MTG Salvation

> Followed me into 2 mislynches
> Implying I was solely responsible for pg and LMD's lynches
> laugh.png

Unvote. Actually, there is something else we need to do first. Mass claim.

Forgotten One - Dr. Hicks - Vanilla Town
Tom - Dean of Pentacles - Vanilla Town
Iso - ??? - Bulletproof Town
Rhand - ???
IB - ???
Misting - ???
Proph - ???

Yeah I guess that's correct procedure at this point.

I'm ok with popcorn. Shall we start with Iso?

FO: show how Iso was behind the 2 mislynches please.

Also, I'm Ladislav Pelc.

Oh. Well I've already fullclaimed.

I'm ok with it at this point.

Also V/LA 4/3-4/6ish. Travelling to the Philippines and I won't have any access for a little while.

Quote from Rhand

FO: show how Iso was behind the 2 mislynches please.

You seriously can't go back and look at the two wagons yourself? He was on the PG wagon almost as soon as it started and he pot-shotted him several times while it developed. And the LMD lynch would never have happened without Iso's "counter-claim" and his being fully against a D2 mass-claim which could have potentially saved LMD (which we'll find out soon enough when we claim today).

Quote from Prophylaxis

@FO: Is there any reason that you left EtR off the list or did you simply forget?

I thought I had him on there


Forgotten One - Dr. Hicks - Vanilla Town
Tom - Dean of Pentacles - Vanilla Town
Iso - Ladislav Pelc - Bulletproof Town
Rhand - ???
IB - ???
Misting - ???
Proph - ???
Eron - ???

Are we just going to wait on IB to claim or do we want to pick someone else?

If IB's not around, I want Proph to claim.

Quote from Forgotten One

Quote from Rhand

FO: show how Iso was behind the 2 mislynches please.

You seriously can't go back and look at the two wagons yourself? He was on the PG wagon almost as soon as it started and he pot-shotted him several times while it developed. And the LMD lynch would never have happened without Iso's "counter-claim" and his being fully against a D2 mass-claim which could have potentially saved LMD (which we'll find out soon enough when we claim today).

Change all instances of Iso in this observation with Tom and it's still true.
Do you think they can be buddies?

Quote from Iso

If IB's not around, I want Proph to claim.

Proph already claimed.

I want him to claim again.

Quote from Rhand

Change all instances of Iso in this observation with Tom and it's still true.
Do you think they can be buddies?

That is a very real possibility that I have been contemplating since yesterday, but that would entail some huge amount of bussing if it were true.

There is also the possibility that Iso is indeed our third Town PR, in which case I would push for a Tom lynch. My vote for him at the end of Day 2 was not random...

The problem is that no matter how I try to construct a scum team, there are issues unless there is some bussing going on. This isn't entirely surprising, but its hard to really look at all the possibilities when there are so many and we don't even have a single dead Mafioso yet.

I think IB is the last scum since I haven't been quickhammered yet.

Current Mass-Claim status

Forgotten One - Dr. Hicks - Vanilla Town
Tom - Dean of Pentacles - Vanilla Town
Iso - Ladislav Pelc - Bulletproof Town
Proph - Dr. Dinwiddie AKA "The Bursar", Vanilla Town
Rhand - ???
IB - ???
Misting - ???
Eron - ???

I'd actually like to see Misting claim next.

Quote from Iso

I think IB is the last scum since I haven't been quickhammered yet.

You only have two votes on you right now (Proph and Tom) since I unvoted. And with 8 alive, its 5 to lynch. Not to mention, you might not be getting quickhammered because you are scum....

I thought I was at L-1 for some reason.

Just being silly + expressing my still-scum read of you.

Seeking replacement for IB. Will look into who needs prods later today

Since my V/LA is about to kick in, I'll claim.

I'm Ponder Stibbons, Vanilla Town. I had the highest test score ever and created the University computer called Hex.

See you all in a few days.

Also, don't lynch anyone until IB's replacement gets in here and does something.

Quote from EtR

Also, don't lynch anyone until IB's replacement gets in here and does something.

Should I go ahead and claim? Or wait for the replacement?

Current Mass-Claim status

Forgotten One - Dr. Hicks - Vanilla Town
Tom - Dean of Pentacles - Vanilla Town
Iso - Ladislav Pelc - Bulletproof Town
Proph - Dr. Dinwiddie AKA "The Bursar", Vanilla Town
Eron - Ponder Stibbons, Vanilla Town
Rhand - ???
IB - ???
Misting - ???

@Misting/Rhand: Just go ahead and claim next time you post.

I am Rincewind, Vanilla town.
I hardly have any magical ability and wear a hat that says "Wizzard". Once each night, I can cower in fear, which does nothing.

Horace, Town Vanilla. I am a philosopher who looks after/like a horse. Each night I can discuss the meaning of life with a horse.

Eron, Rhand, and Proph are you leaving out anything in your role? Be sure

Oh look. All VT claims.

Imagine that.

Quote from Tom

Eron, Rhand, and Proph are you leaving out anything in your role? Be sure

What on earth could you possibly mean by this? Why did you leave me out?

I'll tell you later

I hope you understand that if you claim anything other than VT at this point that you're going to be lynched for lying at L-2.

Are you talking to me?

Also, lying isn't always a bad thing. If I claimed doc then 'lynching me for lying' would be stupiddumb.

In fact Iso that sounds a lot like a scheme of 'so guys if there is another PR that lied earlier, you should lynch him instead of me (the PR that makes the least sense of the 4, or rather the 2 alive)'

Yes, I'm talking to you.

No, it's not always a bad thing. But lying at L-2 is almost always lynchworthy - see Avatar: The Legend of Aang Mafia for why.

And if you didn't claim Doc at L-2 initially I'd ask you to get lynched anyway.

Quote from Tom

In fact Iso that sounds a lot like a scheme of 'so guys if there is another PR that lied earlier, you should lynch him instead of me (the PR that makes the least sense of the 4, or rather the 2 alive)'

Funny, it sounds a lot to me like you're looking to see if IB's replacement will claim a 4th PR and, if not, you're going to lie about your role to get me lynched - which you appear to already be making excuses for.

Quote from Tom

I'll tell you later

I wonder if we'll have to wait for this like we're still waiting for your day 1 mistake.

If I am right about what you are 'missing' in our claims, then you should read my claim again.

As of this post, Stormblind replaces infectiousbaloth.

Hay Stormy. We're doing a massclaim and waiting on you to finish it. Also FO and Proph are scum.

Quote from Iso

Hay Stormy. We're doing a massclaim and waiting on you to finish it. Also FO Tom and Proph are scum.

Fixed.

Quote from Iso

Quote from Tom

In fact Iso that sounds a lot like a scheme of 'so guys if there is another PR that lied earlier, you should lynch him instead of me (the PR that makes the least sense of the 4, or rather the 2 alive)'

Funny, it sounds a lot to me like you're looking to see if IB's replacement will claim a 4th PR and, if not, you're going to lie about your role to get me lynched - which you appear to already be making excuses for.

Well rest assured because I'm vanilla town and not lying.

Quote from Rhand

Quote from Tom

I'll tell you later

I wonder if we'll have to wait for this like we're still waiting for your day 1 mistake.

If I am right about what you are 'missing' in our claims, then you should read my claim again.

If you could just give me a simple answer now without further enquiries, once I get similar answers from the other two players I asked I'll explain everything (yes even the mistake) and it should all make sense. K?

Quote from Forgotten One

Quote from Iso

Hay Stormy. We're doing a massclaim and waiting on you to finish it. Also FO Tom and Proph are scum.

Fixed.

Just to get this straight, Iso wants you dead but not me (as far as I know), I want Iso dead but not you, and you want both of us dead?

Quote from Tom

Quote from Iso

Quote from Tom

In fact Iso that sounds a lot like a scheme of 'so guys if there is another PR that lied earlier, you should lynch him instead of me (the PR that makes the least sense of the 4, or rather the 2 alive)'

Funny, it sounds a lot to me like you're looking to see if IB's replacement will claim a 4th PR and, if not, you're going to lie about your role to get me lynched - which you appear to already be making excuses for.

Well rest assured because I'm vanilla town and not lying.

Quote from Tom »

Quote from Forgotten One

Quote from Iso

Hay Stormy. We're doing a massclaim and waiting on you to finish it. Also FO Tom and Proph are scum.

Fixed.

Just to get this straight, Iso wants you dead but not me (as far as I know), I want Iso dead but not you, and you want both of us dead?

FO wants everyone dead. Remember all of his posts from yesterDay I quoted?

Quote from Tom

Just to get this straight, Iso wants you dead but not me (as far as I know), I want Iso dead but not you, and you want both of us dead?

@FO, what I'm really asking here is: You think I'm trying to buddy with you while also gunning for my scumbuddy's death? After all that **** day 1 you think I'm scum buddies with Iso?

Quote from Iso

FO wants everyone dead. Remember all of his posts from yesterDay I quoted?

If they hand out LVP awards, you are getting two. If you really are Town, start paying attention and try acting like one.

Quote from Tom

Quote from Tom

Just to get this straight, Iso wants you dead but not me (as far as I know), I want Iso dead but not you, and you want both of us dead?

@FO, what I'm really asking here is: You think I'm trying to buddy with you while also gunning for my scumbuddy's death? After all that **** day 1 you think I'm scum buddies with Iso?

No, I no longer want Iso dead because there is a good chance that he is our 3rd power role. If Iso had let us mass-claim yesterday, we could have detemined that before mislynching LMD and we could have lynched you yesterday. All that **** on Day 1 between you and Iso could be bussing as far as I know, but it makes sense that it isn't. You are scum, Proph is scum, and I'm fairly sure I know who the third scum is as well. We just need to get Stormblind in here to complete the mass-claim so we can run you up.

Still catching up as last night was my son's birthday; and I only JUST got the replacement message. Bit in the interests of allowing the game to continue, I'll shoot off my claim.

Professor H. Collabone, AKA Dragonbreath. Townie Halitosis Sufferer. Each night I can continue my research into Shellfish in the hopes of finding a cure for my beastly Halitosis. I am told by the mod that the research has no effect.