to run a third, I will /in in a heartbeat.
Otherwise I have a way stupider setup in the queue...
I'll Run it if i can give it a different theme? If thats cool with yall ill put a sign up post late tonight after my tourney
If you run it, make sure if someone rolls the same roll you just go with it rather then rerolling everyone. It would be too much of a giveaway if you don't
Let's not discuss this any further, mmk?
I'll wait for more people to lynch Az.
Even if I have to die first.
vote Zomgarcwind
Azrael (1) - vaimes
bur (1) - zomgarcwind
Zomgarcwind (2) - Ophidia, shadowlancerx
Vaimes (2) - bur, azrael
With 6 alive, its 4 to lynch
ophidia has been prodded
Was that bait for scum-Vaimes, or are we just picking names out of a hat at this point?
I think it would be safe to lynch anyone that claims king, as there is a great chance the assassin is among them.
I think that leaves us in that point where I need to take a closer look at zomg. I'll try to see what you saw there.
I lurk as both alignments.
I'm actually feeling like you are playing this game different, which is part of why I'm more confident. We will see though.
Also, I've got stronger town reads from everyone else thus far, which I'll admit could be my mistake. I'm curious to see everyone else weigh in when they reread.
What bothers me the most is not what there is but what there isn't.
Like, I get this feeling that zomg isn't even on the same page as the rest of us and that unnerves me.
Vote: zomg
Zomgarcwind (3) - Ophidia, shadowlancerx, bur (L-1)
Azrael (1) - vaimes
bur (1) - zomgarcwind
Vaimes (1) - azrael
With 6 alive, its 4 to lynch
Scene forthcoming.
It's not clear why they all thought that mattered, but they rooted out the pointiest.
zomgarcwind was:
oh wait
thats not quite right...
oh well.
as the less pointy members of the party tore him broom from hat, one saw his opportunity and didn't hesitate.
Azrael revealed himself to be:
Ophidia has died
He was:
The game is over.
ShadowlancerX, king dedede has survived.
Biggest neon "I KNOW YOU'RE THE KING" sign ever.
Yes you did. To be fair, he would have been my second lynch
GG. Ruled out everyone aside from you and Oph, and figured it'd be much more fun to take another shot at winning on D1.
Yup, I totally knew he was town, and I really thought I was gonna eat a bullet for that. Then Vaimes your reaction to my revoting you cemented your town status to me. It felt very "Hey, but can get the king to know his alignment but I can't?! What is this crap?"
I'm glad you went for Oph. I very specifically isn't interact with him at all, and everyone else Did the same.
I got your back V
There were a number of things like that Vaimes comment that I didn't put much stock in, because I figured people would be planting red herrings in that vein. So instead I looked for shared themes, like ignoring Oph, 'cause town wouldn't possibly be tricksy enough to each coordinate that kind of a false tell...
Vaimes didn't even claim but other guards could tell he wasnt the assassin and azrael knew he wasnt the king.
I didnt even think about a mass claim, thinking it just outs the king.
But, like, who is gonna CC the king?
So it's pretty gamebreaking with known flavor.
Not even post game?
I dunno, it felt very distinct from Az's vote on shadow. zomg's was more natural and carefree, Az's was stilted and trying too hard to be breezy.
Obviously I wasn't gonna say anything about the King during the game.
I thought Vaimes flavour claimed earlier, but since I couldn't pinpoint his claim, I kinda forgot it.
I see I was wrong about Az, but oh well. We still won.
I was really sure that Az had either figured out or knew the identity of our king due to his reaction to Oph's chainsaw vote (after Zomg voted shadow).
So, I thought that either Az is town or he's the assassin and we have already lost, so better just to think of him as town.
@Tom: I had really intricate plans for breaking the game with flavour claims, but none of them seemed to work perfectly so I abandoned those plans.
@tom I'm definitely /in if there is a third game (though hopefully someone else can run it so you can play)
Otherwise I have a way stupider setup in the queue...
Unreliable cops looks even nuttier than this.
If you run it, make sure if someone rolls the same roll you just go with it rather then rerolling everyone. It would be too much of a giveaway if you don't
I wondered
Tom didn't make one lol.