My thoughts are with the friends and family of the Orlando Shooting victims and with the rest of the LGBTQA+ community.
Check out my Newborder Peasant Cube here! http://www.cubetutor.com/draft/37467
Necarg, please don't acknowledge this in any way whatsoever.
True Name Mafia (Win),Clan Contest IX Mafia (Win), Bravely Default Mafia (Loss), BOTAS (loss), BfV (Loss), Ace Attourney (loss)
Rules Advisor before they were eradicated
Anyway, some reads.
Kpaca is doing... something? This is probably just his thing and I genuinely don't know what to think of it.
Bur seems town because he's scumhunting and acting like town should. I think he'd be good on the seat.
Void is less active than Bur, but I like him a bit more for the seat. It seems that when he does talk, he speaks pure wisdom.
Kami is a pretty null read from me.
Generic is a town read due to him doing good scumhunting. Other reads in a few hours.
Where did these other reads disappear to?
Following Generic’s logic here…
Seat Votes:
Generic voted for Bur
Rhand voted for Bur
Huntzilla voted for Bur
TappingStones voted for Bur
Bur voted for Bur (assumption)
Void voted for Void
Kami voted for Void
Necarg voted for Void
Kpaca voted for Kpaca
Tordeck voted for Tordeck
Last two remaining are Aquamisa and Stormblind (though Plowshares could have locked in the vote before Stormblind had a chance… theorhetically)
Which would mean that the vote would have been tied… For those not math savvy enough to figure out the oddity here.
How would a tie be decided?
I definitely concur with Generic that one of the lurkers is assuredly scum. I believe Stormblind is scum because of the odd entrance to the game and then lack of posts to follow.
Also, I am pretty sure it was a she if I remember correctly, Generic.
Sorry for disappearing a few days. I took on a last-minute 4 day guiding job and forgot to put myself on vl/a.
I'll be back to full activity day after tomorrow.
I'm liking Huntzilla as Scum after post#253. I do not like the biased approach towards the lurkers, Calls out Stormblind for the weird opening and lack of posting, but ignores Aquamisa who's RVS vote would be still be active if not for the votecount reset and has done nothing to progress the game forward with the entire three posts from Aquamisa.
I'm liking Huntzilla as Scum after post#253. I do not like the biased approach towards the lurkers, Calls out Stormblind for the weird opening and lack of posting, but ignores Aquamisa who's RVS vote would be still be active if not for the votecount reset and has done nothing to progress the game forward with the entire three posts from Aquamisa.
Aquamisa is new. Stormblind has played before. I gave the newer person the benefit of the doubt, held the veteran to a higher standard.
Leave me alone with those weak attacks. You can find better than that to press me on.
I am starting to really like the idea of using the seat as a second lynch.
@Hunt: You got called Scum because you choose to give out the benefit of the doubt without expressing it which read as a biased approach. Scum behavior is Scum behavior regardless of experience. You then discredit my claim by calling it a weak attack and now want to change your mind about using the Seat as a second lynch.
Rhand's vote feels like busing to me, that was a very easily recognized slip and he was just a little too quick to hop on the wagon after waiting for someone else to call out Hunt.
Gunna pull an Iso and make the call now, Hunt, TS, Rhand scum-team. GG
Now when Hunt flips scum, we need to lynch Rhand tom.
Rhand's vote feels like busing to me, that was a very easily recognized slip and he was just a little too quick to hop on the wagon after waiting for someone else to call out Hunt.
Gunna pull an Iso and make the call now, Hunt, TS, Rhand scum-team. GG
Now when Hunt flips scum, we need to lynch Rhand tom.
unvote, vote Huntzilla
Scumteam? I'm ok with a Rhand lynch. I also voted him and said his play is scummy. Saying we are scumteam is laughable.
Back from PAX, catching up.
TappingStones: "EBWODP" - edit by way of double post - because we're not allowed to edit posts, if you have a thought that occurs after posting, you double-post. TS is you. KA is me.
Rhand's vote feels like busing to me, that was a very easily recognized slip and he was just a little too quick to hop on the wagon after waiting for someone else to call out Hunt.
Gunna pull an Iso and make the call now, Hunt, TS, Rhand scum-team. GG
Now when Hunt flips scum, we need to lynch Rhand tom.
unvote, vote Huntzilla
You, sir, are scum. You are calling my vote bad for voting for a slip that you call a slip yourself and then proceed to vote Hunt for it too.
Your attempt to tie us together is laughable and a huge scumtell.
You, sir, are scum. You are calling my vote bad for voting for a slip that you call a slip yourself and then proceed to vote Hunt for it too.
Your attempt to tie us together is laughable and a huge scumtell.
Nice OMGUS post by Rhand. Just more fuel for the fire. Might as well give up now. If you aren't lynched toDay, you sure as hell will be Tomorrow.
Hunt is a good lynch. You would be a better one but no one else it seems wants to agree with me so I'll be patient and get you on Day 2 when the rest of the town wakes up.
You, sir, are scum. You are calling my vote bad for voting for a slip that you call a slip yourself and then proceed to vote Hunt for it too.
Your attempt to tie us together is laughable and a huge scumtell.
Nice OMGUS post by Rhand. Just more fuel for the fire. Might as well give up now. If you aren't lynched toDay, you sure as hell will be Tomorrow.
Hunt is a good lynch. You would be a better one but no one else it seems wants to agree with me so I'll be patient and get you on Day 2 when the rest of the town wakes up.
Again I draw your attention to how Kami started this game to how he is playing it now. Has been hiding, doing absolutely no hunting or pushing of anything since I questioned his motives with the questions... Bemoans the lack of activity over 4 days but in that same post does what exactly? A throwaway line about disliking tordecks post...
Kami is Mafia.
How did I start the game? Please back up your assertions with quotes.
[SEPPEL EDITED STUFF OUT HERE THAT WAS ACCIDENTALLY PASTED FROM A GAME IN PROGRESS]
#130 TS & Tordeck are scum. TS dropped a naked unvote instead of voting Tordeck with reasoning, then slyly tells Tordeck to shape up.
#131 Holy shirt KA nailed it.
Also Generic might be town for goading TS, but #137 gives me pause.
Rhand's #133 is innocent enough to absolve him, plus his other posts are great.
Kpaca is VT and I've played with him enough to know where his train of thought is going.
KA's #209 feels weird. "Wait. Rhand, didn't you just want to lynch me (via the seat) for "reaching" when I called kpaca out? Now you're calling kpaca out yourself? "
#218: A chronic replacer replaced a chronic replacer.
Kpaca's plan is solid, but he isn't a team player, and most likely would single-handedly lose the game for the town.
Necarg loves Void.
#235 & #236 is pure lol.
#253 Huntzilla: "How would a tie be decided?" Mod answers. Strong +town to Hunt.
#269 Disagree with Void's vote in Huntzilla.
#271 Nonono, Rhand, you know how Huntzilla operates.
OH I'VE BEEN REPLACED IN??? I STILL DON'T HAVE A ROLE PM.
#278 is amazing
#280 sllightly agree with Generic's scumread on KA.
I don't normally edit stuff out, but I'm going to do so here because it's content related to a completely different game (that I'm modding) and I still don't have my role PM so there's nothing suspicious about it.
I'm agreeing with Generic on his thoughts about Kami's questions.
Three players dying on Day/Night 1 would not be beneficial to the Town.
12 - 3 = 9 - 3 = 6
Math shows us that by the End of Night 2 that the Mafia could win if the Town is wrong with all their choices. Using the seat as a second lynch is not an option.
Rhand - One of the towniest people here. It could be because everyone is pooping on his wonderful posts, and that's giving him the fodder to be a good townie, but I think his respon
Kpaca - Hey look he's still around. He reads like a town Kpaca.
Huntzilla - I've never seen a scum Hunt. But he feels town here. Cop him if he lives to the late game, but don't lynch him.
LIKELY TOWN
Void - His posts may be awful, but I do see a logical progression. His hop off the Rhand wagon was good, but he chose a terrible person to hop onto. I'm not impressed. And the votes for him are curious.
MYSTERIES
Plowshares/Stormblind - Replace-out fodder. This spot is best killed or copped. Definitely not a town PR.
Generic - I've never been able to read him, thanks to his unique brain. He'll also bus mercilessly, even on D1, so cop him ASAP. I'd say kill, but when he's town, he's a benefit.
Necarg - Need to see more. He fooled me last game.
ON NOTICE
Bur - Why is he considered town? He's posting a ton more than I've ever seen him post. I feel like he's being self-conscious and trying to put in effort.
Tordeck - Hold off on him. If Tappingstones somehow flips town, then I have nothing on him. Even #235/#236 is typical town Tordeck behavior.
LYNCH PLS
KamikazeArchon - Clean out this trash. Everything Generic has said is true.
TappingStones - Hoe can anyone say he's playing like he was in CCM? His thoughts are so much more complete in that game, and they follow a logical course. He looks like he's scumhunting there, where here, he's an illogical mess.
...
So there's our two lynches for today. KA and TS. If you disagree, you'd better convince me otherwise. If you don't, then you agree with me.
And remember, you claim this was also a reaction test...
So you opened the game leading the discussion with questions that you claim were also designed to test the other members... Since then? My application of pressure followed by Rhand *****ting on your knee jerk analysis led to you not doing anything in the game to progress it.
So your attempt to escape the scum read with 'back up your assertion' was weak.
And remember, you claim this was also a reaction test...
So you opened the game leading the discussion with questions that you claim were also designed to test the other members... Since then? My application of pressure followed by Rhand *****ting on your knee jerk analysis led to you not doing anything in the game to progress it.
So your attempt to escape the scum read with 'back up your assertion' was weak.
Check out my Newborder Peasant Cube here! http://www.cubetutor.com/draft/37467
True Name Mafia (Win),Clan Contest IX Mafia (Win), Bravely Default Mafia (Loss), BOTAS (loss), BfV (Loss), Ace Attourney (loss)
Rules Advisor before they were eradicated
The Family
Where did these other reads disappear to?
Following Generic’s logic here…
Seat Votes:
Generic voted for Bur
Rhand voted for Bur
Huntzilla voted for Bur
TappingStones voted for Bur
Bur voted for Bur (assumption)
Void voted for Void
Kami voted for Void
Necarg voted for Void
Kpaca voted for Kpaca
Tordeck voted for Tordeck
Last two remaining are Aquamisa and Stormblind (though Plowshares could have locked in the vote before Stormblind had a chance… theorhetically)
Which would mean that the vote would have been tied… For those not math savvy enough to figure out the oddity here.
How would a tie be decided?
I definitely concur with Generic that one of the lurkers is assuredly scum. I believe Stormblind is scum because of the odd entrance to the game and then lack of posts to follow.
Also, I am pretty sure it was a she if I remember correctly, Generic.
In the event of a tie, the first person to received their max votes will win the seat.
Vote count will be posted tonight.
The GJ way path to no lynching:
(Kpaca, I'll get back to you tomorrow. Been bit busy last few days.)
Busy weekend. Be back Monday.
Tordeck (2): Rhand, Tappingstones
Rhand (2): Void, Tordeck
Not voting (8): Kpaca, Stormblind, Huntzilla, Bur, aquaumisa, KamikazeArchon, Generic, Necarg
With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch, and 6 to depose. The deadline ends in 25 days!
The GJ way path to no lynching:
I'll be back to full activity day after tomorrow.
The Family
If it's good for town then why are you worried about it?
Still nervous I see.
Don't worry I didn't forget about you.
The Family
Aquamisa is new. Stormblind has played before. I gave the newer person the benefit of the doubt, held the veteran to a higher standard.
Leave me alone with those weak attacks. You can find better than that to press me on.
I am starting to really like the idea of using the seat as a second lynch.
Vote: Huntzilla
Guilty mindset. He knows there's things he should be pressed on.
unvote, vote Huntzilla
Still ok with Tordeck too.
The GJ way path to no lynching:
Rhand's vote feels like busing to me, that was a very easily recognized slip and he was just a little too quick to hop on the wagon after waiting for someone else to call out Hunt.
Gunna pull an Iso and make the call now, Hunt, TS, Rhand scum-team. GG
Now when Hunt flips scum, we need to lynch Rhand tom.
unvote, vote Huntzilla
The Family
The Family
Scumteam? I'm ok with a Rhand lynch. I also voted him and said his play is scummy. Saying we are scumteam is laughable.
Could you decode the slang?
This is only my second mafia game (first "regular" game).
TappingStones: "EBWODP" - edit by way of double post - because we're not allowed to edit posts, if you have a thought that occurs after posting, you double-post. TS is you. KA is me.
You, sir, are scum. You are calling my vote bad for voting for a slip that you call a slip yourself and then proceed to vote Hunt for it too.
Your attempt to tie us together is laughable and a huge scumtell.
Dislike Tordeck's attempt to chain lynches from Hunt to Rhand.
Hunt is a good lynch. You would be a better one but no one else it seems wants to agree with me so I'll be patient and get you on Day 2 when the rest of the town wakes up.
The Family
Omgus? I've been calling you scum all game.
#130 TS & Tordeck are scum. TS dropped a naked unvote instead of voting Tordeck with reasoning, then slyly tells Tordeck to shape up.
#131 Holy shirt KA nailed it.
Also Generic might be town for goading TS, but #137 gives me pause.
Rhand's #133 is innocent enough to absolve him, plus his other posts are great.
Kpaca is VT and I've played with him enough to know where his train of thought is going.
KA's #209 feels weird. "Wait. Rhand, didn't you just want to lynch me (via the seat) for "reaching" when I called kpaca out? Now you're calling kpaca out yourself? "
#218: A chronic replacer replaced a chronic replacer.
Kpaca's plan is solid, but he isn't a team player, and most likely would single-handedly lose the game for the town.
Necarg loves Void.
#235 & #236 is pure lol.
#253 Huntzilla: "How would a tie be decided?" Mod answers. Strong +town to Hunt.
#269 Disagree with Void's vote in Huntzilla.
#271 Nonono, Rhand, you know how Huntzilla operates.
OH I'VE BEEN REPLACED IN??? I STILL DON'T HAVE A ROLE PM.
#278 is amazing
#280 sllightly agree with Generic's scumread on KA.
I guess this means I can quote stuff now
Rhand and hunt are absolutely awful choices.
I started reading in the middle of page 2, so I'm going to go back and read it now
I still don't even know my alignment so you're getting pure Seppel reads here.
I was typing in the same window
I don't normally edit stuff out, but I'm going to do so here because it's content related to a completely different game (that I'm modding) and I still don't have my role PM so there's nothing suspicious about it.
Ehh. Maybe they're not scum together?
Rhand - One of the towniest people here. It could be because everyone is pooping on his wonderful posts, and that's giving him the fodder to be a good townie, but I think his respon
Kpaca - Hey look he's still around. He reads like a town Kpaca.
Huntzilla - I've never seen a scum Hunt. But he feels town here. Cop him if he lives to the late game, but don't lynch him.
LIKELY TOWN
Void - His posts may be awful, but I do see a logical progression. His hop off the Rhand wagon was good, but he chose a terrible person to hop onto. I'm not impressed. And the votes for him are curious.
MYSTERIES
Plowshares/Stormblind - Replace-out fodder. This spot is best killed or copped. Definitely not a town PR.
Generic - I've never been able to read him, thanks to his unique brain. He'll also bus mercilessly, even on D1, so cop him ASAP. I'd say kill, but when he's town, he's a benefit.
Necarg - Need to see more. He fooled me last game.
ON NOTICE
Bur - Why is he considered town? He's posting a ton more than I've ever seen him post. I feel like he's being self-conscious and trying to put in effort.
Tordeck - Hold off on him. If Tappingstones somehow flips town, then I have nothing on him. Even #235/#236 is typical town Tordeck behavior.
LYNCH PLS
KamikazeArchon - Clean out this trash. Everything Generic has said is true.
TappingStones - Hoe can anyone say he's playing like he was in CCM? His thoughts are so much more complete in that game, and they follow a logical course. He looks like he's scumhunting there, where here, he's an illogical mess.
...
So there's our two lynches for today. KA and TS. If you disagree, you'd better convince me otherwise. If you don't, then you agree with me.
What do you think a reaction test is?
Seppel: I'd prefer Tordeck. TS is hard for me to evaluate due to newness. If not for that wildcard I would be solidly on board.
I have an ability that doesn't work if I'm on the throne. Nice balance there.